To the Prime Minister, Minister of Finance, Minister of Revenue, Members of parliament of all parties
We, the undersigned, are shocked to learn that the government is taxing people on paper income they never in reality made, a.k.a. phantom income.
We understand that this happens as a result of legislation that treats the benefit of acquiring shares through an employee stock option or stock purchase program as an employment benefit yet the loss of selling these same shares as a capital loss which cannot be used to offset the employment benefit.
Thus, people are facing a heavy tax burden on the employment benefit, which they cannot pay as they never actually received any money from that assessed benefit. People\'s financial and emotional lives have been severely impacted and in some cases ruined by this tax on phantom income. We personally know or are aware of people who have been thus affected.
As fair-minded Canadians, we believe that it was never the intent of the law to create this terrible situation.
We ask that the minister of finance quickly introduces and that all parties support a change to the law to fix this problem. One possible way is to allow the capital loss on the shares to be used to offset the paper employment benefit. There are many other approaches. This change needs to be retroactive to address those already affected.
Canada has a reputation as a fair and balanced country. We hope our parliament will demonstrate this by quickly dealing with this issue.
One hundred people have now joined this fight against the government and their predatory tax on phantom income. These bureaucrats are ruining lives while they hide behind unfair laws, but they can no longer pretend this issue does not exist.
Reached 100 supporters
March 31, 2008
6 Comments
M
Mike Beck
18 years ago
Featured
This is absolute robbery. How can the government tax money that doesnt exist? Fix this nonsense now.
K
Kevin Conway
18 years ago
Featured
Government taking money from people who didnt actually make any profit. Classic. Needs to change ASAP.
J
Jennifer Hayes
18 years ago
Featured
Absolutely ridiculous. Nobody should be losing their house over paper gains that never even turned into real cash. Unfair.
L
Linda Roberts
18 years ago
Featured
My brother got hit by this and its destroyed his savings. This law is broken.
S
Sarah Banerjee
18 years ago
Featured
My husband went through this and it was a nightmare for our family. You shouldnt have to pay taxes on money you lost!
D
David Fleming
18 years ago
Featured
Taxing phantom income is just wrong. Canada should be better than this.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
500 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via
.
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
To the Prime Minister, Minister of Finance, Minister of Revenue, Members of parliament of all parties
We, the undersigned, are shocked to learn that the government is taxing people on paper income they never in reality made, a.k.a. phantom income.
We understand that this happens as a result of legislation that treats the benefit of acquiring shares through an employee stock option or stock purchase program as an employment benefit yet the loss of selling these same shares as a capital loss which cannot be used to offset the employment benefit.
Thus, people are facing a heavy tax burden on the employment benefit, which they cannot pay as they never actually received any money from that assessed benefit. People\'s financial and emotional lives have been severely impacted and in some cases ruined by this tax on phantom income. We personally know or are aware of people who have been thus affected.
As fair-minded Canadians, we believe that it was never the intent of the law to create this terrible situation.
We ask that the minister of finance quickly introduces and that all parties support a change to the law to fix this problem. One possible way is to allow the capital loss on the shares to be used to offset the paper employment benefit. There are many other approaches. This change needs to be retroactive to address those already affected.
Canada has a reputation as a fair and balanced country. We hope our parliament will demonstrate this by quickly dealing with this issue.
One hundred people have now joined this fight against the government and their predatory tax on phantom income. These bureaucrats are ruining lives while they hide behind unfair laws, but they can no longer pretend this issue does not exist.
Reached 100 supporters
March 31, 2008
6 Comments
M
Mike Beck
18 years ago
Featured
This is absolute robbery. How can the government tax money that doesnt exist? Fix this nonsense now.
K
Kevin Conway
18 years ago
Featured
Government taking money from people who didnt actually make any profit. Classic. Needs to change ASAP.
J
Jennifer Hayes
18 years ago
Featured
Absolutely ridiculous. Nobody should be losing their house over paper gains that never even turned into real cash. Unfair.
L
Linda Roberts
18 years ago
Featured
My brother got hit by this and its destroyed his savings. This law is broken.
S
Sarah Banerjee
18 years ago
Featured
My husband went through this and it was a nightmare for our family. You shouldnt have to pay taxes on money you lost!
D
David Fleming
18 years ago
Featured
Taxing phantom income is just wrong. Canada should be better than this.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
500 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
This is absolute robbery. How can the government tax money that doesnt exist? Fix this nonsense now.