Residents Oppose Rezoning for the "GO Broome" Development on LES
"GO Broome" is the name of a massive real-estate development project proposed for the Lower East Side, currently going through the city's public review process (known as ULURP).
This plan is led by Gotham Realty Organization, in partnership with the Chinatown Planning Council Housing Development Fund Company Inc. (CPC), who are petitioning the city to change the zoning of this block in order to create their vision for 466,901 sf of new development space, making it 100 feet taller and 5 feet closer to the curb than even any of the surrounding buildings in Essex Crossing. Here is the link for the Land Use Review Application for Go Broome Street Development.
The developer is requesting a zoning variance to R9 zoning (never seen previously in CB3), to get approval for a building almost 3 times what the current zoning allows. This building would be taller than any development at Essex Crossing, which went through decades of community review.
Our Community Board has already voted in support of this plan.The process is still with the borough president and will then move to City Planning Commission for a vote, and then to City Council. A chart from the city can be found here.
After CB3, the process goes to the following parties on its way through ULURP:
- Borough President (30 days)
- City Planning Commission (60 days) * required to hold a public hearing
- City Council (50 days) * required to hold a public hearing
- Mayor approval or veto
Only the City Council can approve or deny the application. CPC is an organization that has provided valuable services to the neighborhood for years, but the specific details of this project are untenable for residents here. Since they are the landowner , if they respect R8 zoning CPC can still choose to present a plan including a mixed-use building with a headquarters and a solid mix of senior and affordable housing ( which neighbors can support ).
COMMUNITY CONCERNS:
1. Height and Bulk/ReZone- waivers for distance between buildings, there are too many variance asks. EVEN WITH THE REZONE, THE PROJECT FAR OVER DEVELOPS PROPERTY.
2. Questionable History of Gotham Realty- facing legal action by the Fair Housing Justice Corp. regarding an extensive history of violating the human rights and fair housing rights of the disabled.
3. Ratio of Market Rate Apartments to Affordable Housing and the questionable determination of those figures.
4. No Traffic/Waste Study has been done- too much large scale construction on very narrow streets.
COMMUNITY REQUESTS:
1.No Rezone. No change to the R8 guidelines for building in that location. A small footprint building with density restrictions in place. Keep R8 zoning.
2. All approval suspended until ADA lawsuit against Gotham is resolved.
3. All approval suspended until thorough Traffic/Waste Study is complete.
4. More actually affordable housing
The Petitioners request that our elected officials vote against the rezoning of the "GO Broome" development under these conditions and stipulations. We the undersigned live in the buildings adjoined, across, behind, next to or in close proximity to the proposed development and will be adversely impacted in so many ways by what this variance will bring to the neighborhood.
Updates
October 24, 2019
im still reading through all the comments you guys are posting and the amount of concern people have about how this will change the neighborhood is wild. im trying to get in touch with some local offices to see if theyll actually listen to us before this goes to the city planning commission.
October 24, 2019
i cannot believe how fast this is growing. so many people are finally paying attention to what gotham realty is trying to pull in our neighborhood and its honestly pretty cool to see us all on the same page.
40 Comments
This neighborhood is rapidly becoming unlivable! Who wants to inhabit dark alleys between skyscrapers with no sunlight. The neglect of the urban fabric, which makes the streets a place of communication and exchange, negates the point of living in the city.
I back the community requests - no NO to rezone; this is just another real-estate grab using 'affordable housing' as the gimmick that it has become.
The proposed project is 2.5x what the current zoning is. And the Gotham Organization is being sued for ADA violations in its other buildings. Where is the Department of Buildings on this?
Build more affordable and moderate and middle income units. Public space needs to be added and designed in such a way that it 'connects' with the adjacent public space north of The Rollins.
As a resident of LES I strongly oppose this plan. Years of study went into our current zoning laws and they should not be altered to make another real estate mogul richer at the expense of the people who live here!!! This is a bad plan and should not be approved!
Preserve access to light, air and sunshine
We don't need more excessively tall buildings. We NEED to be able to see the sky when walking in the streets!
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Copy link or share directly
Residents Oppose Rezoning for the "GO Broome" Development on LES
"GO Broome" is the name of a massive real-estate development project proposed for the Lower East Side, currently going through the city's public review process (known as ULURP).
