We, the undersigned, respectfully request that the City Commission of Birmingham, Mich., direct the city\'s Historic District Study Committee to undertake a study of the Barnum property.
Both the Birmingham Planning Board and the city\'s Historic District Commission have urged the City Commission to ask the Study Committee to research and document the history of the Barnum School buildings and site and to make an objective recommendation on the historical value and the suitability for historic designation.
The two boards were bolstered by an opinion from Oakland County Principal Planner Bob Donahue, who deems the property worthy of study, and has offered his assistance in research and in working with the city to find an appropriate adaptive reuse strategy.
The City Commission has refused, and has voted to move toward demolition of the entire structure, including portions built in 1912 and 1929.
We, the undersigned, make no judgment about the historical significance of Barnum. Rather, we demand that the City Commission proceed only with full knowledge of the historical resources there. In view of the long-term nature of both the Barnum project and the consequences of City Commission action, and in view of the current lease agreement with Beaumont Hospital, which eliminates any cost of delay, we believe such a study is necessary and reasonable.
I have spent the entire morning staring at the old photos of the site and honestly it just baffles me that they want to rush the demolition without doing the homework first. People are messaging me constantly with their own memories of the building and it is pretty wild how much history we are just tossing aside because nobody wants to take the time to look at the facts. Still waiting on a real response from the commission but the silence from them is starting to speak for itself so keep checking back here for whatever happens next.
October 16, 2006
I honestly did not think this would gain this much steam but here we are and it makes me feel better knowing people actually care about the building because the commission is acting like it doesn't matter anyway. It feels weirdly validating to see this many people agree that we should at least look at the history before bulldozing the whole place.
6 Comments
L
Linda Abadi
19 years ago
Featured
My kids went there. It has so much character. Please let them at least study it before the bulldozers get there.
K
Karen Salazar
19 years ago
Featured
The city commission is being so short sighted. Listen to the planning board for once.
M
Mike Iyer
19 years ago
Featured
Ridiculous that they are rushing to tear this down without even checking into it. Do the study first Birmingham. What is the rush???
J
Jason Fletcher
19 years ago
Featured
Save the site. It is part of our hometown history.
S
Sarah Harvey
19 years ago
Featured
Stop the demolition! Once it is gone you cant get it back. Just look at the history before doing something you will regret later.
D
Dave Walsh
19 years ago
Featured
Tear it down and replace it with more bland condos. Classic Birmingham move. Just do the research first.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
100 signatures.
Your share link
Couldn't copy automatically. Long-press to copy:
Share directly
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via
.
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
We, the undersigned, respectfully request that the City Commission of Birmingham, Mich., direct the city\'s Historic District Study Committee to undertake a study of the Barnum property.
Both the Birmingham Planning Board and the city\'s Historic District Commission have urged the City Commission to ask the Study Committee to research and document the history of the Barnum School buildings and site and to make an objective recommendation on the historical value and the suitability for historic designation.
The two boards were bolstered by an opinion from Oakland County Principal Planner Bob Donahue, who deems the property worthy of study, and has offered his assistance in research and in working with the city to find an appropriate adaptive reuse strategy.
The City Commission has refused, and has voted to move toward demolition of the entire structure, including portions built in 1912 and 1929.
We, the undersigned, make no judgment about the historical significance of Barnum. Rather, we demand that the City Commission proceed only with full knowledge of the historical resources there. In view of the long-term nature of both the Barnum project and the consequences of City Commission action, and in view of the current lease agreement with Beaumont Hospital, which eliminates any cost of delay, we believe such a study is necessary and reasonable.
I have spent the entire morning staring at the old photos of the site and honestly it just baffles me that they want to rush the demolition without doing the homework first. People are messaging me constantly with their own memories of the building and it is pretty wild how much history we are just tossing aside because nobody wants to take the time to look at the facts. Still waiting on a real response from the commission but the silence from them is starting to speak for itself so keep checking back here for whatever happens next.
October 16, 2006
I honestly did not think this would gain this much steam but here we are and it makes me feel better knowing people actually care about the building because the commission is acting like it doesn't matter anyway. It feels weirdly validating to see this many people agree that we should at least look at the history before bulldozing the whole place.
6 Comments
L
Linda Abadi
19 years ago
Featured
My kids went there. It has so much character. Please let them at least study it before the bulldozers get there.
K
Karen Salazar
19 years ago
Featured
The city commission is being so short sighted. Listen to the planning board for once.
M
Mike Iyer
19 years ago
Featured
Ridiculous that they are rushing to tear this down without even checking into it. Do the study first Birmingham. What is the rush???
J
Jason Fletcher
19 years ago
Featured
Save the site. It is part of our hometown history.
S
Sarah Harvey
19 years ago
Featured
Stop the demolition! Once it is gone you cant get it back. Just look at the history before doing something you will regret later.
D
Dave Walsh
19 years ago
Featured
Tear it down and replace it with more bland condos. Classic Birmingham move. Just do the research first.
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach
100 signatures.
Your share link
Couldn't copy automatically. Long-press to copy:
Share directly
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
or sign with Email
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept our Terms and Privacy Policy and agree to occasional emails about petitions. Unsubscribe anytime.
My kids went there. It has so much character. Please let them at least study it before the bulldozers get there.