Skip to main content

A Vote on Trans Women Joining Women's Institutes

1,122 Comments

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

WI unfortunately would not be something I now could join as not an adult human female safe space

I
Ingrid Sykes
3 years ago

I joined my local WI last night and would welcome this discussion.

K
Karen Smyth
3 years ago

The WI should be for born women not men who are choosing to dress as if they are women.

A
Alison Howard
3 years ago

I’m in two WIs. They are a safe space for women. If men are allowed to join it will change the nature of the organisation.

B
Benedicte Newland
3 years ago

Men in any space change the dynamics for the women present.

T
Tracey Hammond
3 years ago

Women are not a bunch of clothing that you put on we have a biological reality. Men in any form will change the narrative.

A
Ann Rozier
3 years ago

We will not be silenced

C
Cherry Fielding
3 years ago

Woman should have spaces that are for biological females only. Men in any form should not be able to muscle in on our rights.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Women's Institute is a place where women go to chat, make friends and learn new skills, hobbies, volunteering etc. Conversations cover a wide range of topics from health, family, hobbies, volunteering etc. It is a place where women can meet, relax and enjoy each others company without the presence of men. Allowing men, regardless of how they identify, to join will change this special dynamic. I am currently looking at rejoining WI and being honest, if men are allowed to join I don't think I will bother. Men do not know how women feel, how society views them and I certainly don't want a man impersonating a woman and telling me he "understands how I feel" when he has no idea.

K
Karen Swanscott
3 years ago

I had considered joining but will not do so why this continues.

S
Shiella
3 years ago

No men in women's spaces.

L
Liz Loveridge
3 years ago

I really hope the WI reverses its current position on allowing males to join what should be a female group.

L
Lynn
3 years ago

I am woman, a biological female. Biological sex is important to safeguard women and their spaces. Women’s Institute should be for biological women only. I was about to join but now I will wait.

N
Nicola Hayes
3 years ago

Transwomen are MEN

D
Diane Lawler
3 years ago

Good luck

M
Maureen Hutchins
3 years ago

Having fought for women's equality, we need to ensure we retain safe spaces for women and girls

V
Victoria Williams
3 years ago

Women’s Institute - women only.

D
Debbie Evans
3 years ago

No biological man can become a biological woman - a feminine man yes but never a woman and therefore have no place in women-only spaces even if they have had the surgery.

K
Keturah Garvey
3 years ago

I am not a member of WI yet but imagine I might join my village branch in Ingatestone when I am older. The presence of men pretending to be women in the group would put me off to the extent that I would not join. Please change your policy to restrict membership to biologically female.

K
Kerry Berrisford
3 years ago

I was considering joining now I've retired. I am a little disappointed with the decisions made without membership vote.