You've been down this path before. Did you hear the outcry then? Do you hear it now? Will you listen?
Did you hear when Frances McDormand made "inclusion rider" a battle cry?
Underrepresented people deserve to be included. Their stories matter. Their voices matter. They *must* be given opportunities to tell their stories.
With visibility comes understanding. 80% of trans students feel unsafe at school because of their gender expression. 50% of trans people have suffered violence from a romantic partner. 58% of gender non-conforming students experienced verbal harassment because of their gender expression in the past year. 41% of trans people have attempted suicide.
You, Ms. Johansson and Mr. Sanders, have an opportunity to make a difference in the lives of these people. You have a opportunity to create a space for better trans visibility and understanding on a grand scale. Sometimes the best way to make sure underrepresented voices are included is by knowing when to step aside.
In that light, here is what some transgender actors and film critics have to say about representation. Read. Hear. Listen. And show the world how trans visibility matters to you.
"A trans character should be played by a trans individual. We need the opportunity to just be out there. It's a sad situation, but it's reality. We do have a couple of trans actors out there making waves, but unfortunately, the industry is just not putting too many roles out there for us. It's important so that people can see us and understand us. I think many people have this misconception of who trans people are because we all come from different backgrounds, and things aren't always clear-cut. I can understand that just going through my transition and my life. But it's beautiful when you see someone who looks like you making steps and strides in the film industry or in anything because it shows you that you can do that, that you can attain that. So it's really important that we have that visibility so maybe some of the backlash and some of the hate can be understood, and we have these conversations at the table. If understanding was across the board and people just gave us time, we'd be able to flourish."
-Cess Jones
"There are consequences or risks when trans people are misrepresented. If an audience had no knowledge of the trans experience, and they watched a movie like Silence of the Lambs, and they see the trans character as a serial killer, it creates that idea of trans people for them—that we're killers or addicts or sex workers, troubled characters. People are learning from these representations so there has to be more care and sensitivity because it affects day to day interactions with people."
-Kiley May
"The ultimate thing is to let us tell our stories. In 50 or 100 years when we're all equal and we're all living on an equal playing field, that won't be necessary, but right now it is because there's no way that a white cisgender person can possibly understand what life for us is like right now. And they can't tell our stories as well. That's ownership. That's us being at the table."
-Delia Kopp
"When you hire a trans actor, they don't have to spend weeks or months "preparing and researching" to play a trans person. They can walk in the door on day one, ready to deliver an authentic, nuanced performance. You get the added bonus of having someone on set who can tell you if something about the dialogue or the characterization is falling into tropes and clichés that will ultimately not reflect well on you or the project. (You can also call GLAAD for that feedback. We want to help you get it right from the beginning.)"
-Nick Adams
"It'd be nice if there were more than 11 trans people on television. And it would definitely be nice if there were more films with trans characters played by trans actors who could find a larger audience."
-Danielle Solzman
"As recently as 2015, only 16% of Americans say they knew a trans person. The rest, like my friend, only knew what they saw in film and television. I would always prefer to see a trans actor play a trans part: Our community needs the work, such opportunities will change the industry, the performances will be more nuanced, and it will have a positive impact on the incredibly fragile lives of trans and gender-nonconforming people."
-Jen Richards
Updates
July 4, 2018
The stories shared in the comments are heartbreaking. We are continuing to push for accountability behind the scenes.
July 4, 2018
The momentum is undeniable. This is proof that people are watching and waiting for actual change.
9 Comments
I am cis and I stand with all of the people who demand respect and equal representation. Scarlett Johanssen is a wonderful actor, but she's not for every role. This is not her role. Do the story a favor and cast appropriately. It will speak in volumes.
Enough with the excuses. Hire a trans actor. It is 2018 and we are still doing this? Seriously just do better.
boycott hollywood! we need more lgbtq+ people in the community not less! we say no to hollywood and we need our own media company!
Trans people are tired of being erased from their own stories. Cast someone who actually lives this experience.
Not only does this take away opportunities from actual trans actors, it also sends a message to the world that trans men are really women. They're not. Trans men are men. It's also not about the "best" actor, it's about the right one. There are tons of right actors who never get opportunities, in large part because of stuff like this.
There are many talented trans-people who can play this part. Pick one!
This should be played by a trans actor!
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Copy link or share directly
You've been down this path before. Did you hear the outcry then? Do you hear it now? Will you listen?
Did you hear when Frances McDormand made "inclusion rider" a battle cry?
Underrepresented people deserve to be included. Their stories matter. Their voices matter. They *must* be given opportunities to tell their stories.
