Keep Milli Hill as Keynote Speaker at Midwifery Conference
1,001 Comments
J
Julie Stacey
5 years ago
Milli Hill is an exceptional advocate for women and mothers.
K
Kelly Mills
5 years ago
Don’t erase women!!
S
Samantha Haycock
5 years ago
Only women get pregnant and only women give birth. This is not a controversial or hateful view.
C
Catherine Bell
5 years ago
Milli Hill has long stood for human rights in childbirth. Her work is of great value to all.
L
Lorraine Hart
5 years ago
Biology is real
C
Candice Jackson
5 years ago
I’d sign a petition not to cancel someone with whom I deeply disagree, too. Let free discussion of critical topics occur.
A
Amanda Kenwrick
5 years ago
Men can’t get pregnant. Biology is clear. Only 2 sexes and neither can be changed. Anyone who doesn’t understand and accept these facts should not be working in healthcare of any sort, let alone midwifery.
K
Kathleen Beegan
5 years ago
Women give birth and breastfeed, why are women still so marginalised.
K
Kay Barton
5 years ago
It is ridiculous to cancel Milli Hill, a respected midwife and writer, because a few people don't like her politics. Of course she knows the difference between women and men.
L
Lorraine Simpson
5 years ago
Who'd have thought we would have to petition for the right to speak the truth. Solidarity Milli
B
Beccy
5 years ago
I do not understand this current war against women fought under the guise of exclusion which is in fact excluding a sex class that near enough makes up 50% of the world's population. Why do you want to erase women and the lived experience of women? How on earth on the 21st century, in a so called civilised democracy, is an anti scientific anti sex based rights agenda being pushed so forcefully with huge sanctions against those who dare speak out?
D
Dawn Mercer
5 years ago
I have read the counter petition to this and I can see that the writers misrepresented what Milli Hill has said and are somewhat confused themselves about the difference between sex and gender identity and sexed and gendered language. I think that they would benefit from an open good-faith conversation with Milli and that perhaps if such could occur they may find a lot of common ground. I hope that the New Zealand College of Midwives is encouraged by this petition. Perhaps, given the misunderstanding evident in the petition, it would be a good thing for them to include an additional session to allow Milli to present her actual views and a conversation could ensue.
P
Patricia Spencer
5 years ago
It's beggars belief that this gender ideology has infiltrated everything that should be centred on (biological) women.
S
Sandra Hamilton
5 years ago
Only females can get pregnant. It's a biological fact. Statement of fact is not hatred.
J
Julie Ann Alderman
5 years ago
Everyone who is, or ever been, on this planet came from A Woman: Adult Human Female. I am offended at my reality being erased, and not being allowed to talk openly about my self and my life experience. You cannot force me to accept the religious cult ideologies that males can also get pregnant, give birth and breast feed. A person can only do that if they have female sexual organs. Somewhere a billionaire may already be cloning,
H
Helen Donaldson
5 years ago
It's hard to imagine ever forgiving the organisations that have the needs and interests of women as their core and defining purposes, yet who have so comprehensively failed in that purpose that they willingly embrace the misogynist notion that being a woman is not even a real, material thing. Solidarity with Milli
E
Emilie Carrington
5 years ago
I wish she'd been my midwife rather than the ones I did have. You should be getting her in front of as many midwives as possible not deplatforming her. While Scandal after scandal emerges about how badly women in labour are treated all I see are midwives are tying themselves in knots over whether it's women who give birth. Listen to her - women want you to.
A
Anonymous
5 years ago
Stating facts is not transphobic, and factual sex based language is imperitive to effective midwifery.
A
Anonymous
5 years ago
Milli, your books are inspiring and should be read by everyone. Thanks for doing the work you do. I hope you don't think that all midwives In ANZ share the views of these few hateful and cruel people.
D
Donna Wallace
5 years ago
Silencing open discussion of the biological reality of women is the worst kind of fascism. Only dictatorships deny differing opinions.
Milli Hill is an exceptional advocate for women and mothers.
Don’t erase women!!
Only women get pregnant and only women give birth. This is not a controversial or hateful view.
Milli Hill has long stood for human rights in childbirth. Her work is of great value to all.
Biology is real
I’d sign a petition not to cancel someone with whom I deeply disagree, too. Let free discussion of critical topics occur.
Men can’t get pregnant. Biology is clear. Only 2 sexes and neither can be changed. Anyone who doesn’t understand and accept these facts should not be working in healthcare of any sort, let alone midwifery.
Women give birth and breastfeed, why are women still so marginalised.
It is ridiculous to cancel Milli Hill, a respected midwife and writer, because a few people don't like her politics. Of course she knows the difference between women and men.
Who'd have thought we would have to petition for the right to speak the truth. Solidarity Milli
I do not understand this current war against women fought under the guise of exclusion which is in fact excluding a sex class that near enough makes up 50% of the world's population. Why do you want to erase women and the lived experience of women? How on earth on the 21st century, in a so called civilised democracy, is an anti scientific anti sex based rights agenda being pushed so forcefully with huge sanctions against those who dare speak out?
I have read the counter petition to this and I can see that the writers misrepresented what Milli Hill has said and are somewhat confused themselves about the difference between sex and gender identity and sexed and gendered language. I think that they would benefit from an open good-faith conversation with Milli and that perhaps if such could occur they may find a lot of common ground. I hope that the New Zealand College of Midwives is encouraged by this petition. Perhaps, given the misunderstanding evident in the petition, it would be a good thing for them to include an additional session to allow Milli to present her actual views and a conversation could ensue.
It's beggars belief that this gender ideology has infiltrated everything that should be centred on (biological) women.
Only females can get pregnant. It's a biological fact. Statement of fact is not hatred.
Everyone who is, or ever been, on this planet came from A Woman: Adult Human Female. I am offended at my reality being erased, and not being allowed to talk openly about my self and my life experience. You cannot force me to accept the religious cult ideologies that males can also get pregnant, give birth and breast feed. A person can only do that if they have female sexual organs. Somewhere a billionaire may already be cloning,
It's hard to imagine ever forgiving the organisations that have the needs and interests of women as their core and defining purposes, yet who have so comprehensively failed in that purpose that they willingly embrace the misogynist notion that being a woman is not even a real, material thing. Solidarity with Milli
I wish she'd been my midwife rather than the ones I did have. You should be getting her in front of as many midwives as possible not deplatforming her. While Scandal after scandal emerges about how badly women in labour are treated all I see are midwives are tying themselves in knots over whether it's women who give birth. Listen to her - women want you to.
Stating facts is not transphobic, and factual sex based language is imperitive to effective midwifery.
Milli, your books are inspiring and should be read by everyone. Thanks for doing the work you do. I hope you don't think that all midwives In ANZ share the views of these few hateful and cruel people.
Silencing open discussion of the biological reality of women is the worst kind of fascism. Only dictatorships deny differing opinions.