From the fans of Thorin to Peter Jackson: we would like to be heard.
113 Comments
T
The Thread™
11 years ago
Why were there no petitions that I should live?
T
The Thread™
11 years ago
Why were there no petitions that I should live?
T
The Thread™
11 years ago
Thongale™ anyone? #ThorinLives
T
The Thread™
11 years ago
Thongale™ anyone? #ThorinLives
D
Derek Chen
11 years ago
thorin oakenshield i hereby announce thee dead
D
Derek Chen
11 years ago
thorin oakenshield i hereby announce thee dead
E
Emily M.
11 years ago
please change it, I've been depressed about it since I saw it (that was 2 weeks ago)
E
Emily M.
11 years ago
please change it, I've been depressed about it since I saw it (that was 2 weeks ago)
S
Svetlana Snape
11 years ago
I Love Thorin!
S
Svetlana Snape
11 years ago
I Love Thorin!
C
claudia cristina
11 years ago
please help thorin to noy die in youre story, we know that is based on the bokk but the key word is based so that means that u can chance a few things here and there so please help him to stay alive, abd with that kili and fili to please :)
C
claudia cristina
11 years ago
please help thorin to noy die in youre story, we know that is based on the bokk but the key word is based so that means that u can chance a few things here and there so please help him to stay alive, abd with that kili and fili to please :)
N
Nelly McCausland
11 years ago
I believe the Jackson Thorin should survive. He is the hero of the trilogy no matter what Tolkien said. I happen to keep the two supports separate. I love both but seldom refer one to another. They are two of a kind and I love them both.
N
Nelly McCausland
11 years ago
I believe the Jackson Thorin should survive. He is the hero of the trilogy no matter what Tolkien said. I happen to keep the two supports separate. I love both but seldom refer one to another. They are two of a kind and I love them both.
A
Annette
11 years ago
Long live Thorin!
A
Annette
11 years ago
Long live Thorin!
K
Kasikomi Ooxasy
11 years ago
Да многие читали, что смерть Торина это расплата за его "грехи". За его алчность, гордыню и т.д. Но тогда (если принимать буквально) очень многие люди тоже ДОЛЖНЫ УМЕРЕТЬ. В мире тоже огромное количество людей у которых "драконья болезнь". Тогда почему они ДОСТОЙНЫ ЖИЗНИ, а ТОРИН НЕТ? И откуда такая ненависть к Торину? Согрешил гном, с кем не бывает?! И почему он СРАЗУ ДОЛЖЕН УМЕРЕТЬ? Да и к тому же я прекрасно понимаю, что то что написано пером не выручишь топором, и (возможно) смерть Торина ( без которой я была бы намного счастливее и мою подушку не пришлось бы сушить) и в самом деле многое значит в этой повести. Просто я не хочу принимать эту горькую для меня правду. да и многие не хотят. Особенно после того, как перечитала книгу и пересмотрела фильмы. Мне полюбился этот король. Меня не интересуют какие факты и аргументы вы будете приводить. Я хочу чтобы ТОРИН ЖИЛ. Это обычное детское наивное желание маленькой девочки, которая еще верит в чудеса. Его НИКТО И НИЧТО НЕ ИЗМЕНИТ. Я просто так хочу и все. И мне плевать сбудется оно (чего уж точно не случится) или нет, я останусь верна ему и все.
M
Mokhash Parmar
11 years ago
But when he did die, it was the best and most moving part of the book. After I finished, I'm glad that that scene between Thorin and Bilbo happened.
M
Mokhash Parmar
11 years ago
Have you read anything written by Tolkien?!
If Thorin lives it throws a wedge into the brilliant and complicated timeline that he made. Just because it's fiction doesn't mean that it doesn't have to make sense.
M
Mokhash Parmar
11 years ago
It's called "The Hobbit". So we'd expect it to be "The Hobbit". And in "The Hobbit", Thorin dies. And it's the best and most moving part of the book. But I'm guessing you never read it. The films would be bland and uninteresting if everything was just happy and there were no problems at all.
Why were there no petitions that I should live?
Why were there no petitions that I should live?
Thongale™ anyone? #ThorinLives
Thongale™ anyone? #ThorinLives
thorin oakenshield i hereby announce thee dead
thorin oakenshield i hereby announce thee dead
please change it, I've been depressed about it since I saw it (that was 2 weeks ago)
please change it, I've been depressed about it since I saw it (that was 2 weeks ago)
I Love Thorin!
I Love Thorin!
please help thorin to noy die in youre story, we know that is based on the bokk but the key word is based so that means that u can chance a few things here and there so please help him to stay alive, abd with that kili and fili to please :)
please help thorin to noy die in youre story, we know that is based on the bokk but the key word is based so that means that u can chance a few things here and there so please help him to stay alive, abd with that kili and fili to please :)
I believe the Jackson Thorin should survive. He is the hero of the trilogy no matter what Tolkien said. I happen to keep the two supports separate. I love both but seldom refer one to another. They are two of a kind and I love them both.
I believe the Jackson Thorin should survive. He is the hero of the trilogy no matter what Tolkien said. I happen to keep the two supports separate. I love both but seldom refer one to another. They are two of a kind and I love them both.
Long live Thorin!
Long live Thorin!
Да многие читали, что смерть Торина это расплата за его "грехи". За его алчность, гордыню и т.д. Но тогда (если принимать буквально) очень многие люди тоже ДОЛЖНЫ УМЕРЕТЬ. В мире тоже огромное количество людей у которых "драконья болезнь". Тогда почему они ДОСТОЙНЫ ЖИЗНИ, а ТОРИН НЕТ? И откуда такая ненависть к Торину? Согрешил гном, с кем не бывает?! И почему он СРАЗУ ДОЛЖЕН УМЕРЕТЬ? Да и к тому же я прекрасно понимаю, что то что написано пером не выручишь топором, и (возможно) смерть Торина ( без которой я была бы намного счастливее и мою подушку не пришлось бы сушить) и в самом деле многое значит в этой повести. Просто я не хочу принимать эту горькую для меня правду. да и многие не хотят. Особенно после того, как перечитала книгу и пересмотрела фильмы. Мне полюбился этот король. Меня не интересуют какие факты и аргументы вы будете приводить. Я хочу чтобы ТОРИН ЖИЛ. Это обычное детское наивное желание маленькой девочки, которая еще верит в чудеса. Его НИКТО И НИЧТО НЕ ИЗМЕНИТ. Я просто так хочу и все. И мне плевать сбудется оно (чего уж точно не случится) или нет, я останусь верна ему и все.
But when he did die, it was the best and most moving part of the book. After I finished, I'm glad that that scene between Thorin and Bilbo happened.
Have you read anything written by Tolkien?! If Thorin lives it throws a wedge into the brilliant and complicated timeline that he made. Just because it's fiction doesn't mean that it doesn't have to make sense.
It's called "The Hobbit". So we'd expect it to be "The Hobbit". And in "The Hobbit", Thorin dies. And it's the best and most moving part of the book. But I'm guessing you never read it. The films would be bland and uninteresting if everything was just happy and there were no problems at all.