REFORM ACVM (2011) ACT TO REFLECT ANIMAL PRODUCTION NEEDS FROM FEEDSTUFFS AND TECHNICAL INGREDIENTS
THE PROBLEM
'Feed' is currently not even defined in the current ACVM (2011) Act. Products are either ONC (nutrients) or veterinary drugs. Technical ingredients used globally to support animal production, wellbeing and welfare do not have define categories or standardised submission process
This is needed to provide:
1. Economic benefits to industry and farmers/producers.
2. Reduced registration costs
3. Producers/farmers gain improved efficiency and productivity and innovation
4. Regulatory resources and costs can be better utilised to deal with more urgent and higher risk-based issues and communications within the industry and users.
5. Exemption lists will be kept contemporary with the latest Glocal scientific developments.
6. Compliance will be a co-regulation approach between industry and regulators.
7. Government to show support for both industry and producers through cutting red tape and increasing other assistance to grow profitability.
The proposal
This proposal is to reform current practises to align regulatory effort with commercial needs and safety for animal feed and pet food ingredients. The current ACVM act (last amended 2011) is only set up for individual nutrients (oral nutritional compounds which are exempt from full registration) or veterinary medicines. It does not provide any specifics for functional feed ingredients, which have activities above and beyond just nutrient supply. Historically, this has resulted in an interpretation regarding the scope of regulatory requirements needed for functional ingredients. There is a need to include functional ingredients into the ACVM act and create a defined framework for submission and suitable categories for approvals.
In this document, the term ‘feed’ is taken to include complete, complementary and supplementary (including technical ingredients) products designed for production livestock and other species (including, but not limited to, all pets, working and show animals, equine, alpacas etc.). The proposal is to leverage international regulatory approvals for low-risk products which would allow better access to the latest innovations. It aims to alleviate safety concerns in the NZ industry and for consumers, while allowing agricultural producers to utilise world leading innovations. This will give improved outcomes for reducing reliance on prophylactic antibiotic use, meeting environmental targets and allowing enhanced animal productive performance, health and welfare. Its focus is on regulatory efficiency, reducing time and costs for registration, access to and adoption of innovation to allow NZ to maintain a competitive advantage in its productivity and exports. This must include due diligence regarding risk versus the ‘precautionary principle’, leading to greater ingredient choice for NZ farmers, improving animal health and efficiency and increased profitability, whether in local markets or as exports. Because of the small NZ market and cumbersome regulatory system, farmers and producers currently do not have access to world leading innovations, because of the cost, time and market potential does not justify the expense.
Members of the animal feed industry, including livestock and companion animals (aka pet) food manufacturers as well as single supplement and premixes, are advocating for change to the current regulation of animal feeds, primarily the ACVM Act (last updated 2011). The main arguments centre on the complexity and cost (initial and ongoing) of meeting current regulatory requirements, various hurdles (i.e., not accepting GRAS status), no standardised requirements for feed ingredients and no standardisation between Australia and NZ, which are local trading markets. Alignment between NZ and Australia would allow for more efficient business and more companies entering the market, which will be beneficial to both producers and consumers.In addition, the limitations of the current system must be addressed, as these restrict innovation and competition in global markets (lack of suitable categories, especially for ‘gut modifiers’ by mode of action and plant-based extracts). Additionally, there is a ‘two tier’ system in NZ, whereby locally manufactured materials are often not registered, whilst products from overseas require full disclosure to allow for importation across the border (via the Class Determination system, which only applies to branded products). This has led to various ethical and welfare problems in animals due to essential products and ingredients simply having limited or no availability. The current system does not allow for substitution of products, for example when registered zinc products run out (a regular problem) in high facial eczema risk seasons, the current framework is inflexible, and ultimately leads to animals suffering, due to no treatment options.
The difficulty, as perceived by industry, is the focus of existing requirements, as covered in the current ACVM legislation. This does not allow for world leading and globally recognised zootechnical ingredients and, hence, is excessive when applied to managing the risks to animal feed and pet food.
Purpose and potential benefit
This reform can be achieved by extending the exclusions of certain types of feed ingredients which are already used extensively and have proven safety record within ACVM registration. It includes having an overarching compliance mechanism co-regulated by industry and MPI. There is a need to generate a new list covering all ingredients and listed by both mode of action and legal categorisation. Some may fall into several categories, including those currently exempt (which receive a letter of exemption which is not traceable on the MPI portal).
The proposed reform supports the commitment to:
· Focus on safety of proposed ingredients/products based on LD50, GRAS status and inclusion rates (i.e., preventing overfeeding of minerals as a bypass for AGP activity), rather than ‘claims’ alone. This safety aspect of the proposal is covered through the approved international lists.
