Skip to main content

Speak out to the Napa DA in support of just punishment for felons who steal grapes

672 Comments

S
Susan Glasheen
11 years ago

This theft hurts more than the vineyards, it hurts the consumer who purchases wines. If you reduce the sentence of this convict than you are saying you don't care about the cost to the consumer. Then we will be looking at your future career!

L
Lisa Hanson
11 years ago

Thieves SUCK....

A
Ashley Crooker
11 years ago

For someone to steal 800K worth of material, admit to his guilt and expect to get a felony reduced to a misdemeanor is shocking... even more shocking is a justice system that would allow this. He should be sentenced for the felony and barred from employment in the industry for a few years...

L
L Rogers
11 years ago

This action was a major theft under the law and the appropriate punishment should be for a Felony and not a Misdemeanor. A man needs to be held accountable for his actions.

W
William Dixey
11 years ago

This case is a felony, please treat it as such

C
Craig Junio
11 years ago

Please give Mr. Hill the proper punishment. He theft has been proven and does not deserve leniency.

C
Chaya Donne
11 years ago

This was not a petty crime. Mr. Hill obviously knew the value of what he was stealing from hard working vintners and should not receive a reduced sentence.

B
Brendan Duggan
11 years ago

Inexcusable, good luck! We love your wine.

D
Dan Nelson
11 years ago

I encourage the judge to enforce a strict penalty. An example needs to be made and people need to know there is a big enough penalty if they get caught to deter the behavior.

K
Katherine Nguyen
11 years ago

A 13 year old stealing a $10 lipstick at Target, that's a misdemeanor. What this greedy scumbag has done is FAR from a misdeanor. This is grand theft and deserves the highest penalty! Please give him an $800,000 lesson for his crime!

A
Anonymous
11 years ago

How would it be even remotely alright to only prosecute this crime as a misdemeanor? Mr. Hill wants to play with the big boys, let him pay with the big boys.

G
Gregory Fina
11 years ago

Given the Plea agreement, Mr. Hill should serve time for his felony conviction.

R
Robert J. Donnan
11 years ago

I also support the Del Dotto's in this situation. If the crime committed is a felony; then the charge should be a felony.

D
Debra Blanchard
11 years ago

I support holding people accountable for their actions, therefore, since the theft was in an amount that resulted in a felony, I opposed any reduction in severity.

A
Anthony T Meola
11 years ago

The punishment of a crime should not be lessonedby the admission of guilt -rather extended by the attempt to tell the truth to begin with!

J
John Patrick Rooke
11 years ago

This is a "Felony" all the way. Mr. Hill needs to "come clean" and take his punishment like a Man...

G
Gina Kline
11 years ago

Please do not drop Mr. Hill's felonies to misdemeanors. It will only send the message to other criminals that the punisment for stealing valuable grapes is "no big deal" because it's just a misdemeanor. Mr. Hill needs committed felonies and should serve time in jail.

R
Robert Sheffield
11 years ago

I believe that the felony charges should not be reduced. This is not some teenage prank that perhaps warrants some consideration. This was an adult making the decision to steal from someone else.

A
Anise Abdulla
11 years ago

You will be sending the wrong message if leniency is granted. This man knows better than to commit such an absurd act!

D
Dean Furkioti
11 years ago

I support the sentiment expressed in the letter from the Del Dotto family regarding the theft of their grapes.