WARNING do not donate to this petition. LGB Alliance is investigating what has happened but this was never intended to be a fundraiser.
2,361 Comments
A
Andreia Nobre
7 years ago
Brazilian radfem Journalist. In relationships with full consent, biology doesn't matter. But biology matters in medical contexts. "Gender fluidity" is harmful to women and children in patriarchal societies because it gives even more power to male-bodied people to control women's bodies by taking from them the tools to fight against sexism. The definition of women is not up to debate - biology matters to all females capable of bearing children.
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
Respectful debate is not transphobic!
C
Claire Elise Johnston
7 years ago
I'm a mother of daughters and a son. They recognise differences and similarities. Discussion is needed.
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
Your policies are dragging young homosexual children into trans culture like lambs to the slaughter. Our kids are not an experiment.
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
Please acknowledge that we need to discuss this further
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
I am a woman who has been sexually assaulted several times in public spaces in broad daylight. I do not want to share private spaces like changing rooms with biological men who has self assigned themselves as women. There is no protection for women in this.
S
Susan Jones
7 years ago
This issue has complex consequences and needs more discussion before decisions are made that will affect all women and children.please don't just jump into these proposed changes from an angry defensive position.
F
Fionnuala McKenna
7 years ago
Masters Student in Creative Practice". I cannot say I feel like a woman but I AM an adult human female, therfore my reality is that I am a WOMAN.
C
Catherine Waters
7 years ago
Appalled at Stonewall
C
Clare
7 years ago
I no longer have a choice to live the way everyone rightly should, instead it’s life of fear. Silence is only way I can protect my kids from being threatened.
So many scared to speak up and hiding their name even. It’s not right this is failing the well being of many
P
Penny Thornton
7 years ago
Please don't give rights to some whilst removing the rights of others.
S
Sarah L Nield
7 years ago
I'm signing because I'm not happy, as a B, by the way a loud minority of the T are trying to hog all the resources with your full encouragement.
Thank you
B
Benjamin Michna
7 years ago
In a democracy and in a free society debate must never be shut down. There are clear and obvious issues that need to be addressed in this emerging field of social study and policy.
Stonewall cannot legitimately label anyone who disagrees as an anti trans bigot, not least because there are numerous actual trans people who disagree with their analysis and approach.
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
Please reconsider, please listen to women.
E
Eimear
7 years ago
Trans rights should not supersede women's rights
C
Christine Lough
7 years ago
Please! Just talk to us. All we're asking for is to be listened to honestly and to see some real evidence that you're thinking about what we say.
A
Anonymous
7 years ago
I
T
Tranime Girl
7 years ago
While I will say, yes, transsexual women are women - my right should not come at the expense of other women. Not only do the rights of transsexual women require BALANCE with the rights of natal women - which we are not seeing today - natal women absolutely deserve to speak freely about how my rights as a transsexual women will impact them, without the fear of being silenced.
P
Professor Mary Davis
7 years ago
labour historian
S
Sarah Thomas
7 years ago
Please, please reconcider your approach which is highly damaging. Women should have a voice in this issue, we are directly impacted and should not be be villified for voicing this.
Brazilian radfem Journalist. In relationships with full consent, biology doesn't matter. But biology matters in medical contexts. "Gender fluidity" is harmful to women and children in patriarchal societies because it gives even more power to male-bodied people to control women's bodies by taking from them the tools to fight against sexism. The definition of women is not up to debate - biology matters to all females capable of bearing children.
Respectful debate is not transphobic!
I'm a mother of daughters and a son. They recognise differences and similarities. Discussion is needed.
Your policies are dragging young homosexual children into trans culture like lambs to the slaughter. Our kids are not an experiment.
Please acknowledge that we need to discuss this further
I am a woman who has been sexually assaulted several times in public spaces in broad daylight. I do not want to share private spaces like changing rooms with biological men who has self assigned themselves as women. There is no protection for women in this.
This issue has complex consequences and needs more discussion before decisions are made that will affect all women and children.please don't just jump into these proposed changes from an angry defensive position.
Masters Student in Creative Practice". I cannot say I feel like a woman but I AM an adult human female, therfore my reality is that I am a WOMAN.
Appalled at Stonewall
I no longer have a choice to live the way everyone rightly should, instead it’s life of fear. Silence is only way I can protect my kids from being threatened. So many scared to speak up and hiding their name even. It’s not right this is failing the well being of many
Please don't give rights to some whilst removing the rights of others.
I'm signing because I'm not happy, as a B, by the way a loud minority of the T are trying to hog all the resources with your full encouragement. Thank you
In a democracy and in a free society debate must never be shut down. There are clear and obvious issues that need to be addressed in this emerging field of social study and policy. Stonewall cannot legitimately label anyone who disagrees as an anti trans bigot, not least because there are numerous actual trans people who disagree with their analysis and approach.
Please reconsider, please listen to women.
Trans rights should not supersede women's rights
Please! Just talk to us. All we're asking for is to be listened to honestly and to see some real evidence that you're thinking about what we say.
I
While I will say, yes, transsexual women are women - my right should not come at the expense of other women. Not only do the rights of transsexual women require BALANCE with the rights of natal women - which we are not seeing today - natal women absolutely deserve to speak freely about how my rights as a transsexual women will impact them, without the fear of being silenced.
labour historian
Please, please reconcider your approach which is highly damaging. Women should have a voice in this issue, we are directly impacted and should not be be villified for voicing this.