This article has several good points about the safety of women:
http://thefederalist.com/2015/11/23/a-rape-survivor-speaks-out-about-transgender-bathrooms/
Also... Why not have the option of single occupancy stalls?
R
Roxanne Shackle
10 years ago
All should be treated with dignity and respect. Please respect the needs of all your patrons. Just as you would ask that a mother or father visiting with children of multiple ages and genders, use the family locker room, it would be appropriate to ask transgender etc. to use the family locker room.
C
Chris Vance
10 years ago
I am a former South Family YMCA member and Kids Stuff staff person
D
Danell Rudquist
10 years ago
We are members of the YMCA and will reconsider our membership if lockerrooms are open to anyone based on their gender identity not their biological sex.
G
Gerry Chapdelaine
10 years ago
After visiting with the office director, I think trans gender males or females should use the family changing room since there are locked rooms for changing and showering. When a transcender male is "in the process' as the term was used, there are too many women who are completely nude when such a person walks around the locker room. have them use the family private rooms please.
S
Sarah Gibson
10 years ago
As a former employee, I'm glad I'm not working there any longer if this is the direction they are heading.
I'm remembering back to middle school and how awkward it was to be going through all the changes that go along with puberty. It was awkward being around other girls who were going through the same thing. I can't even imagine what it would be like to be forced to use a GIRLS locker room or bathroom with people who have not and will never go through the same changes I was going through.
C
Cathy Thooft
10 years ago
Gender may be a personal thing which is a personal thing. But in public places only biology can be observed, thus we have male and female bathrooms and showers. If you start letting people go into whatever room they want, you just increase the opportunities for abuse to happen. This just open the Y to more lawsuit. It is a bad policy
A
Ann Hill United States
10 years ago
As a teacher I can tell you that the idea of letting someone "pick their gender" is extremely damaging and confusing to children. The YMCA used to be known for its moral compass; but you have now lost it, by trading it in for "political correctness."
C
Cathy Thooft
10 years ago
I am concerned for safety for minors, there is too much room for abuse of this privilege. Is the YMCA going to screen any background checks? As an adult woman, do my privacy rights get infringed upon too?
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
How does the YMCA prevent a young pervert from taking advantage of this policy?
P
Patrick Phillips
10 years ago
This proposed action is an abomination.
M
Monica Duffy
10 years ago
Featured
For Muslim women, where is the accommodation? Their faith prohibits being seen undressed by a male that is not their husband. Some will not even visit a male doctor. Do you have any families that are practicing Muslims at your location?
S
Stephen Miller
10 years ago
Liberalism is a mental disease.
K
Karen Schultz
10 years ago
I would never support or join a Y (or any other gym) with this policy in place.
S
Susan Zappa
10 years ago
Our youngest daughter recently visited the Hastings Y to pick up an application to join. This WILL NOT happen now. We will not risk her safety & human dignity. Sex has EVERYTHING to do with genitalia. What a ridiculous comment to make!
J
Julie L Carlson
10 years ago
I am a YMCA member and cannot understand this new policy. The rights of many are going to be violated for the rights of a few. This is ridiculous.
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
I will no longer be a Y member if this occurs
G
Gerry Chapdelaine
10 years ago
Do not allow males above5 years of age to use the women's locker room. I will join another club if you do this.
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
My family will never attend the Y again if this policy is enacted.
Thank you
P
Pat
10 years ago
This is insane, and we wonder where morality went in our country?
This article has several good points about the safety of women: http://thefederalist.com/2015/11/23/a-rape-survivor-speaks-out-about-transgender-bathrooms/ Also... Why not have the option of single occupancy stalls?
All should be treated with dignity and respect. Please respect the needs of all your patrons. Just as you would ask that a mother or father visiting with children of multiple ages and genders, use the family locker room, it would be appropriate to ask transgender etc. to use the family locker room.
I am a former South Family YMCA member and Kids Stuff staff person
We are members of the YMCA and will reconsider our membership if lockerrooms are open to anyone based on their gender identity not their biological sex.
After visiting with the office director, I think trans gender males or females should use the family changing room since there are locked rooms for changing and showering. When a transcender male is "in the process' as the term was used, there are too many women who are completely nude when such a person walks around the locker room. have them use the family private rooms please.
As a former employee, I'm glad I'm not working there any longer if this is the direction they are heading. I'm remembering back to middle school and how awkward it was to be going through all the changes that go along with puberty. It was awkward being around other girls who were going through the same thing. I can't even imagine what it would be like to be forced to use a GIRLS locker room or bathroom with people who have not and will never go through the same changes I was going through.
Gender may be a personal thing which is a personal thing. But in public places only biology can be observed, thus we have male and female bathrooms and showers. If you start letting people go into whatever room they want, you just increase the opportunities for abuse to happen. This just open the Y to more lawsuit. It is a bad policy
As a teacher I can tell you that the idea of letting someone "pick their gender" is extremely damaging and confusing to children. The YMCA used to be known for its moral compass; but you have now lost it, by trading it in for "political correctness."
I am concerned for safety for minors, there is too much room for abuse of this privilege. Is the YMCA going to screen any background checks? As an adult woman, do my privacy rights get infringed upon too?
How does the YMCA prevent a young pervert from taking advantage of this policy?
This proposed action is an abomination.
For Muslim women, where is the accommodation? Their faith prohibits being seen undressed by a male that is not their husband. Some will not even visit a male doctor. Do you have any families that are practicing Muslims at your location?
Liberalism is a mental disease.
I would never support or join a Y (or any other gym) with this policy in place.
Our youngest daughter recently visited the Hastings Y to pick up an application to join. This WILL NOT happen now. We will not risk her safety & human dignity. Sex has EVERYTHING to do with genitalia. What a ridiculous comment to make!
I am a YMCA member and cannot understand this new policy. The rights of many are going to be violated for the rights of a few. This is ridiculous.
I will no longer be a Y member if this occurs
Do not allow males above5 years of age to use the women's locker room. I will join another club if you do this.
My family will never attend the Y again if this policy is enacted. Thank you
This is insane, and we wonder where morality went in our country?