Stop Development of Large Senior Living Facility Across from Beechwood Farms
97 Comments
P
Palma T Constantin
7 years ago
I am opposed to this facility! It is not in keeping with land use in our area. I would support thoughtful housing for seniors, but not a building/facility.
C
Carol and Tim O'Connor
7 years ago
Agree that this development should be prevented from occurring for all the reasons mentioned.
K
Ken Debbe Kotchey
7 years ago
Beechwood Farms is an interest for many customers that come from urban areas to enjoy the peacefulness and beauty of our township. Building this facility will destroy this and have a negative impact on the environment. Not only visually, but the constant noise of the delivery trucks during the day and off hours, the HVAC equipment running, and the increase in traffic. The intersection of Harts Run and Dorseyville Road is extremely busy now. This facility will not only increase traffic during rush hour and school hours but will have a constant stream of traffic with visitors and deliveries during "all" hours of the day. Installing a traffic light to handle the amount of traffic this facility will produce will have to be considered. This once again will affect the residence living in that area with light and noise pollution! There are other locations in Indiana Township that are zoned for commercial development. Please consider how this will affect our community!
K
Keith lewis
7 years ago
Not the area for something of this size
A
Andrea Criscella
7 years ago
Its not a good thing to loose more space for wildlife than is necessary
A
Angie Gale
7 years ago
don't do it
A
Audrey Rambo
7 years ago
Please do not build this here, please find another location suited for this it will ruin the environment.
J
James J Staszewski
7 years ago
Enforce existing zoning requirements.
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
This complex (let's call it what it is) will ruin the current ecosystem. How can anyone suggest this monstrosity across from a Nature Reserve won't harm the natural balance already in place? Let's hope many land and water studies are done and results aren't skewed for those with deep pockets. Is there a rule or law that states a Nature Reserve must have some type of boundary that prohibits development?
M
Maureen Anderson
7 years ago
I am opposed to this project!
R
roshan koozekanani
7 years ago
This development is absolutely not harmonious to its surroundings. This is a quiet residential area, not a four lane, busy, commercial intersection that is meant for a three story building housing close to 200 residents, over 150 parking spaces, food vendors, laundry services and more features coming and going from this facility. The traffic is already busy at peak hours without adding further to this situation. Plus, stormwater and flooding is already an issue in areas close by. There has been severe floodwater damage to at least two parks in Fox Chapel, just a few miles away.
M
Mariann Geyer
7 years ago
The petition makes valid points. There are other alternatives for a large scale development that would fit within existing zoning guidelines.
A
Anonymous Anonymous
7 years ago
Please don’t screw up the trail in my backyard with a hideous building and parking lot.
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
Traffic will be a HUGE issue with no other access points except Dorseyville Rd, It was an issue at other facility in Peters Twp and the Waters in Wexford has additional access roads and entry points for all of the visitors, staff and delivery trucks. This is in addition to the 4-6 lane highway of Rt. 19. An article from the Peters Twp paper on the traffic issue: https://observer-reporter.com/news/localnews/developer-calls-traffic-related-demand-unreasonable-appeals-to-court/article_175ec36a-fd3e-11e7-82f6-8b0f64a9a6c1.html
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
Traffic will be a HUGE issue if this facility is approved. There are no other access points or roads for residents, visitors, staff or trucks. It is an issue in Peters Twp, see attached article: https://observer-reporter.com/news/localnews/developer-calls-traffic-related-demand-unreasonable-appeals-to-court/article_175ec36a-fd3e-11e7-82f6-8b0f64a9a6c1.html
P
Paul Schmitt
7 years ago
This development must comply with the current zoning requirements, period.
B
Bill Staley RLA and LEED AP
7 years ago
As a registered landscape architect and LEED accredited professional, I can say with complete certainty that a zoning variance should NOT be granted in this situation. Not only is the scenic character of the area going to be permanently marred, but a development of this size will also have impacts on stormwater management in an already troubled watershed (it will impact neighboring Fox Chapel, have they been consulted on this?) as well as property values in Indiana Township and Fox Chapel. As others have correctly pointed out, there will be traffic impacts as well.
Allowing this development to move forward will be a significant step back for the community, and any community leadership (especially the zoning office) should think long and VERY hard about this one.
D
David Fowler
7 years ago
ALREADY A DANGEROUS INTERSECTION! INCREASED TRAFFIC WOULD INCREASE RISKS DRAMATICALLY!
