Skip to main content

A Vote on Trans Women Joining Women's Institutes

1,122 Comments

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

I don't agree that any biological males should be in the WI. I will not be joining or supporting WI because of this. I am signing in support of stopping more males entering and reviewing the policies. If you are permitting males to join then it should not be entitled women's institute as this is false advertising, it's misleading and the average person would assume it's female only. If you want it mixed rename it as Institute or Mixed Institute. Furthermore, it is my view that allowing trans women (biological males) but excluding men breaches the equalities act as it is prejudicial against biological men identifying as men because of their gender. The equalities act protects exclusion for single sex spaces, but with biological males as members it is no longer a single sex space, so you are excluding men who dress as men. A womens organisation should be a safe space for females. On a personal note I first became aware of the trans debate as I was on a feminist page online and I was told I'm a disgusting TERF (I had to Google that) and I'd make a good bullet cushion!!! because I referred to myself as female and said that I wouldnt personally date a man who'd been born a woman...up until that point I'd believed I was allowed to have a preference. I wasn't. There was a pile on of pure hate which confused the hell out of me. My accounts were also hacked. All from one innocent (and true) commemt. The more I learn about the demands from the trans community the more frightened I am. Everyone deserves a safe space, but if you wouldn't allow a man I'm your space don't allow a biological males as trans women commit sexual and violent crime (against women) at the same rate as men.

N
Nicola Burkinshaw
3 years ago

I have been toying with joining up. Not likely if this ridiculous policy is in place.

J
Jean Craven
3 years ago

Former member of the WI - and I won’t even consider rejoining until this policy is rescinded.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

The WI is one of the only spaces women can come together. Please do not diminish this wonderful organisation by bringing men in.

P
Prudence Evans
3 years ago

Biological women deserve our own space, exclusive of biological males

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Men can’t become women.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Men who claim they are women should not be allowed in the women’s institute.

C
Caitlin Collins
3 years ago

The WI was set up for women - let's keep it that way

J
Julia Lamb Tod
3 years ago

I think it’s essential women’s groups are only for women.

L
Leanne Blake
3 years ago

Women aren’t allowed to have male free spaces anymore, this has to stop.

S
Sarah Haworth
3 years ago

I would love to become a member but not while they have this policy. It's degrading to women.

P
Patrick de Nangle
3 years ago

The radical element of the Trans cause are turning the World against the whole Trans issue by demanding something that’s never going to happen

C
Carol Cunningham
3 years ago

Women’s Institute - it’s in the name. Men should not be allowed, no matter how they ‘identify’.

D
Deborah Ryan
3 years ago

Transwomen should never have been allowed to join the WI - the WI is a single-sex organization, not a 'gender-fluid' organization. Lets stick to reality and allow women to keep what they fought for - single-sex spaces and groups! If the WI goes back to single-sex groups, I will join.

S
Sara Stewart
3 years ago

Women have the right to spaces that only contain our sex. There are many institutions when both men and women attend. The Women’s Institute should not be one of those.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

This should be a member vote not imposed on women.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

WI means Women's Institute. To me that is biological women.

A
Anne Billard
3 years ago

Enough of men deciding they want to invade women's spaces !

S
Susannah Wright
3 years ago

The trans/gender issue is going too far. Leave women alone to enjoy our spaces!

S
Sief GP
3 years ago

I would like to join the WI but will not join whilst males are allowed as members. I want a female only environment.