WARNING do not donate to this petition. LGB Alliance is investigating what has happened but this was never intended to be a fundraiser.
2,361 Comments
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
I'd love Stonewall to think of young lesbians, now embarking on journey to sterility and unknown medical side effects. How can this be acceptance of who you are?
J
Judith Skinner
8 years ago
I'm a lesbian. Fully support rights of transwomen but sex-specific protected characteristics must stand. It is not possible to change sex.
T
Terry
8 years ago
Everyone who signs this petition for real is a transphobic nonce like graham linehan
C
Callie
8 years ago
Why does Stonewall hate biological women and lesbians.
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Trans people should be treated with dignity, respect and have full legal protection under law but so should CIS women! There ARE competing rights and vocal trans activists are attempting to silence and erase the lived realities of cis women.
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
There seems to be no forum for discussion on this without being accused of transphobia
S
Sue Kay
8 years ago
If stonewall wants to continue to claim to be a national voice for lgbt issues then it must acknowledge and respect that there are many different views. All have aright to be expressed and we are all both entitled to be respected and to respect others
T
Tracie Fryer-Kanssen
8 years ago
please listen to women.
K
Kate
8 years ago
I feel a bit frightened by the idea that biological men can turn up in women only spaces just by declaring themselves female. I have nothing against transgender and fully support the rights of any transgendered individuals. But I also have rights and they are being overlooked
C
Charlotte mortimer
8 years ago
Women’s (adult human females) voices must be heard. We will not be silenced anymore. Transwomen are transwomen.
A
Angela Garrod
8 years ago
Stop an evil trend which would permit predatory men and paedophile free access to young girls and vulnerable women.
C
Corinna Cohn
8 years ago
As a transsexual, I believe. Self ID is a disaster for women and girls. It effectively erases sex as a protected category. On top of this, Stonewall has refused to hear the objections, instead mischaracterizing critics of GRA. Stonewall and Ruth Hunt must start listening to women.
C
Christine Johnson
8 years ago
Open discussion is needed here without folk being accused of being transphobic
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
Ruth Hunt & Stonewall: "do not and will not acknowledge that there is a conflict between trans rights and ‘sex based women’s rights’. Sorry but none at all? Won't even consider the possibility? When did this campaigning group become one-trick pony? The Charities Commission need to review this new and worrying development.
K
Katherine Warner
8 years ago
Consider this petition before you infringe in the equality & treatment if women.
J
Jadoo Mirza
8 years ago
I am very concerned at the hate & violence around this issue. The model promoted by Stonewall does not support trans people properly, nor non trans women. Stonewall have a duty to look again at the division they are causing and the harm they are doing to everyone. So many hands are outstretched to them & other such activists to try to find a way forward, and are ignored.
R
Rachel Lombard
8 years ago
Men cannot become women, women cannot become men. To say these things is to tell a lie. To expect me to believe them and reorganise my identity around them is an outrage. To tell children this is is a disgrace. All our bodies are valid and beautiful. Gender is a social construction
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
What does it mean to be a woman? Just when women are starting to get a voice, it feels like men (male-born) are trying to shut us down.
A
Anonymous
8 years ago
We each need a clear voice. There's no point in joining all oppressed voices together - otherwise Stonewall should represent black people, disabled people, straight women. This is not to dimimish the significance or oppression of queer people but we have separate identities and can best support each other through strength gained from organising in our own groups.
H
Helen Fallows
8 years ago
Woman-Adult human female. Lesbians are same SEX attracted.
I'd love Stonewall to think of young lesbians, now embarking on journey to sterility and unknown medical side effects. How can this be acceptance of who you are?
I'm a lesbian. Fully support rights of transwomen but sex-specific protected characteristics must stand. It is not possible to change sex.
Everyone who signs this petition for real is a transphobic nonce like graham linehan
Why does Stonewall hate biological women and lesbians.
Trans people should be treated with dignity, respect and have full legal protection under law but so should CIS women! There ARE competing rights and vocal trans activists are attempting to silence and erase the lived realities of cis women.
There seems to be no forum for discussion on this without being accused of transphobia
If stonewall wants to continue to claim to be a national voice for lgbt issues then it must acknowledge and respect that there are many different views. All have aright to be expressed and we are all both entitled to be respected and to respect others
please listen to women.
I feel a bit frightened by the idea that biological men can turn up in women only spaces just by declaring themselves female. I have nothing against transgender and fully support the rights of any transgendered individuals. But I also have rights and they are being overlooked
Women’s (adult human females) voices must be heard. We will not be silenced anymore. Transwomen are transwomen.
Stop an evil trend which would permit predatory men and paedophile free access to young girls and vulnerable women.
As a transsexual, I believe. Self ID is a disaster for women and girls. It effectively erases sex as a protected category. On top of this, Stonewall has refused to hear the objections, instead mischaracterizing critics of GRA. Stonewall and Ruth Hunt must start listening to women.
Open discussion is needed here without folk being accused of being transphobic
Ruth Hunt & Stonewall: "do not and will not acknowledge that there is a conflict between trans rights and ‘sex based women’s rights’. Sorry but none at all? Won't even consider the possibility? When did this campaigning group become one-trick pony? The Charities Commission need to review this new and worrying development.
Consider this petition before you infringe in the equality & treatment if women.
I am very concerned at the hate & violence around this issue. The model promoted by Stonewall does not support trans people properly, nor non trans women. Stonewall have a duty to look again at the division they are causing and the harm they are doing to everyone. So many hands are outstretched to them & other such activists to try to find a way forward, and are ignored.
Men cannot become women, women cannot become men. To say these things is to tell a lie. To expect me to believe them and reorganise my identity around them is an outrage. To tell children this is is a disgrace. All our bodies are valid and beautiful. Gender is a social construction
What does it mean to be a woman? Just when women are starting to get a voice, it feels like men (male-born) are trying to shut us down.
We each need a clear voice. There's no point in joining all oppressed voices together - otherwise Stonewall should represent black people, disabled people, straight women. This is not to dimimish the significance or oppression of queer people but we have separate identities and can best support each other through strength gained from organising in our own groups.
Woman-Adult human female. Lesbians are same SEX attracted.