Skip to main content

A Vote on Trans Women Joining Women's Institutes

1,122 Comments

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Biological sex is important to safeguard women and their spaces

D
Debbie Seal
3 years ago

Glasshouses - NYW

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Women have the right to their own organisations without the presence of men. Transwomen are men.

S
Sarah Richardson
3 years ago

Women’s institute is for women. Transgender women are by definition male and therefore men.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

No males in females spaces, transwomen are males...get them out..

R
Roberta Goodall
3 years ago

I’m a member of another women’s organisation but they are setting up a committee to discuss the matter. Unfortunately the EA10 is not clear on exceptions for clubs.

S
Susan Low
3 years ago

No man can become a women Buckinghamshire wi

T
Teresa Hollis
3 years ago

I want to join WI but not while men are allowed to. It's totally at odds with everything the WI stands for.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

I’ve left the WI. Going to stay for lectures & conferences you sometimes share a room. Trans women are men in drag

J
Jennifer Ayres
3 years ago

Are women to be allowed nothing without men? Apparently we've lost all our rights to say 'no' to men.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Women should have the right to freedom of association with other women. Men are not women.

R
Richard harrison
3 years ago

My grandmother was a member of the women's institute in droitwich for many years, she went weekly and always spoke lovingly about what they did in the local community and of fhe many friends she had come to know and these friends stayed with her throughout her final years, but to say a man who simply states he's a woman can join the womens institute is just a mad and stupid thing to support check the name of the organisation that should tell you all you need to know, women = adult human female.

S
Shabanah Fazal
3 years ago

Men (those born male will always remain male) have no place in a women‘s organisation designed around the physical, social, psychological and emotional needs of women. Our lives and especially biological experiences are totally different from those of men. I’m particularly concerned about how the WI would protect women’s intimate spaces at venues from the presence of trans-indentifying men eg toilets. Under the Equality Act, the WI could easily apply the exclusion clause but could you be trusted to do it?

S
Stephanie Davies-Arai
3 years ago

Women have the right to their own organisations. This is not controversial. Please never pipe down, ladies of the WI.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

I would like to join the WI in the Scottish Borders but won't whilst you are including men.

S
Sarah-Jane Wilkinson
3 years ago

The Women's Institute is for women, not men no matter how they present themselves

J
Jean Jarvis
3 years ago

I am recently retired and was looking for a local WI group to join, but will not be doing so now

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

I am not currently a WI member, but my local branch is very active and I have considered joining. If the WI continues to embrace the idea that anyone can self-ID as a woman, it would put me off getting involved - if I'm joining a mixed sex community group, I'd prefer one that is honest about it.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

I’ve wanted to join the WI for quite sometime but the trans policy is something I feel strongly about and I can’t join while it is place

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

I do not believe that Shanu Varmu who is a trans activists should be eligible for membership of the WI. He is filled with hateful speech against women. The WI policy to allow trans women into your organisation will not help women to feel safe in their endeavours. Have you changed your Mem &Arts to allow all men into your organisation?