Skip to main content

A Vote on Trans Women Joining Women's Institutes

1,122 Comments

S
Shirley Roper
3 years ago

Women’s groups should be exactly that, confined to natal born women.

H
Helen Smith
3 years ago

Keep women’s institute for women (adult human females) only. I’ll only join when this happens

P
Patricia Hughes
3 years ago Featured

There are so few places where women can meet to have discussions on a wide range of issues without males diluting the female perspective. This is vital for democracy, so, no, men should not be let in. I have yet to see a TW say anything a woman would say.

G
Gerry Robinson
3 years ago

Trans women are men! #Sexnatters

K
Katie Graham
3 years ago

I would like to join but only if the WI stays true to its history and is a group for real women (adult female humans). I’m not looking for a mixed sex group.

D
Diane Dawson
3 years ago

I couldn’t consider joking WI while it includes males however they identify but if you include women however they identify, I would. Please use the exception in EA2010 to clarify that WI is a single sex organisation.

L
Louise Westbrook
3 years ago

I was interested in joining WI however am put off by refusal to allow members not to believe that women is a feeling in a man's head. Its is not.

J
Julia Thomson
3 years ago

I believe the rights of women who are survivors of sexual assault & domestic violence are not being considered by this policy, which has been enacted without consulting membership. A man who identifies as a woman remains a man. There is no way of ensuring predatory men will not exploit the removal of gateways into women’s single sex spaces. Women deserve their own spaces.

J
Jenny O
3 years ago

I’m not a member any longer whilst men (however they identify) can also be members. We need female only groups.

V
Victoria Speirs
3 years ago

Women-only organisations (defined by sex) are legitimate and important

J
Jane
3 years ago

I would be in favour of genuine transsexuals joining but the whole gender nonsense is ludicrous- how do we tell if someone is a transvestite or a trans woman?

K
Kathryn Davies
3 years ago

I have been very uneasy about the stance of NFWI on this issue. I’m glad I am not the only one.

R
Rebecca E
3 years ago

Would love to join the WI but won't until it returns to being an all woman organisation.

R
Rebekah Wershbale
3 years ago

I'd be happier if the existing trans members could be removed too, but it's definitely a solid start

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Women and girls are a sex class. Men and boys are the other sex class. Keep WI 's female sex

E
Elaine Shimmin
3 years ago

'Transwomen' are male. It would ruin the whole ethos of the WI. Besides, most of them still have male privilage and would tend to take over.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Trans women are con men

G
Geraldine Curtis
3 years ago

I object to men using WI meetings to indulge their AGP sexual fetish

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Important that full membership are given opportunity to decide.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

I will not join all the while there are trans identifying men as members