Wounded Knee Medals of Dis Honor

It is past time these slaughters, these murders, were recognized as the atrocities they really are.

This kind of inhumanity needs to be held up to the light in hopes it will never be repeated.

Long over due. We should not honor murderers of women and children.

way past time for this

Make the Medal of Honor meaningful.

There is no honor in butchering the defenseless

Some things in this nations past are truly saddening

There is, and was, nothing to honor in this action. It was, and is shameful.

As a white American I ask these medals be recinded. The awarding of these cheapens all others deservedly awarded.

Correct this wrong.

Time to acknowlege that this was a horrible crime, not a heroic battle.

The names of those Lakota who were massacred at Wounded Knee must be honored. Not the soldiers who took their lives.

These medals should have never been awarded. Medals for shooting elders, women and children. Disgraceful.

Remember

No comment !...

I believe that we as a nation, have become more aware of the way history belongs to the victor. Some soldiers got caught up in the propaganda of the time, and truely believed they were doing good. How a thinking person could massacre woman and children and unarmed men, is unbelievable, but let's not allow this to continue to shame us.

USA ! shame on you! That was a crime!!

Crime against native people are still being carried out, even today...

this is a no-brainer....but, sadly those in a position to do anything about it care more about those in power than those who's ancestors were slaughtered.

What about the MOH awardees for the Sand Creek Massacre in Colorado 1861.

A true travesty and breaks my heart still.

si on échappe a la justice humaine! on échappera pas a celle divine !

We need to share the land. We need to listen to Native wisdom about living on the land. We need to decolonize our minds. This was a massacre, not a military victory. The aims of these military actions were abhorrent and indefensible. It's a tragedy for Native Americans and all Americans. We need to face these tragedies, so that we create the possibility of future.

The Native American genocide continues to this day. The United States Government is willingly involved with this latest disgrace. The Massacre at Wounded Knee was a truly horrible act that should be acknowledged by Removing all United States symbols. This site should be a Holocaust Memorial honoring the Natve Americans who were slaughtered there.

Natives should stop become soldiers in the army and participate in US wars!

There is no honor, in this murderous event, against innocent men, women, and children! History can not be changed. However, it can be honored, by telling the truth.

Rhian are you kidding? Did you really say that? You are an idiot ! Plain and simple...natives helped the US win world war 2...thy were called the code talkers...google that sometimes..then read, and please dont comment on what the natives should do....until you have studied american history...and not the bs you got in school thy were lies...How bout you go live on Pine Ridge, why dont you try to live one year there....then talk ...you live in a different world...and have no clue...Natives dont live in the same America you do....

Make this right!! Never too late.

Disgrace...

Please rescind these medals of ( Dis ) honor. The truth speaks for itself.

Please take the time to view this sad, but truthfull documentary,and then take action to expose this holocaust/genocide of the indigenous people's of this land of the free and brave at the hands of so-called Christian government.peace,truth and light

NEVER FORGET!

This was a massacre of men women and children, and you honored them for murdered! Shame!!!!! They should be disgraced!!!!!

As a retired U.S. Army Officer, I find it disgraceful that these medals still stand.

Rescinding these medals is the only honorable thing to do, even though it can never make up for the horrific actions against all natives of this land.

No Duty and Honor here! Please rescind!!!

Honor the victims, not their murderers.

This was not a military battle. This was a massacre, and medals ahould be rescinded. It's a small step in the right direction towards righting a huge injustice.

No medals for murderers

The medals of honor should be removed from these men!!! It was not a courageous thing to kill innocent women, children, elderly. Honor needs to return to the Native Americans.

An atrocious dark spot in our history.

Please preserve and honor those killed at Wounded Knee. This would be one big step to help heal our people. It would show you care about the atrocities done to us Chi Miigwech. Carmen "Little Fawn" Bares.

No man should be honored for taking part in a massacre of women and children and unarmed men. If they were trying to stop the massacre, that alone would be commendable.

Wounded Knee was a massacre of innocent men, women and children.

Killing in the name of God, manifest destiny, and revenge is dishonorable. Rescind all the medal of honor citations in connection with this act of mass murder. Jeffrey Franklin Cochran

May God forgive them for this sinful disgrace. The disgrace continues on the president and legislature.

Any and all award should be rescinded.

by keeping these medals we are covering history up

What acts were honorable in this massacre? This was a disgrace and MOH Is a joke in this case. Pathetic!!

