Skip to main content

A Vote on Trans Women Joining Women's Institutes

1,122 Comments

P
Pat Woolliams
3 years ago

Little Marlow & Well End

A
Angela Dobb
3 years ago

Single sex exemptions are permitted under EA2010.

P
Pat Farr
3 years ago

Also what about being called ‘woman’ we are loosing our identity.

D
Denise Ward
3 years ago

The denial of the basic reality of sex in favour of a belief about gender is making women and girls less safe and able to achieve in certain spheres like sports. This is already being seen. Trans people of all types can be respected without eroding women’s spaces.

L
Lyndsey Snow
3 years ago

Men aren’t women, womanhood is not an identity. Women should have the right to gather freely without having to accommodate men and their “feelings”.

R
Rhona Anderson
3 years ago

Women need female only spaces. Nothing to stop trans people setting up their own organisations. Leave ours alone.

M
Ms Christine Holt
3 years ago

The WI was a much-valued sanctuary for my mum, who appreciated its mission to advance learning and education of women and girls away from the male gaze. Tragic that this haven for women has lost its purpose.

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Not currently a member due to "inclusive" policy

S
Sally W
3 years ago

Shocking that such an old and established women's organisation has become mixed sex. What a waste of resources, goodwill and opportunities for women.

E
Elena Markham
3 years ago

Keep the WI female!

A
Anonymous
3 years ago

Try asking a Vet if s/he would record the sex of an animal with a penis as a female and see how far you get. Biological males cannot become females. Why does this have to (keep) be(ing) explained ?!

B
Bronwen Davies
3 years ago

Good luck, sisters

K
Karen Fraser
3 years ago

Please don’t force this insane ideology on your membership. Let them have a vote on it!

C
Cindy
3 years ago

Women need to be protected in there private environments.

S
Sian Griffiths
3 years ago

Thank you for doing this. It is reallyy shocking how many people just don't understand what is happening. Prioritising gender (social construct of stereotypes) above biological reality is frankly ridiculous, and puts women's rights back decade's.

C
Catherine S Davies
3 years ago

Abhorrent to even think of the WI allowing biological men to join.

J
James Mills
3 years ago

I support the maintenance of WOMEN-only spaces and advocacy organizations.

K
Kate C
3 years ago

'Transwomen' are men so they of course shouldn't be allowed in.

R
Roby Bone
3 years ago

WI should not be mixed sexed by definition WI. Do we really have to explain this?!

E
Evelyn Strasburger
3 years ago

If the women of the WI are happy to include transwomen, then that would be fine, although I would suggest a change of name to be clear, but they should be given the choice. The philosophical belief that transwomen are women is not universal, and to base a material change in the membership on the basis of this belief is grossly unfair without reference to the current members. This is very underhand work by the committee, although typical of the gains achieved by the trans movement - don't ask those affected and call them bigots if they complain.