This plan is led by Gotham Realty Organization, in partnership with the Chinatown Planning Council Housing Development Fund Company Inc. (CPC), who are petitioning the city to change the zoning of this block in order to create their vision for 466,901 sf of new development space, making it 100 feet taller and 5 feet closer to the curb than even any of the surrounding buildings in Essex Crossing. Here is the link for the Land Use Review Application for Go Broome Street Development.
The developer is requesting a zoning variance to R9 zoning (never seen previously in CB3), to get approval for a building almost 3 times what the current zoning allows. This building would be taller than any development at Essex Crossing, which went through decades of community review.
Our Community Board has already voted in support of this plan.The process is still with the borough president and will then move to City Planning Commission for a vote, and then to City Council. A chart from the city can be found here.
After CB3, the process goes to the following parties on its way through ULURP:
- Borough President (30 days)
- City Planning Commission (60 days) * required to hold a public hearing
- City Council (50 days) * required to hold a public hearing
- Mayor approval or veto
Only the City Council can approve or deny the application. CPC is an organization that has provided valuable services to the neighborhood for years, but the specific details of this project are untenable for residents here. Since they are the landowner , if they respect R8 zoning CPC can still choose to present a plan including a mixed-use building with a headquarters and a solid mix of senior and affordable housing ( which neighbors can support ).
COMMUNITY CONCERNS:
1. Height and Bulk/ReZone- waivers for distance between buildings, there are too many variance asks. EVEN WITH THE REZONE, THE PROJECT FAR OVER DEVELOPS PROPERTY.
2. Questionable History of Gotham Realty- facing legal action by the Fair Housing Justice Corp. regarding an extensive history of violating the human rights and fair housing rights of the disabled.
3. Ratio of Market Rate Apartments to Affordable Housing and the questionable determination of those figures.
4. No Traffic/Waste Study has been done- too much large scale construction on very narrow streets.
COMMUNITY REQUESTS:
1.No Rezone. No change to the R8 guidelines for building in that location. A small footprint building with density restrictions in place. Keep R8 zoning.
2. All approval suspended until ADA lawsuit against Gotham is resolved.
3. All approval suspended until thorough Traffic/Waste Study is complete.
4. More actually affordable housing
The Petitioners request that our elected officials vote against the rezoning of the "GO Broome" development under these conditions and stipulations. We the undersigned live in the buildings adjoined, across, behind, next to or in close proximity to the proposed development and will be adversely impacted in so many ways by what this variance will bring to the neighborhood.
Updates
October 24, 2019
im still reading through all the comments you guys are posting and the amount of concern people have about how this will change the neighborhood is wild. im trying to get in touch with some local offices to see if theyll actually listen to us before this goes to the city planning commission.
October 24, 2019
i cannot believe how fast this is growing. so many people are finally paying attention to what gotham realty is trying to pull in our neighborhood and its honestly pretty cool to see us all on the same page.
40 Comments
I strongly oppose a ReZone granting a developer to build a project 3X the size currently slated for this property. I also have questions regarding the history of this particular developer. Thank you for your time.
This neighborhood is rapidly becoming unlivable! Who wants to inhabit dark alleys between skyscrapers with no sunlight. The neglect of the urban fabric, which makes the streets a place of communication and exchange, negates the point of living in the city.
I back the community requests - no NO to rezone; this is just another real-estate grab using 'affordable housing' as the gimmick that it has become.
The proposed project is 2.5x what the current zoning is. And the Gotham Organization is being sued for ADA violations in its other buildings. Where is the Department of Buildings on this?
Build more affordable and moderate and middle income units. Public space needs to be added and designed in such a way that it 'connects' with the adjacent public space north of The Rollins.
As a resident of LES I strongly oppose this plan. Years of study went into our current zoning laws and they should not be altered to make another real estate mogul richer at the expense of the people who live here!!! This is a bad plan and should not be approved!
Preserve access to light, air and sunshine
We don't need more excessively tall buildings. We NEED to be able to see the sky when walking in the streets!
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach 100 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via .
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
I strongly oppose a ReZone granting a developer to build a project 3X the size currently slated for this property. I also have questions regarding the history of this particular developer. Thank you for your time.