About time.

The Congressional Medal of Honor is an award for acts of Valor, above and beyond the call of duty. It is because of this requirement that most medals of honor recipients of the last 100 years DIED to get them. Saving comrades in arms, eliminating enemy fortifications singlehandedly, and doing both simultaneously. Sgt. York from World War 1 is a perfect example of Medal of Honor criteria. He took two German machine guns and more than 100 enemy soldiers prisoner using only his M1911 pistol. The medals given out after Wounded Knee, that can only be described has a massacre, bring shame upon all recipients of the CMH. These blood medals were earned through murder. And they must be rescinded.

These medals need to be taken away immediately.

This is very upsetting I hope those metals are taken away from those ungrateful cruel soldiers

My own extensive research of the issue of giving Medals Honor to most, if not all, of those of the 7th Calvary brings shame to them for accepting them as well as those who awarded them. The records and THE FACTS bear out this was a massacre such as that which occurred at the My Lei Massacre some years later. Shameful history 7th Calvary. Be man enough to cooperated in returning the medals and instead prosecute, in abstentia of course, the murders for their sins committed against human kind.

That these 23 men were awarded the nation's highest military honor--supposedly for valor above and beyond the call of duty--for cold-blooded murder in retaliation for Little Bighorn, makes a mockery of the Medal of Honor. Yes, rescind their medals at once!

Don't let this crime against history stand.

It is time for us all to join together and share our land with the people who live in the badlands and all the other lands who live in with the tribes.

I know we cannot change what has been done but by this gesture, at least, the white people are admitting that what was done was WRONG! It's not much, but it helps.

There were many more exterminations of Indians in the settlement period.

It is the only RIGHT thing to do. We must learn from our past ..... and acknowledge that we, too, have committed inhuman atrocities. We MUST NOT honor them lest we repeat them.

Genocide should not be decorated with the Congressional Medal of Honor. STOP THIS HISTORICAL INSULT TO THE NATION'S ORIGINAL PEOPLE.

There is no justification for offering America's highest military honor to perpetrators of this atrocity, the 19th century equivalent of the My Lai massacre.

Nothing can undo the atrocity of Wounded Knee. However, I believe that, because this nation has set high standards for itself, it is critical that we admit where those standards have been horrifically violated and take responsibility for them.

Murderous acts should not be awarded with medals. No Medal of Honor for murdering innocent. This is in aberration.

This is consistent with so much of American history that we can never go back and make amends for every crime and injustice. It continues to this day.

Collect your honour and end this disgrace.

Cowardly murder of defenseless women & CHILDREN is NOT honorable!! This is a NO BRAINER! NO medals!

A lot of time has passed. Too much, really. It is time to do the right thing and rescind these Medals of (dis)honor. It was murder, plain and simple, slaughter unforgivable, a stain on the history of this country. Undo it. At least, START.

WAY overdue!

This massacre was never a suitable basis upon which to bestow our nation's most coveted honor. Rectify this travesty, in the name of those who truly deserved the Congressional Medal of Honor.

Sadly, the election of Donald Trump demonstrates that Euro-Americans have not changed and still do not respect life and diversity. Of course the medals should be rescinded, and every soldier involved at Wounded Knee should be tried and convicted for participating in genocide. Their names should be remembered with disgust.

We can't save lives long lost or use the principle employed at Nuremberg that required members of the military to be held accountable for carrying out immoral orders. These murderers are all dead and gone along with their victims. But we can strip them of awards for murdering innocents, and we owe it to the victims to do so.

The Nazi SS killed tens of thousands people and were awarded medals for their service. Evil deeds need to be treated as such and not rewarded with medals!

A small tribute for all of the tragedies that have been fostered upon all the Native American tribes since the coming of the Europeans.

Why celebrate genocide? It's nothing to honor.

Time for the U.S. to demonstrate "Honor and Courage" by withdrawing the medals given to soldiers participating in the massacre at Wounded Knee.

It´s about time

What a senseless act against Native Americans.

Rescind the Congressional Medal of Honor and replace it with a Medal of Shame.

There should have been charges of acts against humanity brought against the 7th; not honors given.

I am sorry native people were slaughtered on their land by American soldiers. God help us.

By all means rescind the Medal of Honor. There was no honor in this shameful act.

Killing innocent women and children is NEVER honorable.

