Skip to main content

Bring Back Mrs. Arthur

6,740 Comments

T
Tim McCaghren
10 years ago

There comes a time when personal responsibility must be conferred on Tue individual committing Tue crime, rather than blaming the victim by saying that they enabled the perpetrator. While I agree that it wasn't the best choice for Mrs Arthur to leave her phone unattended, the student who picked up the phone, searched through photos, an d then distributed the content needs to be held responsible for making the series of choices that brought this situation about. To punish Mrs Arthur an d do nothing to the student contributes to that student's delinquency by showing him/her that there is no consequence for these types of actions, and embolden others to follow that example. You want to put a stop to students' bad behaviors? Punish them, be strict and teach them to respect others regardless of how they feel about them personally.

S
Senpai
10 years ago

>student steals teacher's property >student steals teacher's personal information >teacher fired Mrs. Arthur had reasonable expectation of privacy and it was breached. Locked phone or not, that's stolen property and stolen personal info.

E
eddy najdowski
10 years ago

Hire her back! Discipline the student! Why is this so hard?

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

The school board needs to handle this better.

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

This is unfair the only laws broken are theft and 'revenge porn' all committed by the student

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

Disgraceful behaviour by the students involved. Theft and invasion of privacy, hope they get thrown out of school and the teacher re-instated. The superintendent is an idiot.

A
Angel Olvera
10 years ago

Students should be expelled.

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

Absolutely disgusting!

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

Data privacy is a serious issue and anyone infringing on other person's privacy should be punished. We should teach children that stealing someone's data is exactly same as going to someone's house an stealing physical objects. Moreover, teachers are humans too. They are allowed to have their own person life.

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

This situation absolutely needs to be investigated further.

B
Brianna R
10 years ago

If anything, the student should be charged and the teacher allowed to return to her job. The boy who went through her personal photos is to blame, not her.

G
Gil Matos
10 years ago

I'm from Portugal, and I wonder what the hell is happening in the USA. I read so many stories that just trample over the most basic common sense that its mind boggling. I actually feel stupid signing this petition in a "it can't be possible" way. Anyway the teacher should obviously get her job back, with a tremendous apology and the dumbass kid should be disciplined. Duh!

S
Stephen M
10 years ago

Highschool is the final stage in preparing children for adulthood and idepemdence. Responsibility for one's actions is a key lesson in life. The unfortunate outcome of this situation is not only giving children the idea that victim shaming is appropriate, but it is also showing them that taking responsibility and accountability for their own actions, be they a momentary lapse in judgement or not, is not necessary. This teacher needs a sincere apology, both as a teacher and a fellow human being, and the options n to be reinstated. The student needs to learn an important lesson in responsibility and accountability.

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

Who was the mentally challenged fool that fired her?

A
Anonymous
10 years ago

Bring the teacher back and ban the student for a week!

C
Caroline
10 years ago

Despite what Superintendent David Eubanks thinks, it's actually 2016 and women are allowed to engage in and enjoy sex with other individuals that they choose. The only thing inappropriate here is the utter lack of loyalty to your employee and a complete disregard for holding a 16 year old student accountable for his actions. I find it interesting that an older generation can simultaneously complain about "how entitled our generation is" while allowing kids to get away with things like this. Pick one.

Z
Zach Thibault
10 years ago

Total invasion of privacy by the student.

J
John Underdown
10 years ago

This teacher is a VICTIM of crime, not responsible for one.

B
Brian Appel
10 years ago

Clearly this was a knee-jerk reaction that should be corrected.

H
Hannah Rehman
10 years ago

Everyone deserves the right to privacy. No one should be able to violate that. If they do, that is illegal and that should be punished.