God forbid they nominate a song because it's good - not because it's from a hit film. F***!
I
Ivan Palomares
12 years ago
Broughton is an exceptional composer. Other powerful academic send DVDs for your consideration and they are not disqualified. Broughton sent emails and he has been. Hypocrisy
J
John Elliott
12 years ago
Disgraceful decision.
S
Simon Oswell
12 years ago
what a disgrace.
R
Roderick Elms
12 years ago
This is a shameful decision, not worthy of such an instituion. It should be reversed and an fulsome apology offered to Mr. Broughton.
A
Anonymous
12 years ago
So bad
B
Brendon Kelly
12 years ago
This only puts the Academy and its Oscar ceremony in bad light. Disgraceful ddc
B
Brendon Kelly
12 years ago
This only puts the Academy and its Oscar ceremony in bad light. Disgraceful ddc
C
Christopher Gunning
12 years ago
This is a bad decision. Please reverse it and apologise to Mr Broughton.
C
Cado Bell
12 years ago
We need the talents of Bruce and Dennis
F
Fernando Fernandez
12 years ago
please, reconsider
S
Scott Glasgow
12 years ago
shameful and wrong
A
Andres de la Torre
12 years ago
This is an unacceptable move by the Academy if it's true all Mr. Broughton did was to send emails trying to promote his work. Isn't that what the "for your consideration" campaign is all about?
This decision makes you appear corrupt. Please rescind your decision and apologise publicly to Mr Broughton.
T
Tess Myers
12 years ago
Make it right, Academy!!!
M
Mark Ford
12 years ago
We all know that politics and favortisim are staples of Hollywood like most places, but it still doesn't excuse this type of thing if it isn't applied evenly and fairly across the board.
S
Scott Henderson
12 years ago
Reconsider and Reinstate the nomination!
M
Myke Smith
12 years ago
Apparently you can run 200 "for your consideration" billboards up and down sunset blvd., but one email is a big no no. Academy rules do not prohibit sending emails or even the more aggressive "for your consideration". Academy rules only apply when convenient, for the academy.
God forbid they nominate a song because it's good - not because it's from a hit film. F***!
Broughton is an exceptional composer. Other powerful academic send DVDs for your consideration and they are not disqualified. Broughton sent emails and he has been. Hypocrisy
Disgraceful decision.
what a disgrace.
This is a shameful decision, not worthy of such an instituion. It should be reversed and an fulsome apology offered to Mr. Broughton.
So bad
This only puts the Academy and its Oscar ceremony in bad light. Disgraceful ddc
This only puts the Academy and its Oscar ceremony in bad light. Disgraceful ddc
This is a bad decision. Please reverse it and apologise to Mr Broughton.
We need the talents of Bruce and Dennis
please, reconsider
shameful and wrong
This is an unacceptable move by the Academy if it's true all Mr. Broughton did was to send emails trying to promote his work. Isn't that what the "for your consideration" campaign is all about?
[email protected]
This decision makes you appear corrupt. Please rescind your decision and apologise publicly to Mr Broughton.
Make it right, Academy!!!
We all know that politics and favortisim are staples of Hollywood like most places, but it still doesn't excuse this type of thing if it isn't applied evenly and fairly across the board.
Reconsider and Reinstate the nomination!
Apparently you can run 200 "for your consideration" billboards up and down sunset blvd., but one email is a big no no. Academy rules do not prohibit sending emails or even the more aggressive "for your consideration". Academy rules only apply when convenient, for the academy.
Academy, must reconsider !