Ban Arif Abdul Hussain (Bata)

Ali Panju calls all those who have signed the petition stupid fools and that must include him - as he has signed. To call 1031 signers fools demonstrates the contempt in which WF holds those who object to the perversion of their religion from within by a renegade Aga Khani. WF in the post -Mullah Asgar MM Jaffer period has become a despicable organisation and some of its previous SG are in open revolt against Syed Sistani and in favour of the likes of Abdulkarim Soroush and Arif Bata. If the present SG is against Arif Bata as you appear to imply, then why has he not declared this openly and signed the petition.

Re Ali Panju. Clear evidence has emerged that SG's firm has been making donations to support Bata and no amount of airbrushing can conceal the importance of this fact. SG who led the philanthropists to Davos has a clear and undisclosed conflict of interest and must resign.This is the reason WF has come out a statement to placate the community. What has it been doing all these years that it now needs time to collect and analyse, if his statements are true. What did the WF do when he shortened the fasting times by 2 or 3 hours. WF did not ban Sachedina - this was done by Syed Sistani. Had it been left to WF they would still be analysing his book.

I saw the message regarding WF and I thought what nonsense are people speaking. 1. WF came out with a statement against Arif already 2. WF has set up a team (as per its statement) to meet Arif and see if his contents were true and then to take him to task i.e. involve the Marjae 3. It was WF who banned Sachedina 4. It was WF who banned Akram Majedi The people on this list are stupid fools. Picking on a SG of WF whose partner supports Al Mahdi but who himself does not is not befitting. Really - people like Fitna and to spread untruths without verification! May Allah (SWT) forgive them.

This type of so called mullas should be ban for entering the mosque

Neo con funding to attack Marjaiyat

If WF is opposed to Bata and taking him to task, surely they would have the petition. The fact is neither WF, CoEJ Nasimco or indeed Jamat committee members have signed. Yes, they either fearful of Bata or fully signed up to Bata's agenda.

Agreed with your comments and action to be taken on this individual who has no respect for our Imam a.s.

Sayyid Hassanain says that WF Office Bearers for first time are taking Arif to task. That is wishful thinking. This is a case of leopard airbrushing the spots for short term expediency.

Syed Mehdi, you cannot really remove the name Hussein which he has adopted instead of Bata. A large nuber of people adopt names like Hussein to acquire legitimacy and make of the sympathy that is their in the heart of belivers. Saddam Hussein being a case in point. His rule came to an end after a long period of terror and so will Bata's.

These kind of lectures Must be banned to protect our youths from being misguided

WF clearly attempting to hide links between Bata and Sachedina who has been banned. Sachedina is of course Bata's mentor and his work has been endorsed by Centre for Strategic Studies, a neo-convervative think tank based in Washington.

A clear case of conflict of interest. Shame on WF attempting to mislead community and Ayatollah Sistani

Sayyid Hassanain disputes that World Federation and its Secretary General are funding Ayatollah Bata and his Hawza Al-Mahdi Institute.I refer him to the published accounts of a MSA Global Holdings Ltd Co No 08128061 for the year end September 2014, a company of which he is Director and major share holder. This clearly states a sum of £11,000 was donated to Al-Mahdi Institute. WF and some of its officers have been working to a long term plan to modify or subvert our beliefs and religion from within. The Secretay General of WF led a large group of Khoja philanthropist to Davos 2017 in Switzerland. Clearly, he must have been encouraging his co-philanthropist's to donate to Al-Mahdi Institute.

A walk from Najaf to Karbala is one of The symbol of unity among the Shias and a great love to our holy ones Therefore any comments that indicates destroying of this unity I am against it thank you

The most hated so called mullah of the Shias

I was appalled that someone said the WF secretary general was in support of Arif! If anything WF, led by the President and SG, are doing something about this - infact I hear WF Office Bearers for first time are taking Arif to task - finally!

Ban him immediately

Yes he shud be

I really wants to banned such Sheikh Hussaini even take out the name of Hussain from his name Such person r not capable for such pure name Who is he to hurt aqedah

Ban him for lifetime and all those who support him....The entire chain