Please do not cut down the beautiful Cottonwood tree
F
Freya Weissner
10 years ago
This beautiful Cotttonwood tree should be able to live out its life. It is not a danger but should be protected, not destroyed
T
Ted Mouras
10 years ago
There has to be a way to protect the public and protect this tree, which has long served as an icon for the SPRNCA. Fencing is the answer.
J
Joanne Swolak
10 years ago
Best comment yet! Thank you!
R
Robert J Luce
10 years ago
I agree with BLM that this tree is in decline, but fencing it to protect both the tree and the public is the best answer. In that way we, the public, get to enjoy seeing the tree as long as it is around, but are protected from limb failure. I suggest a scientific study to document the stages of decline so the data can be used to project future options on other similar trees.
J
John Lowry
10 years ago
This tree has been an important part of the scenery and the experience of the visit to this iconic birding spot for a very long time. There is no reason to destroy it. Cottonwoods, especially aged ones with nooks and crannies, are very important for nesting birds and other animals in addition to the food and shade resource they provide.
If you are worried about the danger of this tree, you are worrying too much. May as well fence off the river and pave the paths too, in case someone should fall.
J
Jeremey Caron
10 years ago
I love how people just think they can decide to destroy something that's been alive longer then them.
M
Mareena Anderson
10 years ago
This beautiful tree should be protected, not destroyed.
J
Joan Richardson
10 years ago
I've visited this tree for years and felt it's aura and strength. Please let it be!
G
Gabriel Lewis
10 years ago
Myself and many friends played on this tree as children. It's become a part of the history of the San Pedro, and of the surrounding community. Protection of what little natural beauty we have in this area, and protection of our environment as a whole, is a lesson many children are taught, but few seem to learn. Prioritise convenience over the environment and children will learn that the nature is a nuisance.
N
Nicholas Night
10 years ago
Please DO NOT cut down this tree, it's power as an attractor of visitors FAR OUTWEIGHS any short term benefits from cutting it down!
R
Rachel Greensmith-Annino
10 years ago
I have very fond memories of going to the San Pedro house and climbing all over that tree. It was my favorite thing to do there. I would be very sad to know that future generations would not get to play and learn around that tree.
N
nancy
10 years ago
Don't cut it down!!!!!
T
Tiffany Angela Hooper
10 years ago
Why is this even something that is being considered? This is a conservation area, and cutting down a tree will not be tolerated.
V
Vincent Weber
10 years ago
Seriously? How many more trees need to fall at the hands of men to no benefit?
B
Barbara Jones
10 years ago
Please don't cut this precious tree down
D
Doug Hulmes
10 years ago
One of the largest cottonwoods in Arizona. Why would you cut down this amazing tree?
T
Tierra Chapman
10 years ago
This is a magnificent being who provides beauty and shade while cleansing the air your breathe. Who in their right mind or heart would kill such an old friend?
K
Karen Worcester
10 years ago
Save this landmark tree!!
D
Donna Joyce
10 years ago
Please do not destroy a living monument to the earth.
Please do not cut down the beautiful Cottonwood tree
This beautiful Cotttonwood tree should be able to live out its life. It is not a danger but should be protected, not destroyed
There has to be a way to protect the public and protect this tree, which has long served as an icon for the SPRNCA. Fencing is the answer.
Best comment yet! Thank you!
I agree with BLM that this tree is in decline, but fencing it to protect both the tree and the public is the best answer. In that way we, the public, get to enjoy seeing the tree as long as it is around, but are protected from limb failure. I suggest a scientific study to document the stages of decline so the data can be used to project future options on other similar trees.
This tree has been an important part of the scenery and the experience of the visit to this iconic birding spot for a very long time. There is no reason to destroy it. Cottonwoods, especially aged ones with nooks and crannies, are very important for nesting birds and other animals in addition to the food and shade resource they provide. If you are worried about the danger of this tree, you are worrying too much. May as well fence off the river and pave the paths too, in case someone should fall.
I love how people just think they can decide to destroy something that's been alive longer then them.
This beautiful tree should be protected, not destroyed.
I've visited this tree for years and felt it's aura and strength. Please let it be!
Myself and many friends played on this tree as children. It's become a part of the history of the San Pedro, and of the surrounding community. Protection of what little natural beauty we have in this area, and protection of our environment as a whole, is a lesson many children are taught, but few seem to learn. Prioritise convenience over the environment and children will learn that the nature is a nuisance.
Please DO NOT cut down this tree, it's power as an attractor of visitors FAR OUTWEIGHS any short term benefits from cutting it down!
I have very fond memories of going to the San Pedro house and climbing all over that tree. It was my favorite thing to do there. I would be very sad to know that future generations would not get to play and learn around that tree.
Don't cut it down!!!!!
Why is this even something that is being considered? This is a conservation area, and cutting down a tree will not be tolerated.
Seriously? How many more trees need to fall at the hands of men to no benefit?
Please don't cut this precious tree down
One of the largest cottonwoods in Arizona. Why would you cut down this amazing tree?
This is a magnificent being who provides beauty and shade while cleansing the air your breathe. Who in their right mind or heart would kill such an old friend?
Save this landmark tree!!
Please do not destroy a living monument to the earth.