With visibility comes understanding. 80% of trans students feel unsafe at school because of their gender expression. 50% of trans people have suffered violence from a romantic partner. 58% of gender non-conforming students experienced verbal harassment because of their gender expression in the past year. 41% of trans people have attempted suicide.
You, Ms. Johansson and Mr. Sanders, have an opportunity to make a difference in the lives of these people. You have a opportunity to create a space for better trans visibility and understanding on a grand scale. Sometimes the best way to make sure underrepresented voices are included is by knowing when to step aside.
In that light, here is what some transgender actors and film critics have to say about representation. Read. Hear. Listen. And show the world how trans visibility matters to you.
"A trans character should be played by a trans individual. We need the opportunity to just be out there. It's a sad situation, but it's reality. We do have a couple of trans actors out there making waves, but unfortunately, the industry is just not putting too many roles out there for us. It's important so that people can see us and understand us. I think many people have this misconception of who trans people are because we all come from different backgrounds, and things aren't always clear-cut. I can understand that just going through my transition and my life. But it's beautiful when you see someone who looks like you making steps and strides in the film industry or in anything because it shows you that you can do that, that you can attain that. So it's really important that we have that visibility so maybe some of the backlash and some of the hate can be understood, and we have these conversations at the table. If understanding was across the board and people just gave us time, we'd be able to flourish."
-Cess Jones
"There are consequences or risks when trans people are misrepresented. If an audience had no knowledge of the trans experience, and they watched a movie like Silence of the Lambs, and they see the trans character as a serial killer, it creates that idea of trans people for them—that we're killers or addicts or sex workers, troubled characters. People are learning from these representations so there has to be more care and sensitivity because it affects day to day interactions with people."
-Kiley May
"The ultimate thing is to let us tell our stories. In 50 or 100 years when we're all equal and we're all living on an equal playing field, that won't be necessary, but right now it is because there's no way that a white cisgender person can possibly understand what life for us is like right now. And they can't tell our stories as well. That's ownership. That's us being at the table."
-Delia Kopp
"When you hire a trans actor, they don't have to spend weeks or months "preparing and researching" to play a trans person. They can walk in the door on day one, ready to deliver an authentic, nuanced performance. You get the added bonus of having someone on set who can tell you if something about the dialogue or the characterization is falling into tropes and clichés that will ultimately not reflect well on you or the project. (You can also call GLAAD for that feedback. We want to help you get it right from the beginning.)"
-Nick Adams
"It'd be nice if there were more than 11 trans people on television. And it would definitely be nice if there were more films with trans characters played by trans actors who could find a larger audience."
-Danielle Solzman
"As recently as 2015, only 16% of Americans say they knew a trans person. The rest, like my friend, only knew what they saw in film and television. I would always prefer to see a trans actor play a trans part: Our community needs the work, such opportunities will change the industry, the performances will be more nuanced, and it will have a positive impact on the incredibly fragile lives of trans and gender-nonconforming people."
-Jen Richards
Updates
July 4, 2018
The stories shared in the comments are heartbreaking. We are continuing to push for accountability behind the scenes.
July 4, 2018
The momentum is undeniable. This is proof that people are watching and waiting for actual change.
9 Comments
Hi. I'm transnonbinary, and our visibility is even more nonexistant -- ScarJo, you gotta drop this role and give trans actors a chance to shine. They don't even have to method act! I'm really disappointed in the director for his casting choice and in you for taking the opportunity from someone who can represent it more authentically.
I am cis and I stand with all of the people who demand respect and equal representation. Scarlett Johanssen is a wonderful actor, but she's not for every role. This is not her role. Do the story a favor and cast appropriately. It will speak in volumes.
Enough with the excuses. Hire a trans actor. It is 2018 and we are still doing this? Seriously just do better.
boycott hollywood! we need more lgbtq+ people in the community not less! we say no to hollywood and we need our own media company!
Trans people are tired of being erased from their own stories. Cast someone who actually lives this experience.
Not only does this take away opportunities from actual trans actors, it also sends a message to the world that trans men are really women. They're not. Trans men are men. It's also not about the "best" actor, it's about the right one. There are tons of right actors who never get opportunities, in large part because of stuff like this.
There are many talented trans-people who can play this part. Pick one!
This should be played by a trans actor!
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach 100 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via .
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Make your voice count today!
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
Hi. I'm transnonbinary, and our visibility is even more nonexistant -- ScarJo, you gotta drop this role and give trans actors a chance to shine. They don't even have to method act! I'm really disappointed in the director for his casting choice and in you for taking the opportunity from someone who can represent it more authentically.