I am 1/4 Crow Indian. My ancestors suffered from the European invasion. Genocide should never be lauded. It is a stain upon this nation. Rescind medals of Dis Honor that should never have been given.

US amends must be made to our Native people's for the losses they endured at the hands of the US government military!

Giving those men a medal for what they did is the same as giving Hitler a medal for slaughtering the Jews. Shame will befall those generations who participated in this horrible act.

There are still many devils among the white invaders. One was just declared to be the next potus.

Shame should not be rewarded.

Long overdue.

En l'honneur de mes frères amérindiens..

I'm surprised this hasn't been done already it's a disgrace .

Mór an náire

82nd airborne vet who has visited wounded knee site.

And basic training part of our education was the history and the requirements of the medal of honor this conflict would not have met those requirements

Hope my signature will be usefull !

The Medal of Honor should represent the highest virtues of valor and sacrifice. That this medal has been awarded to war criminals is a insult to all other recipients of that same award.

Hello

While we cannot erase the horrors of the past, we must acknowledge what happened, face the truth, repent, and take action to make amends as best as possible. This is one small step we as a Nation ought to do in repenting for our mistreatment of the Native Americans and our fellow Human Beings. Those who participated in this massacre, were following orders and should not be condemned more harshly than any other soldier at the time, however they do not deserve any special recognition especially as those they killed were unarmed and included children. This breached both 19th century and modern expectations/rules of combat.

Absolutely shameful incident of ruthless slaughter, but only the last of a multitude since the time of Clodumbass in 1492. The families and descendants should investigate the truth, and subsequently do the right thing and return these medals of shameful “dis-honor”. The policy of mass genocides and cultural annihilations by the government of this “great” land must be brought to light, taught in our schools, and atoned for. This land is really founded on the principles of lie/cheat/steal and rape/pillage/plunder. How’s that for the guys in the white hats?

Appalling and shameful, let’s try to make things right

Where is the honor is slaughtering defenseless men, women, and children? The MOH is given to our soldiers who have performed acts of bravery and gallantry, and it cheapens that honor when it is awarded for acts like Wounded Knee. These medals must be rescinded.

Clearly this was a horrible military snafu. these medals should only be issued to people for conduct above and beyond the call of duty, not for drunken retaliation of the Little Big Horn Battle.

the medals of honor are a shame

The medals shouldn't have been given in the first place. They killed innocent men, women and children.

Wounded Knee: On the morning of December 29, 1890, the US Army demanded the surrender of all Sioux weapons. Amid the tension, a shot rang out, possibly from a deaf brave who misunderstood his chief's orders to surrender. The Seventh Cavalry — the reconstructed regiment lost by George Armstrong Custer — opened fire on the Sioux. The local chief, Big Foot, was shot in cold blood as he recuperated from pneumonia in his tent. Others were cut down as they tried to run away. When the smoke cleared almost all of the 300 men, women, and children were dead. Some died instantly, others froze to death in the snow. This massacre marked the last showdown between Native Americans and the United States Army....The 1890 United States census declared the frontier officially closed. Time goes on and on but Men do not!!! It they thought they could get away with it the Pipe line would be another Wounded Knee 1890-2016. ~~~Jack Crow~~~ Credit: Christopher John Lamb

It's the right thing to do.

This is the time to acknowledge the dishonor of this massacre !

This is a small step in recognizing that many evil efforts were performed in order to eliminate Native Americans.

My God Almighty. My Almighty God

War Criminals!

I've been able to find absolutely nothing honorable about the conduct of U.S. Army personnel at Wounded Knee, SD, on December 28, 1890.

I was at the last Wounded Knee, May have stopped the Marshals’ assault on the town. National outrage!

This is long overdue!

The time to reconcile with the original inhabitants of this continent is long overdue. The same Creator made us all, and this is the only earth we have. We need to live in peace and harmony.

Rescinding these medals, which should be awarded only for acts of honor, is long overdue. No one should be honored for preforming acts of genocide on innocents.

People should not be honored for slaughtering children.

There is no honor in cold blooded murder. The US military never engages anyone who has the ability to defend themselves, that has not changed.

Wounded knee is a blot on U.S. history.

Shameful!

This action was not honorable

The slaughter of Native Americans at Wounded Knee in 1890 was a crime of the worst order. Instead of being court-martialed, the commanders and their soldiers got Medals of Honor. While the crime cannot be undone, the medals can be stripped away from these men, correcting a national moral outrage.