· Reduce red tape, time and costs for the feed and associated industry.
· Allow for registered ingredients to be used within associated feeds and other products, as long as no contraindications declared.
· Provide a logical categorisation for all current (and anticipated) feed ingredients, based on mode of action. Australia successfully uses a category called Excluded Nutritional and Digestive Enhancers (END products) and this is an example worth considering.
· Use internationally accepted (e.g., AFFCO, EU Feed addtive) lists to minimise costs and time.
· Provide opportunities for improving efficiency of the regulator
(MPI), allowing ease of attaining.
· Focus MPI resources on higher risk chemicals, pharmaceuticals and novel compounds.
· Address industry concerns regarding ‘level playing field’ for all overseas v local manufacturers.
· Improve industry access, in a timely manner, to low risk, minimally regulated, safe additives and ingredients.
· Encourage a commercial environment that supports innovation and allows value added products (feed or milk, meat and eggs etc.)
· Ensure the quality and safety, including documentation and labels, of supplied feed and supplements – rather than just a focus on ‘claims’.
The overarching exemption list could include;
· Pre-, post- or pro-biotics,
· Liver function and digestive support,
· Toxin binding,
· Rumen activity,
· Modifying gut function,
· Nutritional support for animal development (skeletal, connective tissue) and
· Supporting specific periods, such as weaning,
· Feed efficiency additives,
· Mineral advances for animal welfare in terms of milk quality and fertility
· New innovations into the future which address consumer, environmental etc needs.
Industry has estimated the direct benefits of removing the costs associated with obtaining
and maintaining a registration to be NZ$36 million pa. Annual savings to ingredient suppliers are expected to be NZ$12 million just for streamlining ACVM registration processes. A major benefit would be reduced feed costs at the farm gate, estimated by industry as $4-10/t feed, equating to NZ$4.3-12.7 million per annum. (NZFMA, 2023). Petfood would benefit in a greater manner, as it is mainly exported (US$150 million) from NZ to other countries, where the GE-free and ‘clean food’ marketing is the main marketing driver. Lack of access to modern zootechnical ingredients currently limits the production of innovative feed, pet food, supplements and treats.
Market competition would be driven by this reform, supporting the benefits to industry. New Zealand’s market size reduces the overseas incentive to spend money on both time consuming and costly process of registration for low-risk products, and hence, many companies ignore NZ as a viable market.
Existing regulatory circumstances
Certain compounds are currently exempt under ACVM, including single nutrients, such as certain minerals or energy sources (e.g., oils), despite the fact these may have claims which exceed simple supply. This list is incomplete, doesn’t follow current scientific knowledge or keep up with contemporary developments in technology and science or market demands. Such strict definitions and regulation by ‘claim’ limit development and access to new technologies.
Proposed regulatory circumstance
The proposal is to extend the scope of exemption currently provided for in the ACVM Act. It is proposed that products which meet safety criteria, are designed to ensure appropriate use (for humans, animals and trade), are excluded from the requirements of the ACVM Act. This exclusion would be restricted to feeds for voluntary consumption (i.e., not directly or forcibly introduced to an animal’s digestive system) and not make any ‘curative’ claims.
The criteria (manufacturing and supply, labelling and ingredients) should define the circumstances of the exclusion. Products that do not fully meet such criteria would remain veterinary/chemical products and subject to the requirements of the ACVM Act. The key criteria are that ingredient or compound must already be on an approved list, referring to GRAS, AFFCO or EU Feed Additives, where its safety for use has already been determined. The purpose for use has already been defined by those authorities and a product cannot be applied for reasons that differs from the approved use. For example, if approved for use in poultry it cannot be applied for use in dairy cows, however, it should be applicable to all chickens.
Oversight and compliance
It is proposed that oversight is a co-regulation approach. All manufacturers should have a simple and affordable audited system to ensure compliance, while regulators are tasked with enforcing any non-compliance and ensuring a level playing field regarding all feed and products, regardless of whether made overseas or in NZ.
Industry already has established QA systems, like FeedsafeNZ and FAMIQS/GMP+. Both systems are purpose built with rigorous independent auditing that ensures compliance both within feed and additive suppliers. The fall back remains with ACVM compliance team to respond to any queries or non-compliance.
1 Comment
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
Share this petition
Share this petition to help it reach more people.
