Oppose the planned changes in the Swiss train network connecting Geneva
Dear Federal Councillor Albert Rösti, dear SBB CEO Vincent Ducrot,
We - international servants at different international organisations and expats in Geneva - are concerned and worried by the planned changes in the Swiss railway network. In our daily work and lives, we rely on efficient means of transportation including the Swiss railway. We are convinced that SBB CFF FFS is one of the most reliable railway companies in the world. Many of us actively choose trains as the preferred means of transportation for both time-efficiency and ecological reasons.
We recently learned through the Press release in May 2023 about the timetable change planned for 2025. We are deeply concerned and worried about the changes affecting the connections to Geneva - the second largest city in Switzerland. The planned suppression of the IC5 connection to Geneva has several severe implications for us:
- It will be more difficult to reach Germany and France through Basel. At present the German railway offers direct trains from Basel to Frankfurt, Hamburg and Berlin, the French railway direct trains from Basel to Strasbourg. On the contrary, to reach Basel from Geneva, a much shorter distance, two changes (in Biel and Renens) will be needed in the future. This is the second time that the quality of the connection between Geneva and Basel declines: in 2015 the direct connection between Geneva and Basel was removed.
- The planned changes imply a 50% reduction of direct connections between Geneva airport and Zürich airport. As international servants, a decent amount of us up until today heavily relies on air travel in our daily work and we are worried that the Zürich airport hub becomes less accessible from Geneva.
- With the existing rail network and the trains available, SBB CFF FFS currently has the potential to replace the air travel connection between Geneva and Zürich entirely. The planned changes have the opposite effect. This is not in line with the global effort of CO2 reduction.
- With the intended plans, there would be no direct connection to Yverdon, Neuchatel and Biel available anymore. This makes the train more unattractive and business and private travellers will likely choose the car as the preferred means of transportation.
One may argue that one additional change of train as the plan foresees does not make a large difference. But we believe it does. On the one hand, currently, the business zone coaches allow excellent working conditions if one is not interrupted. Needing to change the train frequently does not allow for efficient working and makes the train unattractive. On the other hand, many of us have their origin in other countries and frequently travel there with their families or are visited by relatives. Keeping in mind the inclusiveness of train travels, specifically for families with children or with senior people, it is very unpractical to change the train many times, as for instance twice within less than 3 hours between Geneva to Basel.
For these reasons, we urge you to reconsider your stance on the plans of scheduling for 2025:
- Keep the direct connection from Geneva to Yverdon, Neuchatel and Biel.
- Reinstate a direct connection between Geneva and Basel, connecting the second and third largest city of Switzerland at least a few times per day.
- Keep two direct trains per hour connecting Geneva and Zurich, the two largest cities in Switzerland.
Links:
- Press release SBB (German): https://news.sbb.ch/medien/artikel/122773/neugestaltung-des-sbb-fahrplans-in-der-westschweiz-ab-2025
- Press release SBB (French): https://news.sbb.ch/fr/medias/article/122773/refonte-de-l-horaire-cff-en-suisse-occidentale-des-2025
This petition will be sent as letter to the recipients above with the signatures of those appearing in the online signature list. If you would like to sign without disclosing your name, please uncheck the box "show my name in the online signature list".
(Train image courtesy of Ricard Codina under Create Commons license BY-NC-SA 2.0)
Updates
June 20, 2023
We just hit 250 signatures and I am honestly stunned by how many of you value these train routes as much as I do. My daily commute feels a little less lonely knowing that so many people are ready to fight for a connected Geneva.
Reached 250 supporters
June 19, 2023
June 18, 2023
I take this connection to Basel every week to see my family and these planned cuts would completely break my commute. We are getting very close to 250 signatures today so please send this link to your colleagues who rely on these trains to ensure our protest reaches the board.
Reached 100 supporters
June 9, 2023
June 7, 2023
My commute depends on these connections and seeing this support grow reminds me I am not alone in this fight. We need to push harder to hit that first hundred mark before the SBB officials look our way.
36 Comments
Commuting between GVA and ZRH every week, the suppression of this connection will highly affect my ability to strike a healthy balance between family life and duties at work.
Visiting my family members in Germany and receiving visits from them will be difficult with multiple train changes required, especially when travelling with children or for elderly persons who cannot carry their luggage as easily.
I may add that also the direct service Geneva-Milan continues to deteriorate both in frequency and duration. The trains are often fully booked - more connections are required, not less
I am planning to use the train from Germany to Geneva for my trips to CERN because of the climate change. It would be making my train travel much more complicated. You should encourage train travel and not hinder it.
The CFF plans sum up to decouple Geneva, Switzerland's second largest city and a pole of the Arc Lemanique economical powerhouse from the other economical hub of the country, between Basel and Zürich.
Also the direct connection from Geneva to Bern now is affected, which has been the alternative for going to Basel, for those who get sick on tilting trains. Reaching Geneva by train from Germany is now becoming really inconvenient, not to mention the ecological implications if more people again use cars or flights. This is really the opposite of what should be the future.
Trains help to reduce traffic pollution, so please add direct connections to/from Geneva instead of cancelling them.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Copy link or share directly
Oppose the planned changes in the Swiss train network connecting Geneva
Dear Federal Councillor Albert Rösti, dear SBB CEO Vincent Ducrot,
We - international servants at different international organisations and expats in Geneva - are concerned and worried by the planned changes in the Swiss railway network. In our daily work and lives, we rely on efficient means of transportation including the Swiss railway. We are convinced that SBB CFF FFS is one of the most reliable railway companies in the world. Many of us actively choose trains as the preferred means of transportation for both time-efficiency and ecological reasons.
