Hold Public Meetings on Scarsdale Surveillance System
93 Comments
P
Paul R Weiss
1 year ago
What is the benefit of this surveillance to our safety at the expense of privacy and the threat that the data will affect our privacy. This company has BAD reviews
R
Robert Berg
1 year ago
This is a shanda!
J
Jill Krutick
1 year ago
It is outrageous to add surveillance to our neighborhood without having a proper public discourse and transparency. This is an over-reaching effort by local government to take advantage of its neighbors.
U
Umut Topkara
1 year ago
The Village Board has overstepped its mandate by unilaterally approving and purchasing surveillance equipment without sufficient public input or transparency. This kind of decision demands broader community engagement, not quiet overreach.
A
Anonymous
1 year ago
Looking for more transparency
A
Anonymous
1 year ago
Need more transparency on how the technology will be used over time
S
Sheila Stempler
1 year ago
I would like more information as well as participation by residents in any decision making regarding the matter
A
Alex Wong
1 year ago
The company implementing the data gathering gains valuable marketable data from their activities. What safeguards are in place to ensure the data is not sold to third parties? Does Scarsdale IT control the physical devices gathering, transporting, and storing the data? What assurances are there that the the collected data is not being copied?
R
Ravi Charles
1 year ago
More transparency is required; proof and results of analysis of comparable proposed surveillance in other villages
J
JeanLuc deDianous
1 year ago
Thank you Mayra for raising awareness of this lack of process
R
Rena Schwartzbaum
1 year ago
Transparency is critical.
M
Melissa Hagerty
1 year ago
Please do not sign us up for ‘Big Brother’ surveillance. This is a slippery slope. We did not vote for this or the expenditure.
J
Jean-Claude Mazzola
1 year ago
1) Full disclosure is key. 2) Why is this not under the control of SPD? 3) what does and Flock do with the data? 4) Why is constant surveillance of our comings and going necessary. 5) what about the 4th Amendment - freedom from searches? 6) On what probable cause does the town base their decision to follow me or anyone? 7) How long does is the data kept? 8) very very troubling... Take some time and visit other parts of the world where you are under constant government surveillance and take a look at how they live - this is a terrible idea. How about this, of you are worried about the crime, take all that money that we are going to spend on a vendor and hire a few more cops?
D
Diana simon
1 year ago
We need full disclosure, something this entire town struggles with
P
Phyllis Friedman Perkins
1 year ago
Concerned about this and I think it needs more public discussion.
C
Cristy Eguiluz
1 year ago
Featured
While I support stronger security measures, I’d love to know that the community is involved in the process, transparency in the company we hire to install said surveillance and privacy is guaranteed for our residents.
A
Anonymous
1 year ago
No surveillance pleae
A
Anonymous
1 year ago
Thank you for organizing this
A
Anonymous
1 year ago
Featured
This is not a decision that should be made behind closed doors by a few trustees. I'm surprised and disappointed by the way this issue has been handled by the town. We need full disclosure and answers to the many questions that have been raised about implementing such a plan.
J
Jeremy Oades
1 year ago
Featured
Why do we need drone surveillance in Scarsdale at all? If we do then shouldn’t it be under the oversight of SPD? Why is Flock recurring annual expenses so high? This seems aggrejous pricing for an u clear community benefit - we’re competitive quotes sought and transparent pricing pursued? If so where are the results?
What is the benefit of this surveillance to our safety at the expense of privacy and the threat that the data will affect our privacy. This company has BAD reviews
This is a shanda!
It is outrageous to add surveillance to our neighborhood without having a proper public discourse and transparency. This is an over-reaching effort by local government to take advantage of its neighbors.
The Village Board has overstepped its mandate by unilaterally approving and purchasing surveillance equipment without sufficient public input or transparency. This kind of decision demands broader community engagement, not quiet overreach.
Looking for more transparency
Need more transparency on how the technology will be used over time
I would like more information as well as participation by residents in any decision making regarding the matter
The company implementing the data gathering gains valuable marketable data from their activities. What safeguards are in place to ensure the data is not sold to third parties? Does Scarsdale IT control the physical devices gathering, transporting, and storing the data? What assurances are there that the the collected data is not being copied?
More transparency is required; proof and results of analysis of comparable proposed surveillance in other villages
Thank you Mayra for raising awareness of this lack of process
Transparency is critical.
Please do not sign us up for ‘Big Brother’ surveillance. This is a slippery slope. We did not vote for this or the expenditure.
1) Full disclosure is key. 2) Why is this not under the control of SPD? 3) what does and Flock do with the data? 4) Why is constant surveillance of our comings and going necessary. 5) what about the 4th Amendment - freedom from searches? 6) On what probable cause does the town base their decision to follow me or anyone? 7) How long does is the data kept? 8) very very troubling... Take some time and visit other parts of the world where you are under constant government surveillance and take a look at how they live - this is a terrible idea. How about this, of you are worried about the crime, take all that money that we are going to spend on a vendor and hire a few more cops?
We need full disclosure, something this entire town struggles with
Concerned about this and I think it needs more public discussion.
While I support stronger security measures, I’d love to know that the community is involved in the process, transparency in the company we hire to install said surveillance and privacy is guaranteed for our residents.
No surveillance pleae
Thank you for organizing this
This is not a decision that should be made behind closed doors by a few trustees. I'm surprised and disappointed by the way this issue has been handled by the town. We need full disclosure and answers to the many questions that have been raised about implementing such a plan.
Why do we need drone surveillance in Scarsdale at all? If we do then shouldn’t it be under the oversight of SPD? Why is Flock recurring annual expenses so high? This seems aggrejous pricing for an u clear community benefit - we’re competitive quotes sought and transparent pricing pursued? If so where are the results?