Is it Time that we stop letting the Tail Wag the Dog?
Majority
Rule. 50% +1 or 66 2/3%
When the Co-op was first formed the decision was made to have a 2/3 Majority for many voting issues writen into our bylaws. I am
sure that back in the day this was needed to be fair to all concerned
when it came to spending a huge amount of money out of pocket.
Times
Change and so does the need for some rules. Currently, we need 66 and 2/3 of the membership to pass just about anything the members want. In any given vote, the Minority, not the Majority actually wins. For example, say we wanted a pickleball or Volleyball court. Say the vast majority of 66% vote yes and a minority of 34% vote no. The motion fails. The Minority wins. 34 % outweighs 66%? Does that seem right to you? It seems to be that the tail is in fact, wagging the
dog.
Our proposal is as follows: This petition is only to get these questions onto the Agenda. PLease sign the petition if you would like to discuss these issues and put them to a vote at the Annual Meeting of the Oakwood Manor Homeowners Association in January, 2023
1) Amendment to Article 10
10-3 Adoption
Exept as elsewhere provided, such
approvals must be by not less than ...
Remove: Sixty-six and two thirds percent ( 66-2/3%)
Replace
with: Fifty Percent plus 1 (50% +
1)
of the
members present in person or by proxy and voting at a membership
meeting at which a quorum has attended.
2) Amendment to Article 22 -
Alterations and Improvements
From time to
time the association board of directors may materially alter or
modify, or substantially improve the common areas and association
property upon obtaining the affirmative vote of at least ...
Remove: - two-thirds (2/3)
Replace with: a
Simple Majority 50% +1
of the members in
person or by proxy at a duly called and convened meeting of the
association.
3) Amendment to Article 23 –
Acquisition of additional lands.
From time to
time the association, through its board of directors shall have the
right to purchase or otherwise acquire additional real property,
which lands may not be converted to cooperative parcels. Material
alterations or substantial additions to such property by the
association shall not be deemed to constitute a material alteration
or modification of the appurtenances of a unit if such action is
approved by the affirmative vote of
Remove: two-thirds (2/3)
Replace with: a
simple majority 50% +1
of the members
present in person or by proxy and voting at a duly called and convened meeting of the association. ...
If you agree and feel that these are important issues and that they are added to the 2023 Agenda, then please, have one member of your household sign our petition and include your lot number. ( To keep the Lawyer types happy ).
We need a minimum of 130 Member votes (20%) to have this item added to the agenda.
Hey William, Yes, for example, a few years back there was a motion to install a pickleball court that would be fully funded by those that really wanted one. No cost to our members but free use whenever we wanted. The vote was close if I remember correctly but something like 428( 66%)yes votes and 221 (34%) no votes. The no votes won the day and we do not have a pickleball court. We need 432 votes to pass a motion in the park. This is what I mean by the tail wagging the dog. 221 members ( a vast minority, win) I think it is time for a change. Thanks for listening. Marty.