We recently learned through the Press release in May 2023 about the timetable change planned for 2025. We are deeply concerned and worried about the changes affecting the connections to Geneva - the second largest city in Switzerland. The planned suppression of the IC5 connection to Geneva has several severe implications for us:
- It will be more difficult to reach Germany and France through Basel. At present the German railway offers direct trains from Basel to Frankfurt, Hamburg and Berlin, the French railway direct trains from Basel to Strasbourg. On the contrary, to reach Basel from Geneva, a much shorter distance, two changes (in Biel and Renens) will be needed in the future. This is the second time that the quality of the connection between Geneva and Basel declines: in 2015 the direct connection between Geneva and Basel was removed.
- The planned changes imply a 50% reduction of direct connections between Geneva airport and Zürich airport. As international servants, a decent amount of us up until today heavily relies on air travel in our daily work and we are worried that the Zürich airport hub becomes less accessible from Geneva.
- With the existing rail network and the trains available, SBB CFF FFS currently has the potential to replace the air travel connection between Geneva and Zürich entirely. The planned changes have the opposite effect. This is not in line with the global effort of CO2 reduction.
- With the intended plans, there would be no direct connection to Yverdon, Neuchatel and Biel available anymore. This makes the train more unattractive and business and private travellers will likely choose the car as the preferred means of transportation.
One may argue that one additional change of train as the plan foresees does not make a large difference. But we believe it does. On the one hand, currently, the business zone coaches allow excellent working conditions if one is not interrupted. Needing to change the train frequently does not allow for efficient working and makes the train unattractive. On the other hand, many of us have their origin in other countries and frequently travel there with their families or are visited by relatives. Keeping in mind the inclusiveness of train travels, specifically for families with children or with senior people, it is very unpractical to change the train many times, as for instance twice within less than 3 hours between Geneva to Basel.
For these reasons, we urge you to reconsider your stance on the plans of scheduling for 2025:
- Keep the direct connection from Geneva to Yverdon, Neuchatel and Biel.
- Reinstate a direct connection between Geneva and Basel, connecting the second and third largest city of Switzerland at least a few times per day.
- Keep two direct trains per hour connecting Geneva and Zurich, the two largest cities in Switzerland.
Links:
- Press release SBB (German): https://news.sbb.ch/medien/artikel/122773/neugestaltung-des-sbb-fahrplans-in-der-westschweiz-ab-2025
- Press release SBB (French): https://news.sbb.ch/fr/medias/article/122773/refonte-de-l-horaire-cff-en-suisse-occidentale-des-2025
This petition will be sent as letter to the recipients above with the signatures of those appearing in the online signature list. If you would like to sign without disclosing your name, please uncheck the box "show my name in the online signature list".
(Train image courtesy of Ricard Codina under Create Commons license BY-NC-SA 2.0)
Updates
June 20, 2023
We just hit 250 signatures and I am honestly stunned by how many of you value these train routes as much as I do. My daily commute feels a little less lonely knowing that so many people are ready to fight for a connected Geneva.
Reached 250 supporters
June 19, 2023
June 18, 2023
I take this connection to Basel every week to see my family and these planned cuts would completely break my commute. We are getting very close to 250 signatures today so please send this link to your colleagues who rely on these trains to ensure our protest reaches the board.
Reached 100 supporters
June 9, 2023
June 7, 2023
My commute depends on these connections and seeing this support grow reminds me I am not alone in this fight. We need to push harder to hit that first hundred mark before the SBB officials look our way.
36 Comments
This new schedule is super annoying. Two changes to Basel are maing this trip way less enjoyable. You can't work properly in the train anymore. On top of this, the Renens changes sometimes have 15min change times, or if it is only 5min you have to change platforms, which is super stressful
Commuting between GVA and ZRH every week, the suppression of this connection will highly affect my ability to strike a healthy balance between family life and duties at work.
Visiting my family members in Germany and receiving visits from them will be difficult with multiple train changes required, especially when travelling with children or for elderly persons who cannot carry their luggage as easily.
I may add that also the direct service Geneva-Milan continues to deteriorate both in frequency and duration. The trains are often fully booked - more connections are required, not less
I am planning to use the train from Germany to Geneva for my trips to CERN because of the climate change. It would be making my train travel much more complicated. You should encourage train travel and not hinder it.
The CFF plans sum up to decouple Geneva, Switzerland's second largest city and a pole of the Arc Lemanique economical powerhouse from the other economical hub of the country, between Basel and Zürich.
Also the direct connection from Geneva to Bern now is affected, which has been the alternative for going to Basel, for those who get sick on tilting trains. Reaching Geneva by train from Germany is now becoming really inconvenient, not to mention the ecological implications if more people again use cars or flights. This is really the opposite of what should be the future.
Trains help to reduce traffic pollution, so please add direct connections to/from Geneva instead of cancelling them.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach 500 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via .
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
This new schedule is super annoying. Two changes to Basel are maing this trip way less enjoyable. You can't work properly in the train anymore. On top of this, the Renens changes sometimes have 15min change times, or if it is only 5min you have to change platforms, which is super stressful