Skip to main content

THE KILTS ARE STAYING AT CARDINAL CARTER!! WE WON THIS FIGHT AND PROVED THAT OUR TRADITION IS WORTH DEFENDING!! THANK YOU TO THE 1,190 OF YOU WHO REFUSED TO BACK DOWN DURING THIS PROCESS!! STAY VIGILANT AS WE MOVE FORWARD TO ENSURE THIS VICTORY STICKS FOREVER!!

April 8, 2021

Keep the kilts at Cardinal Carter Academy for the Arts

Keep the kilts at Cardinal Carter Academy for the Arts

🏆 Won — 1,146 supporters Verified

Final supporters

J
Jessica
J
James
M
Maya
S
Sheree A.
S
Someone
I
Ivy P.
S
Someone
S
Someone
J
Jen L.
L
Lauren
+1,136 more
SC
Started by Simona Carnevale 9 years, 6 months ago

Dear students, parents, teachers etc of Cardinal Carter Academy for the Arts,

By now we all know that in recent years there has been an emphasis on proper uniform policies, especially those concerning the kilt. It's no surprise that the majority of students are against the recent announcement of a kilt ban beginning in September 2017. However it does come as a surprise to most students that the alleged banning of our kilt is an infringement on the Parent and Student Charter of Rights. We ask you to please read the following explanation, it may be long but it has very important information regarding the "kilt ban". After reading we ask you to please sign this petition in support of our case. As of March 23, 2017, the Toronto Catholic District School Board has been informed and an email was sent outlining our issues with the handling of our uniform in accordance with board policies. Thank you to everyone for your continued by support!

In July of 2016 when students' report cards were sent home a letter stating that the kilt would only be around for a limited time was sent with it. Again in student agendas at the beginning of the year under the school uniform section on page 26 it is stated in bold; "We are currently in the consultation phase of the elimination of the Girls' Kilt. Please be aware that if you purchase a kilt, it will be allowed only for a limited time." As well throughout the year parents, students and staff have been told multiple times that the kilt will be gone beginning September 2017.

However, I am here to inform you that this cannot be the case. The following quote is taken directly from the Toronto Catholic District School Board's Policies under Local Dress Code Requirements section E: Approval Process for Establishing or Changing the Local Dress Code, it clearly states the requirements in changing the uniform at a secondary school.

"Should an elementary school wish to establish a Uniform Dress Code, or a secondary school wish to change their current Uniform Dress Code, the following approval process will apply:

  • each school will develop and distribute an action plan, including a communication strategy and voting process (see below) to determine what the Local Dress Code should be for their own school (suggested by December of the school year preceding implementation)
  • have a community meeting at least two weeks prior to voting
  • Catholic School Advisory Council ("CSAC") must be involved in the development and implementation of this action plan

The approval process shall:

  • provide a vote every five years to be initiated by the principal in consultation with the CSAC
  • clearly establish which parents or students are eligible to vote
  • ensure that a minimum of 70% of the eligible respondents have cast a vote
  • not include proxy voting
  • ballots must include a description and costs associated with the proposed Dress Code and a line each for the name and grade of the student, and family surname
  • not be considered valid unless the votes are signed
  • be completed by February for successful implementation in the following school year and include families registered at the school for September of next school year

Secondary:

  • Entitle each family to one vote per student registered in the school (excluding the grade 12 students)
  • At least 80% support of those eligible to vote is required to determine whether the Local Dress Code will change from the current Uniform Dress Code to an alternate Uniform Dress Code
  • Failing the 80% "YES" vote, the original Uniform Dress Code shall be adopted as the Local Dress Code for secondary schools."

None of the Board's policies on Local Dress Code have been followed by our administration, yet we are being told the kilt is officially banned or as stated in the agenda "in the consultation phase". However if we were really in the "consultation phase" the above requirements would already be completed since it is March and as stated above should have been completed by February. As mentioned this is an infringement on the Parent and Student Charter of Rights specifically Parent Right #12 that states that parents have "The right to have TCDSB rules and regulations and individual school policies applied and adhered to with transparency, consistency, fairness and compassion."

We would like to inform all students, parents and staff as soon as possible so we kindly ask you to sign this petition and share it on all you social media accounts! Thank you!

Here is the link to the Board's website where the above policies and requirements were stated: https://www.tcdsb.org/Board/Policies/Pages/SS07.as...

And here is the link to the Parent and Student Charter of Rights: https://www.tcdsb.org/FORPARENTS/DraftCharterOfRig...

edit**: please keep all comments appropriate, they will be deleted if found otherwise.


Updates

Reached 1,000 supporters

February 8, 2021

September 23, 2018

I AM ABSOLUTELY BLOWN AWAY BY THE STORIES YOU ARE ALL TELLING IN THE COMMENTS!! YOUR PASSION FOR KEEPING THE KILTS IS FUELING THIS ENTIRE MOVEMENT AND PROVING THAT OUR IDENTITY AT THIS SCHOOL MATTERS!! WE ARE CURRENTLY PREPARING OUR NEXT STEPS TO CHALLENGE THE BOARD AND WE WILL NOT BACK DOWN NOW!!

June 13, 2017

THIS MOMENTUM IS ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE!! I AM BEYOND EXCITED TO SEE SO MANY OF YOU FIGHTING TO KEEP OUR KILTS AT CARDINAL CARTER!! WE ARE SHOWING EVERYONE THAT OUR TRADITION IS WORTH PROTECTING!!!

March 16, 2017

ONE HUNDRED PEOPLE HAVE ALREADY SIGNED TO KEEP OUR KILTS!! THIS IS ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE NEWS AND THE MOMENTUM IS OFFICIALLY BUILDING!! THANK YOU ALL FOR STANDING UP FOR OUR TRADITION!!

Reached 100 supporters

March 15, 2017

231 Comments

A
Aurora Carnevale
9 years ago Featured

I believe in Carter keeping the kilt as it isn't fair to penalize an entire population of the school for the way a minority chooses to wear it. Regardless of my personal feelings, if the administration wants to ban the kilt, they can follow the rules and do it properly.

J
Joseph Carnevale
9 years ago Featured

Pretty sad when the Board doesn't adhere to its own policy. Congratulations to the students for standing up for something you believe in and using the Board's own policy to argue your point.

J
Joie Sia
9 years ago Featured

Kilts are one of Carter's symbol, it's a waste to get rid of them. It is unfair for the students in the music department to buy them for their performance dates and only use them then. It is also unfair for the students who did wear the kilt properly but are getting punished for others mistakes.

M
Moné Flowers
9 years ago Featured

It's important to realize that there are BOYS in the school who come to school not wearing the proper pants with the CCAA logo on it. At least with the kilts the girls are wearing their PROPER school uniform with the school's logo on it and not some cheap pants from H&M or WALMART. Don't ban the kilt.

S
Sabrina Daudlin
9 years ago Featured

I've been at Carter since the seventh grade and I've only worn the pants once. I wear the kilt everyday because it makes me feel comfortable with myself while at school and because the pants don't fit me. So I best be wearing my kilt for my last year here.

K
Katherine Guzman
9 years ago Featured

kilts are $80. i spent $160 on just my kilts. why? because anyone who wants to wear a kilt, should be able to wear a kilt. simple as that. any other girl (or boy) who's spent money just as I did shouldn't let that money go to waste just because of a stupid ban.

M
Maya
9 months ago

Me and my friends were so upset when we found out there were no skirts but luckily I found this petition!!! Really hope I can wear skirts when I go

A
ana
2 years ago

PLEASE KEEP THE KILTS