Right a wrong from 125 years ago. It's the right thing to do.

Let's correct a grievous wrong! Overdue!

Massacres of innocents should not be celebrated as military victories.

As a volunteer writer for a charity trying to aid the Lakota while respecting their incredible culture (One Spirit), I fully support righting this egregious wrong.

Mitakwe Oyasin. May we all live in peace. We can't change the past, but we can build a better the future together.

Medals of honor have no place on those who slaughter innocents and the unarmed.

Do the right thing.

As a nation of immigrants we must recognize and reject our past atrocities; further we must fight to yet more cruelty and injustice now.

This is long overdo and it makes me ashamed to be an American!

This is one of the biggest stains in the history of our country. It's past time to own up to it.

We need to own the injustice perpetrated upon the indigenous peoples of this country. It matters not if our ancestors participated in the murder because it is still going on. We must admit it, own it and make amends.

We’ve treated the indigenous people very badly then and today. The reservations need health care, a descent education, job training and incentives to help the people find jobs. I believe our society treats many indigenous people very badly.

80221

Yes!

Member: REAL Veterans Against Adolph(draft dodger/pervert/baby killer/good Nazi/anti-Christ/pedophile/Putin's stooge)Trump & his enabling Republicanazi traitors, perverts, crooks, bigots, & voter suppressing, war mongering robber barons of the 4th Reich!

I visited Black Kettle in OK - it was a very moving experience. I hope some day to equally pay my respects at Wounded Knee.

It is hard for one era to judge another, but this Slaughter cannot be excused

We sometimes forget that the brutality of Nazi Germany was not by any stretch of the imagination unique to History. Our ancestors, and some of their living descendants, had/have a limited ability to grasp the humanity of those who think and live a little differently than they do. When a Medal of Honor is awarded for an act of dishonor and needless brutality, it tarnishes all the other Medals ever awarded. This needs to be fixed, not only as a symbol of repentance and apology, but also to remove the stain on this high honor.

An grave injustice can be undone. As a healing nation, we must do this! It took 35 years for anyone to welcome me home from Vietnam...they were all Native Americans!

This was an atrocity. No medals were given to Nazis after WWII.

IT'S ABOUT TIME SOMETHING POSITIVE IS BEING DONE FOR OUR PEOPLE.

It is time we All Stand Together!!!

May their names live in infamy ... and high time, too!

Wounded Knee massacre is one of the most horrific blots on the history of this Country. I cannot believe the participating soldiers were given medals for the wholesale slaughter of women, children, babies. These medals must be rescinded. I cannot imagine how soldiers, even of that time, could participate in such an act. The extent of hatred for our Native peoples is appalling.

War crimes should never be rewarded.

Atrocities like the slaughter of men, women, and children, including infants, should NEVER have been rewarded with medals of honour in the first place. Those medals MUST be rescinded immediately!

It breaks my heart to know how the Native Americans were treated by the U.S. government. Please revoke the medals given to people who committed this atrocity.

I cannot agree more.

Wounded Knee was not a place of U.S. Military glory. It is a place that should serve as a reminder, like any place of mass slaughter, of the inhumanity of humans to other humans. The First Nations of the Americas deserve every restitution and remedy we can offer... and more. The U.S. must atone, beginning with rescinding any medal awarded during/for this massacre of First Nation people.

Mitakuye Oyasın Wanbli Wicahcala for sharing this. Peace and love.

Since when do we reward atrocities?

Since when do we reward atrocities?

Massacring innocent women and children is NOT what the CMH is for. This is a DEPLORABLE part of our history. The lives can't be restored, BUT HONOR DEMANDS the Medals of Honor be rescinded.

As a 34 year military veteran, I am disgusted with some of our nation's atrocities related to Native Americans, Japanese internment, slavery, Jim Crow.... the list goes on. The MoH.... as all medals, should only be awarded to worthy candidates.... not war criminals.

Justice delayed, but not forgotten

no honor for dishonor

Do not honor the murderers of children.

I heartily agree that giving Congessional Nedals of Honor to the US Army members who massacred women and children at Wounded Knee is a horrific disgrace. Those who conduct genocide must not be honored. The medals must be rescinded.

This was such a tragedy, and massacre.

