Skip to main content
Artemis Fowl Movie Casting Controversy

Artemis Fowl Movie Casting Controversy

288 signatures 212 to reach 500
D
Danilo R. signed
A
Adude signed
S
save_arty signed
M
Minerva signed
S
Someone signed
E
EDL signed
J
James I. signed
S
Someone signed
E
Eleanor H. signed
L
Lizzie signed
AA
Started by Anti Artemis Fowl Movie 8 years, 7 months ago

On December 20, 2017 the makers of the upcoming Artemis Fowl movie had released new information on their choice of actors/actresses. This did indeed grab the attention of the book's fans. Angered, confused, and upset they were (though some were excited that there was even progress being made). Long story short: us fans are unhappy with the casting choices due to many obvious reasons. With the help Tumblr user Pixiequinn, we were able to present this with you all today. Listed below are the multiple issues reagarding each character that we, the fans, see problematic so far:

  • Butler is described as a Eurasian man in the books, (start of chapter one, book one) and this is a big part of his character. Having him played by a black man takes away a vast amount of this character, changing him completely. But also takes away an opportunity of an Eurasian actor. He is also Artemis Fowls bodyguard, and is sworn to protect the boy. The Butler family has protected and served the Fowl family for years, and having a black man serve a white family has caused many people see the racist connotations.

(Textual proof of Butler's race)

  • Julius Root is the commander of the LEP (the police squad
    that Holly Short works for). Holly is, in the books, the first female
    officer in the squad, and so Root is constantly hard on her, pushing her
    further, and punishing her more for mistakes, because he wants her to
    prove herself, and knows many men won’t take her seriously. This is a
    huge plot point throughout the books, and changing Julius’s gender will
    have an impact on this effective story line. The impact will result in less feministic rights throughout the movie.
  • Holly Short is a member of the LEP. She is described as having “Nut brown skin”, (Start of chapter three, book one), and is an adult woman. Having her played by a child is unreasonable, as she is old enough to have a job, and is about 80, though ages appear younger. She is admittedly shorter than a human, but has adult features. Many fans also worry that this dramatic decrease in age will lead to a romantic relationship between her and Artemis, ruining their important, completely platonic, friendship. Pairing a canonically 80 year old with a 12 year old is extremely wrong, even if you must age down a character for this. Having her played by a white person is also an issue, as Holly Short is a role model throughout the books, and is someone children aspire to be. Having her as a brown woman gives young brown girls hope, and lets them be represented. They will not get this needed representation with a white character. It is racist to turn a brown character white, and there is no reason for this.

(Textual proof of Holly's charateristics)


Signing this petition would show your support as not only a fan of the Artemis Fowl series, but towards all due rights for racial equality/diversity and women in the workforce. Which this series already held onto greatly. We understand that the casting may not be changed immediately or at all, but we (as a fan base) would prefer legit reasoning for these casting choices. Which are to be of true value and not for diversifying a series - where it is not needed.

Thank You!

***There is no affiliation with this account in regards to the Artemis Fowl series' original author (Eoin Colfer) or the movies legal owners (Disney).

Updates

January 6, 2018

The casting choices ignore the source material and erase key details about the characters we grew up with. Post your specific concerns regarding these changes on Facebook to keep the pressure on the studio. Email the casting directors today and tell them why loyalty to the books matters.

January 6, 2018

The momentum behind this casting critique is undeniable and proves how much this story matters to readers. Send the link to your local book club members today to keep the pressure mounting on the studio.

Reached 100 supporters

January 6, 2018

89 Comments

K
Kat
8 years ago Featured

Artemis Fowl was a formative book series for me growing up— it taught me many lessons and focused on impactful themes that i feel are completely undermined by your casting choices. i would love to go see a treasured childhood story play out on the big screen but if the casting remains as it is, i will be disappointed before even entering the theatre

H
Heather Rusk
8 years ago Featured

This series has inspired me beyond compare and pulled me out of very dark places. The casting decisions are vastly different from the books and as stated by many others there are problems with the people cast. I'm sure they're all amazing actors but they just aren't right for this particular series in the roles they've been given.

S
Shannon Callahan
8 years ago Featured

Casting a white girl as Holly infantalizes her character and takes away an excellent opportunity for a black actress to shine in this role. Casting Commander Root as a woman negates a large part of Holly's character development in the books, and I would rather see Judi Dench play Vinyaya.

T
Tabitha Wilson
8 years ago Featured

They removed Holly being the 1st female LEPrecon officer... literally threw away the female role model breaking the gender barrier

R
Robyn
8 years ago Featured

I'm mostly here for Holly, tbh. She was my favorite character growing up, and remains one of my favorites now. Seeing such dramatic changes being made to such a brilliant character does not bode well for the quality of the movie. The books are amazing, and definitely deserve a more faithful adaptation.

L
Luiza Constant de Lima
8 years ago Featured

Please don't change what was the only book I've ever read with a platonic, lovely friendship between a male and a female characters.

D
Danilo Rodriguez
6 years ago

This movie is racist. Reasons stated above and more. It’s time for change. This racism in casting should no longer continue

A
Anonymous
6 years ago

Please retain the books' integrity and already diversified characters. Thank you.

Help this petition grow

Share it with friends to help reach 500 signatures.

Sign Petition

We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.

or sign with Email

Add a comment?

Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.

By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Share Petition

Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact

Copy link or share directly

Instagram
QR Code