S
Steve huegel
7 years ago
I agree with the comments made by many others. I recognize that growth will happen but this is much too large and would have a very deleterious impact on the area. Thank everybody who is on this petition!
G
Grace m mcgorrian
7 years ago
Featured
This is a poor use of one of the existing green spaces in Indiana township. It would detract from the stunning Audubon facility at Beechwood and ultimately reduce property values and thus tax basis.
I am opposed to this facility! It is not in keeping with land use in our area. I would support thoughtful housing for seniors, but not a building/facility.
Agree that this development should be prevented from occurring for all the reasons mentioned.
Beechwood Farms is an interest for many customers that come from urban areas to enjoy the peacefulness and beauty of our township. Building this facility will destroy this and have a negative impact on the environment. Not only visually, but the constant noise of the delivery trucks during the day and off hours, the HVAC equipment running, and the increase in traffic. The intersection of Harts Run and Dorseyville Road is extremely busy now. This facility will not only increase traffic during rush hour and school hours but will have a constant stream of traffic with visitors and deliveries during "all" hours of the day. Installing a traffic light to handle the amount of traffic this facility will produce will have to be considered. This once again will affect the residence living in that area with light and noise pollution! There are other locations in Indiana Township that are zoned for commercial development. Please consider how this will affect our community!
Not the area for something of this size
Its not a good thing to loose more space for wildlife than is necessary
don't do it
Please do not build this here, please find another location suited for this it will ruin the environment.
Enforce existing zoning requirements.
This complex (let's call it what it is) will ruin the current ecosystem. How can anyone suggest this monstrosity across from a Nature Reserve won't harm the natural balance already in place? Let's hope many land and water studies are done and results aren't skewed for those with deep pockets. Is there a rule or law that states a Nature Reserve must have some type of boundary that prohibits development?
I am opposed to this project!
This development is absolutely not harmonious to its surroundings. This is a quiet residential area, not a four lane, busy, commercial intersection that is meant for a three story building housing close to 200 residents, over 150 parking spaces, food vendors, laundry services and more features coming and going from this facility. The traffic is already busy at peak hours without adding further to this situation. Plus, stormwater and flooding is already an issue in areas close by. There has been severe floodwater damage to at least two parks in Fox Chapel, just a few miles away.
The petition makes valid points. There are other alternatives for a large scale development that would fit within existing zoning guidelines.
Please don’t screw up the trail in my backyard with a hideous building and parking lot.
Traffic will be a HUGE issue with no other access points except Dorseyville Rd, It was an issue at other facility in Peters Twp and the Waters in Wexford has additional access roads and entry points for all of the visitors, staff and delivery trucks. This is in addition to the 4-6 lane highway of Rt. 19. An article from the Peters Twp paper on the traffic issue: https://observer-reporter.com/news/localnews/developer-calls-traffic-related-demand-unreasonable-appeals-to-court/article_175ec36a-fd3e-11e7-82f6-8b0f64a9a6c1.html
Traffic will be a HUGE issue if this facility is approved. There are no other access points or roads for residents, visitors, staff or trucks. It is an issue in Peters Twp, see attached article: https://observer-reporter.com/news/localnews/developer-calls-traffic-related-demand-unreasonable-appeals-to-court/article_175ec36a-fd3e-11e7-82f6-8b0f64a9a6c1.html
This development must comply with the current zoning requirements, period.
As a registered landscape architect and LEED accredited professional, I can say with complete certainty that a zoning variance should NOT be granted in this situation. Not only is the scenic character of the area going to be permanently marred, but a development of this size will also have impacts on stormwater management in an already troubled watershed (it will impact neighboring Fox Chapel, have they been consulted on this?) as well as property values in Indiana Township and Fox Chapel. As others have correctly pointed out, there will be traffic impacts as well. Allowing this development to move forward will be a significant step back for the community, and any community leadership (especially the zoning office) should think long and VERY hard about this one.
ALREADY A DANGEROUS INTERSECTION! INCREASED TRAFFIC WOULD INCREASE RISKS DRAMATICALLY!
I agree with the comments made by many others. I recognize that growth will happen but this is much too large and would have a very deleterious impact on the area. Thank everybody who is on this petition!
This is a poor use of one of the existing green spaces in Indiana township. It would detract from the stunning Audubon facility at Beechwood and ultimately reduce property values and thus tax basis.