In honor of my 4X great grandma and 2X great grandfather who narrowly escaped the Trail of Tears

This is totally disgusting, that murders were committed, and then, these bastards were honored for them. I'm ashamed.

This is a wrong that can easily be righted; rescind these medals.

Atrocities are not matters for celebration. Rescind the Medals of Dishonor.

It is way past time...

We stole their land, we killed their ansectors and gave them small pox. Recsend any military honors for killing defense less people.

No words can adequately capture the horror and the shame of these despicable actions taken by despicable men so long ago. And yet these disgusting attitudes toward Original Americans stull persist in our continued disregard for their rights, their culture, and for the very treaties we have made and continually broken. When will it stop? Begin by taking away the symbols of praise, these medals of ... what? Honor? I think not. These petty justifications for slaughter and genocide, take them and stomp them into the ground on the shore of Wounded Knee Creek as another symbol that this will never happen again and aid in healing the attitudes that have conspired to thwart the progress and dignity of our indigenous brothers and sisters.

time to be human

I support this and I wish they would change everything, like street names and all that. Maybe give them native American names.

Genocide exists through the ages. This is one of the most cruel situation performed by humanity

Native Americans have been treated as less than human and continue to suffer from efforts to destroy their culture, take their land and defile their sacred places. The damage done cannot be reversed, but we need to address each and every instance of violence, disenfranchisement and disrespect in meaningful ways and stop glorifying those responsible for the carnage and cruelty. Rescinding these medals is one small, but necessary, step toward healing.

This was one of the most heinous crimes ever perpetrated on the Native American people. To be honored for slaughtering women and children is an abomination, not to be tolerated. Rescind the medals, for there is nothing honorable in their actions

This is one of the most sickening, disturbing things I have ever read.

Another in a long line of disgusting atrocities committed in the name of some ridiculous reason in this case just like the Jews entitlement and genocide. No one should be proud of the murderous actions of a bunch of blood thirsty hateful 'men.' Only in the us would someone be commended for such a horrifying act. I say give Native American's their rightful place in world until we came existed in peace respect and harmony.

Awarding the Medl of Honor to murderers of American-Indians insults and demeans all other Medal wimmers.

Never Again, EVER!

Those medals MUST be recinded, they are not deserving!!!!!!

About time!

There is no glory or honor in the acts committed by the murders at Wounded Knee.

Should Americans be proud of the way our ancestors butchered their way from sea to shinning sea; leaving a sea of blood in between?

Do the honorable thing and rescind the medals. Murder shouldn't be honored.

Genocide has no place in a civilized society, and no one participating in such endeavors deserves any honor of any kind. The only honorable thing to do is to rescind the medals.

"They landed at Plymouth Rock, and shot and MURDERED their way, all the way across the country!" - Dick Gregory.

Too sickeningly long overdue.

Peace and Love Always

I have recently gone to volunteer with Ti-pi raisers. After asking what I could do politically, I was pointed in this direction! Thanks! -Esmee

RIP...

Correct the wronged history.

Où est l'honneur que de tuer femmes, enfants, vieillards?

Absolutely appalling that these honors have not been rescinded years ago. This is what the Black Lives Matter movement is making visible. Do the right thing to allow healing and unity: Offer a full official apology to the tribes(compensation) and sentence the perpetrators, posthumously.

Any decent and right thinking person would see this is the right thing to do.

This won't make it right. But it will be a start.

Rescind the Wounded Knee Medals of Honor awarded to 7th Cavalry members and teach the REAL history of this despicable tragedy in all schools. People MUST know the truth of what happened there - "Honor" was not present among US Army soldiers that horrible day!

Rescinding the 7th Cavalry Medals of Honor awarded for the Wounded Knee Massacre. There was no honor in the actions of the soldiers on this awful day!

This is wrong on so many levels. Although the killings cannot be undone, it is only through acknowledgement of this country's wrong that we can atone for our sins.

Peace cannot prevail as long as these atrocities are not addressed

So wrong ......

Que la vérité éclate et que justice soit faite.

long long overdue

Truly a dishonor to the Medal of Honor. As a combat Veteran of the Vietnam War, I have seen bravery during battle. The Wounded Knee massacre will always be a disgrace in the history of the 7th Cavalry.

Que plus jamais de massacres comme celui-ci ne se produise

It was a huge shame and crime to give medals to murderers for murder of innocent people ,mostly women and children.