Prevent the 92nd St Y Gala from being traif (for first time)
357 Comments
A
Anonymous
9 years ago
Horrific
A
Anonymous
9 years ago
Only Kosher!!
A
Anonymous
9 years ago
WHAT A DISGRACE !!!!!!
N
nechama gross
9 years ago
you should not represent the jewish people when you are clearly embarrassed to be one.
our torah and it's laws, our jewish homeland is what keeps us together.
do not claim to be a jew, represent jews when feeding all of us treif. SHAME ON YOU!!!
A
Anonymous
9 years ago
If your represent yourself as an orginization serving/representing the greater jewish community of nyc, It behooves you to serve only kosher food at your official event.
A
Anonymous
9 years ago
Why not be all inclusive and make sure these events stay kosher? What loss is there to the "Y". Really do not understand.
A
Anonymous
9 years ago
outrageous
M
Mark Breiner
9 years ago
Be honest tell them it is not kosher and see how few will show up
M
Mark Lands
9 years ago
Shame on you to use tactics that divide jews. There must be at least 500 kosher caterers in the New York metropolitan area. It's only a self hating Jew that could've come up with such an idea.
While the text of this petition might be a bit too harsh, the Y should seriously consider changing its event even at this late date.
The reasons Jewishly affiliated organizations should only host events where dietary laws are observed (and inclusive laws, not avant-garde interpretations from the left coast) are too obvious and innumerable to list.
It seems self-evident that an inclusive Jewishly identified institution would want to host only Kosher events regardless of the predilections of its members and most attendees.
A
arthur miller
9 years ago
a bowal movement has more worth than the vile reform movement. Many of its memebers aren't even Jewish. AND I AM NOT FRUM
S
Shelley Fox
9 years ago
Please do not discriminate & infringe on the strict dietary requirements which torah observant jews need to follow.
B
Binnie Stein
9 years ago
"Kosher Style" is not Kosher. Even if you use Vegetarian or Fish, it doesn't matter, according to the Tanach. Find a Kosher Caterer who will suit all of your needs AND your wallet.
E
Ellen Drandoff
9 years ago
Keep it kosher!!!
G
Gary Buchwald
9 years ago
This is an outrage and demonstrates that the JCC wishes to distance itself from Conservative & Orthodox Jews.
D
Daniel Kronengold
9 years ago
Featured
As a teen volunteer at the Y in the 90's, I (and other kosher keeping individuals) were generously accommodated by our supervisor making the gala event kosher. I hope the Y will continue to be accommodating to kosher-keepers at its Dinner.
S
Sidney Ingber
9 years ago
The 92nd Street Y has always been the most inclusive institution without drawing attention to religious observance or lack thereof. By deviating from long established practice of kosher catering for all we are displaying observance or non-observance in the public square and creating division in the "Y" for all to see, which never was there before.
It is really sad to see the clock being turned back to a time long gone when a schism in the Jewish community was purposely created in exactly the same way. Hopefully history will not be repeated.
R
Rabbi Joseph Kolakowski
9 years ago
I generally feel I should mind my own business in such manners, as I try to be a tolerant person, but this is a disgrace and insult.
Horrific
Only Kosher!!
WHAT A DISGRACE !!!!!!
you should not represent the jewish people when you are clearly embarrassed to be one. our torah and it's laws, our jewish homeland is what keeps us together. do not claim to be a jew, represent jews when feeding all of us treif. SHAME ON YOU!!!
If your represent yourself as an orginization serving/representing the greater jewish community of nyc, It behooves you to serve only kosher food at your official event.
Why not be all inclusive and make sure these events stay kosher? What loss is there to the "Y". Really do not understand.
outrageous
Be honest tell them it is not kosher and see how few will show up
Shame on you to use tactics that divide jews. There must be at least 500 kosher caterers in the New York metropolitan area. It's only a self hating Jew that could've come up with such an idea.
Horrifying! http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/featured/1272547/grave-threat-judaism-op-ed.html
Please, respect your Jewish identity.
While the text of this petition might be a bit too harsh, the Y should seriously consider changing its event even at this late date. The reasons Jewishly affiliated organizations should only host events where dietary laws are observed (and inclusive laws, not avant-garde interpretations from the left coast) are too obvious and innumerable to list. It seems self-evident that an inclusive Jewishly identified institution would want to host only Kosher events regardless of the predilections of its members and most attendees.
a bowal movement has more worth than the vile reform movement. Many of its memebers aren't even Jewish. AND I AM NOT FRUM
Please do not discriminate & infringe on the strict dietary requirements which torah observant jews need to follow.
"Kosher Style" is not Kosher. Even if you use Vegetarian or Fish, it doesn't matter, according to the Tanach. Find a Kosher Caterer who will suit all of your needs AND your wallet.
Keep it kosher!!!
This is an outrage and demonstrates that the JCC wishes to distance itself from Conservative & Orthodox Jews.
As a teen volunteer at the Y in the 90's, I (and other kosher keeping individuals) were generously accommodated by our supervisor making the gala event kosher. I hope the Y will continue to be accommodating to kosher-keepers at its Dinner.
The 92nd Street Y has always been the most inclusive institution without drawing attention to religious observance or lack thereof. By deviating from long established practice of kosher catering for all we are displaying observance or non-observance in the public square and creating division in the "Y" for all to see, which never was there before. It is really sad to see the clock being turned back to a time long gone when a schism in the Jewish community was purposely created in exactly the same way. Hopefully history will not be repeated.
I generally feel I should mind my own business in such manners, as I try to be a tolerant person, but this is a disgrace and insult.