Skip to main content

McRobbie, Daniels and the ASA

32 Comments

J
John Baesler
12 years ago

As a graduate of the Indiana University Department of History graduate program I strongly support this petition.

B
Barbara Ransby
12 years ago

Chicago, Illinois

S
Susan Seizer
12 years ago

Associate Professor, Department of Communication & Culture, Indiana University

K
Kenneth Chernoff
12 years ago

A S A = anti-Semitic assholes!

D
Don Anderson
12 years ago

I Seriously OBJECT!

J
jules chametzky
12 years ago Featured

I am opposed tot he boycott, but agree with Alan Wald's position as it relates to academic freedom and democratic procedures

R
Rachel Rubin
12 years ago

Dishonest characterizations from educational leaders are distressing.

A
Alan Wald
12 years ago Featured

While I have strong criticisms of some of the language of the resolution and aspects of the process that occurred, I feel that the points made in this petition are accurate and important to support.

G
Gary Scott
12 years ago

But a university has no obligation to allow for the free expression of hate and the singling out of one group of people as targets of hate. Do you share a similar passion for the oppressed in other Middle Eastern countries?

G
Gary Scott
12 years ago

Yes, me must all give our strong and unflagging support to such courageous human beings. Thanks for speaking out for decency.

G
Gary Scott
12 years ago

Thanks for illuminating the blatant hypocrisy found in organizations such as the ASA, which to me has become nothing more than a hate group.

M
Myra Mendible
12 years ago

A university MUST allow for the free expression of ideas and dissent!

C
Cheryl Higashida
12 years ago Featured

The ASA resolution stands for academic freedom for ALL. It is a boycott on institutions that deny academic and other freedoms to Palestinians. The decision to boycott was made democratically, with two-thirds of ASA membership voting on the resolution. By contrast, the stunning response of IU's and Purdue's presidents to the ASA boycott is entirely undemocratic, taken without consultation of the faculty. Out of support for my colleagues who have bravely taken a stand for human rights, I will be making my contribution to the ASA and urging others to sign this petition.

A
Alex Aviña
12 years ago

Tallahassee, FL, United States

S
Samer Alatout
12 years ago

Associate Professor, University of Wisconsin-Madison

T
Tom Foster
12 years ago

Former adjunct member of American Studies at Indiana University and former director of the Cultural Studies Program at Indiana University

B
beatrice pita
12 years ago

Stop the madness!

Y
Yolanda Martinez- San Miguel
12 years ago Featured

Boycotts should not be resolved with further boycotts. University Presidents have been expressing their positions without proper consultation with their faculty. We must respect ASA's democratic discussion and vote on this resolution, and faculty shold decide individually if they want to belong to ASA. THe BDS campaign has been around since 2004, and academic associations constantly boycott cities and countries based on political and social issues, and university presidents have not intervened in these boycotts before. This intervention now is simply capricious. Many university presidents are reacting to ASA's boycott without being properly informed.

J
joan scott
12 years ago Featured

i urge Presidents McRobbie and Daniels to follow the example of President Eisgruber of Princeton University: At least one college president, however, has publicly resisted calls to crack down on the A.S.A. Christopher L. Eisgruber, president of Princeton University, has responded to alumni inquiries about the boycott with a letter saying he opposes it but does “not intend to denounce the A.S.A., make it unwelcome on campus or inhibit the ability of faculty members to affiliate with it.” The better approach, he said, is to engage with the association and hope “more thoughtful and reasonable members will eventually bring the organization to its senses.”

R
Robert Aponte
12 years ago

Back off; you're wrong and can't win this one!