Skip to main content

Speak out to the Napa DA in support of just punishment for felons who steal grapes

672 Comments

M
Mathew harrold
11 years ago

Sounds like he's friends with the DA..

L
Laura nelson
11 years ago

100% wrong! There is no way to pay back the loss...it would be sad to see any punishment less than the max

M
Mark Tate
11 years ago

This should be a felony

J
James Koller
11 years ago

I am a grape grower / farmer We need protection from people who steal are crops under the cover of darkness. Farming is exausting. Losing what the del dotto family lost is tragic. Their should be stuff penalties for stealing grapes. It is no different than Robbing a bank. let's send a tough message and slap this guy with 10 years in prison. He will be out in 5 with good behavior.

L
Lisa May
11 years ago

do right by Del Dotto! Theft of this proportion must not be overlooked.

L
Liz Holtzclaw
11 years ago

With a 24 year career in the wine business I agree that Mr. Hill's crime to which he pled no contest deserves the full penalties of the major crime that it was. Felony with jail time. I am confident that there will be federal charges to follow.

J
Jaclyn Nelson
11 years ago

My husband and I can not believe that someone who could steal grapes and takes away profit from a winery does not receive more punishment for his crime!!!

H
Heather Carlson
11 years ago

I'm in full support of Del Dotto!

M
Michael McMillan
11 years ago

I don't believe that this should be looked at as trying to make an example out of Mr. Hill in order to deter others. This has to be looked at as enacting justice in a case that has major implications and losses to many directly effected and even further reaching implications to the protection of the highly valuable brand of Napa Valley. Mr. Hill acted with full intent to break the law and should be punished to the full extent of the law.

A
Andrew Eggert
11 years ago

If he'd stolen an $ 800000 tractor or sports car what would his sentence be?

M
Marlo Klein
11 years ago

I think they should reimburse the businesses that have been affected by this-it's The right thing to do. How will these businesses recover?

R
Robert M Mrozek
11 years ago

A plea deal is not acceptable in preventing this action in the future.

R
Rebecca Scarratt
11 years ago

Please consider the consequences of Mr Hills actions and the impact on our valleys growers and wineries! I'm of the belief that if the punishment is not severe it allows the dishonest to continue the crimes. .. Sincerely RJS

P
Pia Morris
11 years ago

Please punish to the full extent of the law.

M
Michael O'Neill
11 years ago

Jeff Hill has destroyed the trust built up in the valley for decades. He belongs in jail.

O
Oderus Urungus
11 years ago

Forced sky burial

R
Rickey Trombetta
11 years ago

This is about right and wrong, following the laws and being a good citizen. Too many times it becomes a game between lawyers finagling and twisting the interpretation of the law to their benefit. A major crime has been committed and the innocent party has been hurt. How about restitution for them in the form of justice.

D
Duane Hoff
11 years ago

This was a major crime and inflicted damage on the victim's brand and his loss of income. He committed a felony and deserves a felony conviction.

B
Beverly Brown Flynn
11 years ago

Clearly a felony. This is not petty theft of bubble gum in the candy store. It should be prosecuted as a felony and he should be tried as such.

V
Vic Gundotra
11 years ago

How is a $800,000 theft considered a misdemeanor? Please help fix this.