Dear Superintendent Blake,
We are Winthrop and Doyon parents and we are writing with concern over the district's action to put Nurse Stafford on leave. Having reviewed the offending Facebook post we firmly believe that it qualifies as protected speech and any attempt to discipline the employee would result in legal liability for the town.
The complaints generated from the post were instigated by people on Facebook who did not agree with the statement for political reasons. They do not have children in the school system, and many do not even live in the state. Persecution of teachers for their private opinions shared outside of school is modern day McCarthyism and will not be tolerated by the community. This move is a slippery slope and endangers all of our teachers and our students. Moreover, it does not effectively model American civics or protected constitutional rights to our children, which is the school’s responsibility.
We have witnessed the care, attention, and professionalism that Nurse Stafford brings to his work. He knows each and every Winthrop student and we trust him with protecting our children’s health and safety. He knows when calling parents with health concerns how to effectively explain the urgency of a matter such that parents and caregivers are well-informed but not unnecessarily panicked.
Unfortunately, your Saturday morning message to parents left us unnecessarily panicked due to its vagueness. We find suspending Nurse Stafford to be an over-reaction to what amounts to a relatively common type of social media post not intended for, sent to, or directed at students.
Suspending Nurse Stafford will not keep our students safe, but will instead deprive them of an excellent health practitioner who knows their needs and cares about them. Replacing him with a temporary substitute would not be equivalent or an effective use of resources. Moreover, it is not what we parents or students actually need or want. We hope that you will consider our viewpoint and convey a clear plan of action at curriculum night this week or sooner.
Sincerely,
Haley Mosher & Christina Elder
I have personally watched Jon work with the children at Winthrop. He is a loving and devoted member of the community— a true representative of the nurturing environment they strive to create there. His firing would be a huge loss for everyone!