Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.
Final supporters
Blizzard,
This petition is to seek fairness in the Mythic Dungeon Invitational. The first item that has been extremely unfair to teams can be seen from the EU Bracket in MDI. Team PogChamp beat Kjell's Angels and sent them to the loser's bracket. PogChamp ultimately won the winner's bracket and lost one series to Kjell's Angels and was automatically seeded 2nd to them in that bracket. In true fairness, Kjell's Angels would technically have tied the series 1-1, and one more would need to be played to determine the true winner. This may not be that important in a "for fun" setting, but when money is involved this becomes something that needs to be evaluated.
Second, when a dungeon is complete but has to be remade due to a bug, why not make only the team who had the "bug" redo the dungeon and compete against the previous team's time. An example of this is when Team Method NA had a "bug" in Lower Karazhan and the game had to be remade. Team Limit had already finished the dungeon, so why make them redo it unless it was their decision. This was extremely unfair to Team Limit, since their had already proved their efforts in the first run.
We understand that MDI is supposed to be entertaining, but that entertainment gets affected when equality and fairness is not considered to the full extent. A remake is fair to the team who experienced the bug, but maybe not so to the team that had already finished a dungeon and was happy with their effort. We think a more in-depth look of how MDI could become more fair should definitely be a high priority.
Sincerely,
Your Subscribers
More like this
Lightning's Blade EU Realm Imbalance!
Warmane - petition to ban Multiboxing from Wintergrasp
Updates
May 25, 2018
The competitive integrity of the Mythic Dungeon Invitational remains the primary focus of this initiative. I am currently compiling a comprehensive list of specific instances where tournament rules disrupted fair play to present to the organizers. Your feedback regarding these inconsistencies continues to provide essential evidence for our argument.
May 25, 2018
The response to this petition has demonstrated a clear desire for greater integrity in professional competition. This momentum confirms that people care deeply about the fairness of these tournaments when stakes are high.
5 Comments
its honestly ridiculous that teams have to replay whole dungeons just because of some server bug. blizzard needs to get their act together if they want this to be taken seriously as a real esport.
totaly agree. if one team finishes their run they shouldnt have to do it again. unfair to make them waste their energy like that.
KKona
yes
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Copy link or share directly
Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.
Final supporters
Blizzard,
This petition is to seek fairness in the Mythic Dungeon Invitational. The first item that has been extremely unfair to teams can be seen from the EU Bracket in MDI. Team PogChamp beat Kjell's Angels and sent them to the loser's bracket. PogChamp ultimately won the winner's bracket and lost one series to Kjell's Angels and was automatically seeded 2nd to them in that bracket. In true fairness, Kjell's Angels would technically have tied the series 1-1, and one more would need to be played to determine the true winner. This may not be that important in a "for fun" setting, but when money is involved this becomes something that needs to be evaluated.
Second, when a dungeon is complete but has to be remade due to a bug, why not make only the team who had the "bug" redo the dungeon and compete against the previous team's time. An example of this is when Team Method NA had a "bug" in Lower Karazhan and the game had to be remade. Team Limit had already finished the dungeon, so why make them redo it unless it was their decision. This was extremely unfair to Team Limit, since their had already proved their efforts in the first run.
We understand that MDI is supposed to be entertaining, but that entertainment gets affected when equality and fairness is not considered to the full extent. A remake is fair to the team who experienced the bug, but maybe not so to the team that had already finished a dungeon and was happy with their effort. We think a more in-depth look of how MDI could become more fair should definitely be a high priority.
Sincerely,
Your Subscribers
Updates
May 25, 2018
The competitive integrity of the Mythic Dungeon Invitational remains the primary focus of this initiative. I am currently compiling a comprehensive list of specific instances where tournament rules disrupted fair play to present to the organizers. Your feedback regarding these inconsistencies continues to provide essential evidence for our argument.
May 25, 2018
The response to this petition has demonstrated a clear desire for greater integrity in professional competition. This momentum confirms that people care deeply about the fairness of these tournaments when stakes are high.
5 Comments
If remakes are going to happen, the best time of both teams should be taken into account.
its honestly ridiculous that teams have to replay whole dungeons just because of some server bug. blizzard needs to get their act together if they want this to be taken seriously as a real esport.
totaly agree. if one team finishes their run they shouldnt have to do it again. unfair to make them waste their energy like that.
KKona
yes
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
If remakes are going to happen, the best time of both teams should be taken into account.