WARREN — Patriot Water has been identified as the source of the molecule causing a foul odor in some of the city’s northern neighborhoods, according to Water Pollution Control Director Ed Haller.
“We were able to trace the odor to Patriot Water by following it to the area where it was the greatest,” Haller said.
The molecule causing the bad odor has been identified as dimethyl disulfide, which produces a strong garlic-like odor when the water in which it is located is agitated.
The Patriot Water treatment plant, 2840 Sferra Boulevard, treats light total dissolved solids in water used in natural gas and oil drilling that could not be practically reused and should not be injected into deep wells, according to its website.
However, Haller said since the decline of the natural gas drilling industry in northeast Ohio, Patriot has taken in contracts to process polluted water from other industries. The polluted water is sent to Patriot Water to reduce the amounts of solids in them before they are sent to Warren’s Water Pollution Control department for further cleaning.
Patriot officials months earlier would not give city officials access to the raw materials being treated at the plant because company officials believed the disclosures would place them at a competitive disadvantage, Haller said.
However, Haller said the company’s refusal to turn over a list of their raw materials was not related to the investigation of this odor.
Councilman Eddie Colbert, D-at large, said it is unacceptable for a company not to cooperate with the city’s effort to determine the cause of an odor that has driven residents from their homes and forced companies to temporarily close.
“People have spent hundreds of dollars of their own money in an attempt to solve a problem that apparently has been caused by this company,” Colbert said.
Councilman Alford Novak, D-2nd Ward, said the odor has been permeating neighborhoods since March.
“Other area companies have shut down their operation due to the heavy odors,” Novak said.
Council President Jim Graham said residents and businesses that have spent money to make repairs to alleviate the odor coming into their homes and business may have to file a class action suit to recover their losses.
The city’s Water Pollution Control Department sought for several weeks to take samples from inside Patriot’s plant to find out if the discharge levels were matching what they city had already found outside the facility, Haller said. However, anytime one of the city workers was ready to take samples, the company would say they were not discharging from the plant at that time.
It was an analysis of materials emailed to the city by Patriot Water that convinced Haller on Wednesday to identify it as the primary source of the chemical.
Safety Service Director Enzo Cantalamessa and members from the Water Pollution Control met with representatives of Patriot Water June 8. Patriot Water representatives said they believe the dimethyl disulfide was coming from one of two companies, which Patriot did not identify.
Patriot Water has been working to reduce the odor by mixing in a combination of peroxide and chlorine bleach, Haller said. The amount of dimethyl disulfide found in Warren’s sewer system has not been sufficient enough to cause harm to residents, he said.
Haller said the department is working to purchase an analyzer designed to monitor the level of dimethyl disulfide.
Updates
June 16, 2017
Seeing this grow makes the long hours of fighting for our air feel a little less lonely. It is draining work to keep pushing against a company like Patriot but the weight of your names behind me helps keep the momentum moving forward.
24 Comments
weve had to leave our home could not cook had to buy food and eat it else where, this company invaded my home illegally
Please everyone share with everyone you know! This petition will be so important in the process of recording who this smell has affected. If a lawyer is retained for a class action lawsuit we will need names of individuals, homes and businesses that have been adversely affected.
I have 2 pregnant daughter's and the smell has been really hard in them .Let's stop this nonsense already!
It was horrible the scent was even in my basement.The order would occur at about 130 at night an on weekend.
The smell is nauseating and gives me a headache. At it's strongest it makes me cough and gag, and makes my eyes and nose burn and itch.
something needs to be done. my whole house smells constantly from it.
Get the problem gone
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Copy link or share directly
WARREN — Patriot Water has been identified as the source of the molecule causing a foul odor in some of the city’s northern neighborhoods, according to Water Pollution Control Director Ed Haller.
“We were able to trace the odor to Patriot Water by following it to the area where it was the greatest,” Haller said.
The molecule causing the bad odor has been identified as dimethyl disulfide, which produces a strong garlic-like odor when the water in which it is located is agitated.
The Patriot Water treatment plant, 2840 Sferra Boulevard, treats light total dissolved solids in water used in natural gas and oil drilling that could not be practically reused and should not be injected into deep wells, according to its website.
However, Haller said since the decline of the natural gas drilling industry in northeast Ohio, Patriot has taken in contracts to process polluted water from other industries. The polluted water is sent to Patriot Water to reduce the amounts of solids in them before they are sent to Warren’s Water Pollution Control department for further cleaning.
Patriot officials months earlier would not give city officials access to the raw materials being treated at the plant because company officials believed the disclosures would place them at a competitive disadvantage, Haller said.
However, Haller said the company’s refusal to turn over a list of their raw materials was not related to the investigation of this odor.
Councilman Eddie Colbert, D-at large, said it is unacceptable for a company not to cooperate with the city’s effort to determine the cause of an odor that has driven residents from their homes and forced companies to temporarily close.
“People have spent hundreds of dollars of their own money in an attempt to solve a problem that apparently has been caused by this company,” Colbert said.
Councilman Alford Novak, D-2nd Ward, said the odor has been permeating neighborhoods since March.
“Other area companies have shut down their operation due to the heavy odors,” Novak said.
Council President Jim Graham said residents and businesses that have spent money to make repairs to alleviate the odor coming into their homes and business may have to file a class action suit to recover their losses.
The city’s Water Pollution Control Department sought for several weeks to take samples from inside Patriot’s plant to find out if the discharge levels were matching what they city had already found outside the facility, Haller said. However, anytime one of the city workers was ready to take samples, the company would say they were not discharging from the plant at that time.
It was an analysis of materials emailed to the city by Patriot Water that convinced Haller on Wednesday to identify it as the primary source of the chemical.
Safety Service Director Enzo Cantalamessa and members from the Water Pollution Control met with representatives of Patriot Water June 8. Patriot Water representatives said they believe the dimethyl disulfide was coming from one of two companies, which Patriot did not identify.
Patriot Water has been working to reduce the odor by mixing in a combination of peroxide and chlorine bleach, Haller said. The amount of dimethyl disulfide found in Warren’s sewer system has not been sufficient enough to cause harm to residents, he said.
Haller said the department is working to purchase an analyzer designed to monitor the level of dimethyl disulfide.
Updates
June 16, 2017
Seeing this grow makes the long hours of fighting for our air feel a little less lonely. It is draining work to keep pushing against a company like Patriot but the weight of your names behind me helps keep the momentum moving forward.
24 Comments
The smell has made me sick to my stomach and caused me headaches for the last few months and it's been upsetting that I can't walk outside my home and enjoy the air peacefully without being sick.
weve had to leave our home could not cook had to buy food and eat it else where, this company invaded my home illegally
Please everyone share with everyone you know! This petition will be so important in the process of recording who this smell has affected. If a lawyer is retained for a class action lawsuit we will need names of individuals, homes and businesses that have been adversely affected.
I have 2 pregnant daughter's and the smell has been really hard in them .Let's stop this nonsense already!
It was horrible the scent was even in my basement.The order would occur at about 130 at night an on weekend.
The smell is nauseating and gives me a headache. At it's strongest it makes me cough and gag, and makes my eyes and nose burn and itch.
something needs to be done. my whole house smells constantly from it.
Get the problem gone
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach 100 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via .
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
The smell has made me sick to my stomach and caused me headaches for the last few months and it's been upsetting that I can't walk outside my home and enjoy the air peacefully without being sick.