Spirit days are, in essence, an
outlet for students and teachers who face stresses and complications in other
parts of their life. They are meant to stir pride in one’s school and oneself
by uniting the student body by showing them one common goal. Pride can create a
sense of belonging in those who are dearly in need of it, but when the pride
that is generated is negative, it can also stir detrimental feelings in the
same people.
Pandy’s
Funeral and Santa Rosa Nerd Day are two spirit days at Montgomery High School
that have been hailed by the school population since the beginning of the
school’s rivalry with Santa Rosa High. While a healthy rivalry with another
school is amusing and part of the traditional school experience, these spirit
days are not.
Nerd Day is a time
when the student body and teachers dress as stereotypical nerds in the school
colors of the rival. This is wrong for many reasons, one being the negative
connotation that comes with the word “nerd”. Originally, those who were
considered nerds were bullied for their intelligence and appearance. By
dressing as ‘Santa Rosa Nerds’ the school insinuates that those who attend the
rival high school should be subject to bullying. It also implies that people in general should be bullied for
being knowledgeable, or for sporting a specific appearance.
Pandy’s Funeral
follows the example of Nerd Day by poking fun at the students of Santa Rosa
High, but this spirit day takes it to a larger, and more physical extent. In
this spirit day, the students of Montgomery High hold a mock funeral for the
mascot of Santa Rosa High. In this funeral, the mascot is humiliated in order
to show the Montgomery students in a better light. As a mascot is the
representation of its student body, Montgomery High School essentially
dehumanizes the students of Santa Rosa High when the students hold this funeral.
Especially when equality is, and has always been, a problem in this world,
Pandy’s Funeral does not help to stir pride in the student body. Instead, it
stirs the mentality that they are better than someone else.
One may argue that
these spirit days never result in violence, and so they are essentially
harmless. What these people do not see is that even if there is no physical
damage, those who participate in these spirit days leave with the mentality of
superiority makes them extremely dangerous. Others insist that, since these
spirit days are tradition, they cannot possibly be banned. However, in all cultures
there have been traditions that are considered to be dangerous in the modern
world, even if they were innocent when created. Finally, there are those who
argue that, since Santa Rosa holds the same spirit days, it is fine to do the
same to them. This idea brings up the concept of revenge and retribution. If
one school does something to another, do they have the right to fight back?
While answering yes brings satisfaction, it is important to remember that
revenge is a double-edged sword. If one person gets hurt, the other is bound to
as well.
In conclusion, the two
spirit days are unhealthy for the general mentality of Montgomery High School.
It promotes the ideas of bullying, superiority, and revenge. In order to
brighten the school campus, banning these spirit days is the best course of
action.
Thank you for your comments. They are all very valid points, and I appreciate your politeness. I made this petition knowing that I would get a lot of resistance. I was pleasantly surprised, however, when everyone was so nice with their comments. Contrary to popular belief, I love the idea of school spirit! I think it's an awesome idea that unites the student body. But I still believe that these two spirit days are wrong. I stand by my opinion, even if I do respect yours.