Did you watch any of the BBC\'s Young Musician of the Year competition on television recently If you did, and had watched it in previous years, what were your reactions to the decision to exclude much of the music from the television broadcasts by relegating it to an online domain, and concentrating instead on personalities and trivia It is plain from comments in the broadsheets, Radio Times, Points of View and BBC Radio 3 and BBC Four websites that many existing viewers of this important biennial competition were totally alienated by the decision to push the actual music-making into the background.
So far the BBC have barely acknowledged the concern and complaints about this major change in presentation, nor have they made any comments or committments regarding how the programme might be presented in the future. There is a danger that any audience criticism will be brushed aside because it is so fragmented. To this end, we have decided to make our feelings felt in a more unified way, and to ask the BBC questions regarding this coverage which are still unanswered, and furthermore to seek assurances that their treatment of classical music will be given more serious consideration in the future.
Questions that we want to ask include:
Why was the decision made to exclude music performance from the television coverage Who made that decision
Why does the BBC believe that presenting the performances exclusively online - with inferior sound and picture, as well as excluding those without decent internet access - was a satisfactory alternative to the traditional coverage on TV
Why was the concerto final not shown on television Who made that decision
Who does the BBC believe is the audience for the programmes Have they succeeded in reaching that audience
Do the BBC Trust and the DCMS committee members believe that the BBC\'s coverage of the competition met the promises made in the Charter review
What assurances do we have that this production approach will not be repeated in 2010
If you care about maintaining standards of music broadcasting and regret the decision to move such an important event into the incompatible realm of reality television, then we urge you to help us make the public\'s feelings clear by adding your name to the petition below.
We will present the completed petition to the BBC Trust, the BBC\'s Chairman Sir Michael Lyons, relevant department heads and members of the government\'s Culture, Media and Sport committee.
Thank you.
IMPORTANT NOTE : You do not have to donate any money in order to sign the petition. This petition is hosted for free by iPetitions and they will appeal for donations in order to survive. But you are under no obligation to do so. Your signature will always count.
The number of signatures is nearing one hundred. Please circulate this petition to your personal networks so we can reach this initial milestone before we present our concerns to the BBC.
6 Comments
D
David Abadi
18 years ago
Featured
The quality online is awful compared to the broadcast. why ruin a great program for the sake of some pointless filler content
L
Linda Shaw
18 years ago
Featured
i pay my license fee to watch music not to search for it online. fix this bbc.
M
Mark West
18 years ago
Featured
total nonsense. who decided this? absolute disgrace to treat such talented young musicians this way.
S
Sarah Marquez
18 years ago
Featured
Ridiculous decision. We want to see the performance not just people talking about it. Put the music back on tv where it belongs
H
Helen Mehta
18 years ago
Featured
So disappointed this year. Used to love watching this with my family but the new format just ruins the whole experience.
R
Robert Alvarez
18 years ago
Featured
bring back the full performances. nobody watches this for the trivia segments.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
500 signatures.
Your share link
Couldn't copy automatically. Long-press to copy:
Share directly
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via
.
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
Did you watch any of the BBC\'s Young Musician of the Year competition on television recently If you did, and had watched it in previous years, what were your reactions to the decision to exclude much of the music from the television broadcasts by relegating it to an online domain, and concentrating instead on personalities and trivia It is plain from comments in the broadsheets, Radio Times, Points of View and BBC Radio 3 and BBC Four websites that many existing viewers of this important biennial competition were totally alienated by the decision to push the actual music-making into the background.
So far the BBC have barely acknowledged the concern and complaints about this major change in presentation, nor have they made any comments or committments regarding how the programme might be presented in the future. There is a danger that any audience criticism will be brushed aside because it is so fragmented. To this end, we have decided to make our feelings felt in a more unified way, and to ask the BBC questions regarding this coverage which are still unanswered, and furthermore to seek assurances that their treatment of classical music will be given more serious consideration in the future.
Questions that we want to ask include:
Why was the decision made to exclude music performance from the television coverage Who made that decision
Why does the BBC believe that presenting the performances exclusively online - with inferior sound and picture, as well as excluding those without decent internet access - was a satisfactory alternative to the traditional coverage on TV
Why was the concerto final not shown on television Who made that decision
Who does the BBC believe is the audience for the programmes Have they succeeded in reaching that audience
Do the BBC Trust and the DCMS committee members believe that the BBC\'s coverage of the competition met the promises made in the Charter review
What assurances do we have that this production approach will not be repeated in 2010
If you care about maintaining standards of music broadcasting and regret the decision to move such an important event into the incompatible realm of reality television, then we urge you to help us make the public\'s feelings clear by adding your name to the petition below.
We will present the completed petition to the BBC Trust, the BBC\'s Chairman Sir Michael Lyons, relevant department heads and members of the government\'s Culture, Media and Sport committee.
Thank you.
IMPORTANT NOTE : You do not have to donate any money in order to sign the petition. This petition is hosted for free by iPetitions and they will appeal for donations in order to survive. But you are under no obligation to do so. Your signature will always count.
The number of signatures is nearing one hundred. Please circulate this petition to your personal networks so we can reach this initial milestone before we present our concerns to the BBC.
6 Comments
D
David Abadi
18 years ago
Featured
The quality online is awful compared to the broadcast. why ruin a great program for the sake of some pointless filler content
L
Linda Shaw
18 years ago
Featured
i pay my license fee to watch music not to search for it online. fix this bbc.
M
Mark West
18 years ago
Featured
total nonsense. who decided this? absolute disgrace to treat such talented young musicians this way.
S
Sarah Marquez
18 years ago
Featured
Ridiculous decision. We want to see the performance not just people talking about it. Put the music back on tv where it belongs
H
Helen Mehta
18 years ago
Featured
So disappointed this year. Used to love watching this with my family but the new format just ruins the whole experience.
R
Robert Alvarez
18 years ago
Featured
bring back the full performances. nobody watches this for the trivia segments.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
500 signatures.
Your share link
Couldn't copy automatically. Long-press to copy:
Share directly
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
The quality online is awful compared to the broadcast. why ruin a great program for the sake of some pointless filler content