Your share link
Couldn't copy automatically. Long-press to copy:
REFORM ACVM (2011) ACT TO REFLECT ANIMAL PRODUCTION NEEDS FROM FEEDSTUFFS AND TECHNICAL INGREDIENTS
THE PROBLEM
'Feed' is currently not even defined in the current ACVM (2011) Act. Products are either ONC (nutrients) or veterinary drugs. Technical ingredients used globally to support animal production, wellbeing and welfare do not have define categories or standardised submission process
This is needed to provide:
1. Economic benefits to industry and farmers/producers.
2. Reduced registration costs
3. Producers/farmers gain improved efficiency and productivity and innovation
4. Regulatory resources and costs can be better utilised to deal with more urgent and higher risk-based issues and communications within the industry and users.
5. Exemption lists will be kept contemporary with the latest Glocal scientific developments.
6. Compliance will be a co-regulation approach between industry and regulators.
7. Government to show support for both industry and producers through cutting red tape and increasing other assistance to grow profitability.
The proposal
This proposal is to reform current practises to align regulatory effort with commercial needs and safety for animal feed and pet food ingredients. The current ACVM act (last amended 2011) is only set up for individual nutrients (oral nutritional compounds which are exempt from full registration) or veterinary medicines. It does not provide any specifics for functional feed ingredients, which have activities above and beyond just nutrient supply. Historically, this has resulted in an interpretation regarding the scope of regulatory requirements needed for functional ingredients. There is a need to include functional ingredients into the ACVM act and create a defined framework for submission and suitable categories for approvals.
In this document, the term ‘feed’ is taken to include complete, complementary and supplementary (including technical ingredients) products designed for production livestock and other species (including, but not limited to, all pets, working and show animals, equine, alpacas etc.). The proposal is to leverage international regulatory approvals for low-risk products which would allow better access to the latest innovations. It aims to alleviate safety concerns in the NZ industry and for consumers, while allowing agricultural producers to utilise world leading innovations. This will give improved outcomes for reducing reliance on prophylactic antibiotic use, meeting environmental targets and allowing enhanced animal productive performance, health and welfare. Its focus is on regulatory efficiency, reducing time and costs for registration, access to and adoption of innovation to allow NZ to maintain a competitive advantage in its productivity and exports. This must include due diligence regarding risk versus the ‘precautionary principle’, leading to greater ingredient choice for NZ farmers, improving animal health and efficiency and increased profitability, whether in local markets or as exports. Because of the small NZ market and cumbersome regulatory system, farmers and producers currently do not have access to world leading innovations, because of the cost, time and market potential does not justify the expense.
Members of the animal feed industry, including livestock and companion animals (aka pet) food manufacturers as well as single supplement and premixes, are advocating for change to the current regulation of animal feeds, primarily the ACVM Act (last updated 2011). The main arguments centre on the complexity and cost (initial and ongoing) of meeting current regulatory requirements, various hurdles (i.e., not accepting GRAS status), no standardised requirements for feed ingredients and no standardisation between Australia and NZ, which are local trading markets. Alignment between NZ and Australia would allow for more efficient business and more companies entering the market, which will be beneficial to both producers and consumers.In addition, the limitations of the current system must be addressed, as these restrict innovation and competition in global markets (lack of suitable categories, especially for ‘gut modifiers’ by mode of action and plant-based extracts). Additionally, there is a ‘two tier’ system in NZ, whereby locally manufactured materials are often not registered, whilst products from overseas require full disclosure to allow for importation across the border (via the Class Determination system, which only applies to branded products). This has led to various ethical and welfare problems in animals due to essential products and ingredients simply having limited or no availability. The current system does not allow for substitution of products, for example when registered zinc products run out (a regular problem) in high facial eczema risk seasons, the current framework is inflexible, and ultimately leads to animals suffering, due to no treatment options.
The difficulty, as perceived by industry, is the focus of existing requirements, as covered in the current ACVM legislation. This does not allow for world leading and globally recognised zootechnical ingredients and, hence, is excessive when applied to managing the risks to animal feed and pet food.
Purpose and potential benefit
This reform can be achieved by extending the exclusions of certain types of feed ingredients which are already used extensively and have proven safety record within ACVM registration. It includes having an overarching compliance mechanism co-regulated by industry and MPI. There is a need to generate a new list covering all ingredients and listed by both mode of action and legal categorisation. Some may fall into several categories, including those currently exempt (which receive a letter of exemption which is not traceable on the MPI portal).
The proposed reform supports the commitment to:
· Focus on safety of proposed ingredients/products based on LD50, GRAS status and inclusion rates (i.e., preventing overfeeding of minerals as a bypass for AGP activity), rather than ‘claims’ alone. This safety aspect of the proposal is covered through the approved international lists.
· Reduce red tape, time and costs for the feed and associated industry.
