No Generative AI At Berklee- Disband Bots, Beats and Bytes
721 Comments
E
E E
I am not a student, I am not even an artist. I am just an average human who wants to enjoy music created by humans.
S
Shannon Bateman
AI shouldn't be used to create music, let alone be taught. It takes away creativity from musicians and takes it away from people who actually want to work and create their own piece of music.
P
Princess Udom
AI providing a “simpler” way to make music is the complete opposite of what making music is about, musicians passionately spend their time and money acquiring skills in a society that ALREADY undervalues them. I believe AI to be a tool that, more often than not, disenfranchises artists, stealing art without consent and regurgitating what it took. AI seems like a way for people to stay risk averse in a field that requires you to show up as an imperfect human. It has no place at Berklee.
R
Reza August
AI does not belong in arts. Especially in academy that arts
M
Max Heinsohn
Music is about the making
A
Ashley Garland
I was 4 classes away from graduating. I dropped out because this is that important to me. It all became worthless to me overnight. I’d come back if Berklee apologized for partnering w/Suno, removed its GenAI classes, and the president resigned. I’m not holding my breath though.
C
Charlie Roethlisberger
I am a highschooler who's dream has always been going to Berklee and this is horrifying. This is supposed to be ART not PLAGIARISM. Art is personal. This ruins everything
J
Jenia Garcia
Art is an individual characteristic. The goal isn’t to be the better than everyone- but rather to enjoy and express. Of course it takes time- it’s a skill. The point of life isn’t wasting time but continuous effort and growth. Art isn’t always going to be enjoyed by everyone. That’s why it’s created. For the individual, for self expression. And when others resonate, it’s something that’s felt.
that’s what it is- They don’t want us to gather together.
S
Sachin Jacobraj
GenAI must never be considered for Art, The human is what makes art 'Art'
B
Bre’niyah Hernandez
Ai is something that doesn’t deserve to be apart of music. It takes away the creativity and art of music and should not be allowed
G
Geovanny Orihuela
Music is a portal to creativity. Being able to pour your heart and soul out into your own creation and tell people astory and express emotion. Artificial intelligence doesn’t belong in any fine art space.
E
Elim Sutton
Cause music is about art, human creation. Not ai making it for them
A
Ally H
AI can’t create anything, it can only take what has already been made and alter it. That’s not art, that’s just stealing.
L
Leon Garner
Music has heart and soul, ai can't replicate the feeling of a song and the expression it brings
L
Lara Mcgrann
I am a young musician, making music is not about the product, it’s about the journey. Creating melodies, adding to them, creating something that is uniquely yours. Music is about human emotion, musicality and talent. The future of music is NOT ai, it is human art and souls. it disgusts me to see this being taught.
A
Andreas Pinterits
I love, create, consume and pay for a lot of music. And I'm not technophobe, in fact I worked in technology most my career. But I abhor AI slop! Get Suno out of Berkelee!
B
Ben Tull
If we teach people to be the client rather than the artist, the ability to make art skips a generation. If the ability to make art skips a generation, then we lose art. If we lose art, what do we have?
P
Paige Bowers
It’s is an unfathomable idea that as a school as prestigious as Berkeley would even consider teaching AI music in their school. It’s frankly embarrassing. AI music is not music and takes no skill to create, real music is an art form that takes hard work and dedication. It’s actually quite disturbing to think that this is where the future of music is headed. Absolutely screw this.
S
Shohei Hasegawa
I am not necessarily anti-AI. In fact, I believe that AI will undoubtedly have a significant impact on all fields, including music.
However, I don't think students at schools like Berklee need to take classes that simply use AI to generate a song. The way AI is used in these classes does not seem to make students better at playing or creating music. And, to be honest, what are you going to do? Bring your AI to gigs?
I am not a student, I am not even an artist. I am just an average human who wants to enjoy music created by humans.
AI shouldn't be used to create music, let alone be taught. It takes away creativity from musicians and takes it away from people who actually want to work and create their own piece of music.
AI providing a “simpler” way to make music is the complete opposite of what making music is about, musicians passionately spend their time and money acquiring skills in a society that ALREADY undervalues them. I believe AI to be a tool that, more often than not, disenfranchises artists, stealing art without consent and regurgitating what it took. AI seems like a way for people to stay risk averse in a field that requires you to show up as an imperfect human. It has no place at Berklee.
AI does not belong in arts. Especially in academy that arts
Music is about the making
I was 4 classes away from graduating. I dropped out because this is that important to me. It all became worthless to me overnight. I’d come back if Berklee apologized for partnering w/Suno, removed its GenAI classes, and the president resigned. I’m not holding my breath though.
I am a highschooler who's dream has always been going to Berklee and this is horrifying. This is supposed to be ART not PLAGIARISM. Art is personal. This ruins everything
Art is an individual characteristic. The goal isn’t to be the better than everyone- but rather to enjoy and express. Of course it takes time- it’s a skill. The point of life isn’t wasting time but continuous effort and growth. Art isn’t always going to be enjoyed by everyone. That’s why it’s created. For the individual, for self expression. And when others resonate, it’s something that’s felt. that’s what it is- They don’t want us to gather together.
GenAI must never be considered for Art, The human is what makes art 'Art'
Ai is something that doesn’t deserve to be apart of music. It takes away the creativity and art of music and should not be allowed
Music is a portal to creativity. Being able to pour your heart and soul out into your own creation and tell people astory and express emotion. Artificial intelligence doesn’t belong in any fine art space.
Cause music is about art, human creation. Not ai making it for them
AI can’t create anything, it can only take what has already been made and alter it. That’s not art, that’s just stealing.
Music has heart and soul, ai can't replicate the feeling of a song and the expression it brings
I am a young musician, making music is not about the product, it’s about the journey. Creating melodies, adding to them, creating something that is uniquely yours. Music is about human emotion, musicality and talent. The future of music is NOT ai, it is human art and souls. it disgusts me to see this being taught.
I love, create, consume and pay for a lot of music. And I'm not technophobe, in fact I worked in technology most my career. But I abhor AI slop! Get Suno out of Berkelee!
If we teach people to be the client rather than the artist, the ability to make art skips a generation. If the ability to make art skips a generation, then we lose art. If we lose art, what do we have?
It’s is an unfathomable idea that as a school as prestigious as Berkeley would even consider teaching AI music in their school. It’s frankly embarrassing. AI music is not music and takes no skill to create, real music is an art form that takes hard work and dedication. It’s actually quite disturbing to think that this is where the future of music is headed. Absolutely screw this.
I am not necessarily anti-AI. In fact, I believe that AI will undoubtedly have a significant impact on all fields, including music. However, I don't think students at schools like Berklee need to take classes that simply use AI to generate a song. The way AI is used in these classes does not seem to make students better at playing or creating music. And, to be honest, what are you going to do? Bring your AI to gigs?
disband "Bots, Beats and Bytes"