Skip to main content

Protect Organic- Prohibit Hydroponics

815 Comments

A
Anonymous

Hydroponic crops should not be labeled organic.

V
Virginia Waldron

Organic is ONLY pure water, pure soil- no unnatural or toxic additives. I know that food growers understand this. Nothing left to say or argue about.

P
Patricia Benjamin

Organics is about building soil. Thousands of people have worked for decades to make "Organic" mean something. Why is the USDA destroying that?

L
Linda

No to hydroponics labeled organic, and absolutely NO to glyphosate!

D
Debbie Almon

Follow the guidelines and do your job!!!! If not, move on and allow someone else that will protect us and the guidelines!

V
Vincent Coniglio

Label it correctly. You are doing a disservice to the people by bending to the will of big money.

M
Monique Kourdae

Organic is soil produced (period).

A
Angela

The definition of organic should not change NO MATTER what new technology or inventions come to market.

C
Cat ernst

Protect organic stop hydroponics

N
Nancy Oden

Hydroponically grown food can never be called USDA Organic or labeled as such. To do so violates the laws already in place for organic certification! Violation of their own law by members our own USDA says something bordering on criminality and legal action!

S
Sue

Keep organic organic. Not sure how the rules got manipulated, but it needs to be undone....

R
Roark Vane

I will not buy hydroponically grown food--it is not grown in soil. The infusion of minerals and trace elements from the soil cannot be duplicated by hydroponic growing methods.

S
Susan

Organically grown crops are, by definition, grown in soil - rich, living soil. Remove organic certification from hydroponic crops, which are not nutrient-rich organisms nurtured by living soil.

S
Susan Lea

NO NONORGANIC TOXIC STUFF EVER ANYWHERE NEED GROWTH OF FOOD/FRUIT/PRODUCE.

M
marle Vane

This is a must.

S
Sally Jane Gellert

Hydroponics do nothing to improve our soil, use a vast quantity not only of water but of fertilizers and often toxic pesticides (glyphosate, for one). Hydroponically-grown foods cannot be considered organic under the current law; they should certainly be labelled “hydroponically grown”.

J
Jeanne Fleigle

NO Hydroponics classified as organic. They are not organic’s.

R
Ross

Predatory corporations constantly seeking loopholes and backdoors to exploit the world for profit. USDA stop undermining the organic label!

B
Barb

Keep it clean

C
Cindy Koch

Why can’t we just have real food in America?! Stop messing w/it!!