· Allow for registered ingredients to be used within associated feeds and other products, as long as no contraindications declared.
· Provide a logical categorisation for all current (and anticipated) feed ingredients, based on mode of action. Australia successfully uses a category called Excluded Nutritional and Digestive Enhancers (END products) and this is an example worth considering.
· Use internationally accepted (e.g., AFFCO, EU Feed addtive) lists to minimise costs and time.
· Provide opportunities for improving efficiency of the regulator
(MPI), allowing ease of attaining.
· Focus MPI resources on higher risk chemicals, pharmaceuticals and novel compounds.
· Address industry concerns regarding ‘level playing field’ for all overseas v local manufacturers.
· Improve industry access, in a timely manner, to low risk, minimally regulated, safe additives and ingredients.
· Encourage a commercial environment that supports innovation and allows value added products (feed or milk, meat and eggs etc.)
· Ensure the quality and safety, including documentation and labels, of supplied feed and supplements – rather than just a focus on ‘claims’.
The overarching exemption list could include;
· Pre-, post- or pro-biotics,
· Liver function and digestive support,
· Toxin binding,
· Rumen activity,
· Modifying gut function,
· Nutritional support for animal development (skeletal, connective tissue) and
· Supporting specific periods, such as weaning,
· Feed efficiency additives,
· Mineral advances for animal welfare in terms of milk quality and fertility
· New innovations into the future which address consumer, environmental etc needs.
Industry has estimated the direct benefits of removing the costs associated with obtaining
and maintaining a registration to be NZ$36 million pa. Annual savings to ingredient suppliers are expected to be NZ$12 million just for streamlining ACVM registration processes. A major benefit would be reduced feed costs at the farm gate, estimated by industry as $4-10/t feed, equating to NZ$4.3-12.7 million per annum. (NZFMA, 2023). Petfood would benefit in a greater manner, as it is mainly exported (US$150 million) from NZ to other countries, where the GE-free and ‘clean food’ marketing is the main marketing driver. Lack of access to modern zootechnical ingredients currently limits the production of innovative feed, pet food, supplements and treats.
Market competition would be driven by this reform, supporting the benefits to industry. New Zealand’s market size reduces the overseas incentive to spend money on both time consuming and costly process of registration for low-risk products, and hence, many companies ignore NZ as a viable market.
Existing regulatory circumstances
Certain compounds are currently exempt under ACVM, including single nutrients, such as certain minerals or energy sources (e.g., oils), despite the fact these may have claims which exceed simple supply. This list is incomplete, doesn’t follow current scientific knowledge or keep up with contemporary developments in technology and science or market demands. Such strict definitions and regulation by ‘claim’ limit development and access to new technologies.
Proposed regulatory circumstance
The proposal is to extend the scope of exemption currently provided for in the ACVM Act. It is proposed that products which meet safety criteria, are designed to ensure appropriate use (for humans, animals and trade), are excluded from the requirements of the ACVM Act. This exclusion would be restricted to feeds for voluntary consumption (i.e., not directly or forcibly introduced to an animal’s digestive system) and not make any ‘curative’ claims.
The criteria (manufacturing and supply, labelling and ingredients) should define the circumstances of the exclusion. Products that do not fully meet such criteria would remain veterinary/chemical products and subject to the requirements of the ACVM Act. The key criteria are that ingredient or compound must already be on an approved list, referring to GRAS, AFFCO or EU Feed Additives, where its safety for use has already been determined. The purpose for use has already been defined by those authorities and a product cannot be applied for reasons that differs from the approved use. For example, if approved for use in poultry it cannot be applied for use in dairy cows, however, it should be applicable to all chickens.
Oversight and compliance
It is proposed that oversight is a co-regulation approach. All manufacturers should have a simple and affordable audited system to ensure compliance, while regulators are tasked with enforcing any non-compliance and ensuring a level playing field regarding all feed and products, regardless of whether made overseas or in NZ.
Industry already has established QA systems, like FeedsafeNZ and FAMIQS/GMP+. Both systems are purpose built with rigorous independent auditing that ensures compliance both within feed and additive suppliers. The fall back remains with ACVM compliance team to respond to any queries or non-compliance.
1 Comment
There is a need to reduce red tape in NZ, improve government efficiency (less spending) and speed up technology access for NZ Farmers. Reform is desperately needed.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach 50 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via .
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
Share this petition
Share this petition to help it reach more people.
Your share link
Couldn't copy automatically. Long-press to copy:
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Make your voice count today!
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
There is a need to reduce red tape in NZ, improve government efficiency (less spending) and speed up technology access for NZ Farmers. Reform is desperately needed.