Skip to main content

NO to Vigil for Palestine on October 7

48 Comments

A
Alyssa Freeman Verified

Inappropriate and insulting to have on the date Hamas took 250 Israeli hostiages and killed 1000 civilians! Imagine having a vigil memorial for Custer after Little Bighorn, or for the terrorists responsible for 9/11!

L
Leetah Stanley Verified

The choice of October 7th as the date for this commemoration is a classic passive-aggressive move: Confrontational, at least, and more accurately an act of violence/hatred toward Israel, and Jewish people, generally, at a time when anti-Semitism is rising at an alarming rate . That's a surprising choice for an organization who prides itself on unity and inclusivity.

R
Robyn Galpern Verified

It is no longer naive to be unaware of the 10/7 attocities, rape, beheading, disfiguring, burning alive and kidnapping that happened to the only Jewish country. It can only be called complacent or antisemitic. The retaliation for the Hamas and Palestinian attacks didnt start until weeks later. This event is heartless

H
Heather Hanson Verified

It’s appalling to plan a “vigil for the loss of life” in the attacking country on the anniversary of the massacre they committed just a few short years ago. Hostages have not even been returned from captivity for a full year yet. Choosing this particular date is not a remembrance of Gaza’s dead so much as it is a celebration of the atrocities that were committed in Israel on this date. These organizers should be ashamed of themselves. I’m sure they’re not, but they should be.

L
Laurel Herman Verified

It’s seriously in bad taste

L
Linda Sommers Verified

Vigil should be for the victims of Hamas’ genocidal mission

M
Milan Hapala Verified

My wife expressed my thoughts exactly—the event must be rescheduled to a date other than October 7th!

S
Susan Hapala Verified

Holding a vigil for Palestinian people who are enduring enormous suffering is not the issue. The issue is holding this vigil on October 7th which is the anniversary of a horrific act of terrorism in which innocent Israeli citizens were slaughtered or taken hostage. I am asking the Board of First UU Church to please re-schedule this vigil for another day.

J
Joanne Nordlinger Verified

I’m shocked that the UU would even consider having this vigil on October 7. No matter how one feels about the Palestinian vs Israeli governments, having a vigil in support of Palestinian rights on the very anniversary of when 1200 Israeli people were slaughtered and raped. Certainly this is not a UU principle, let alone a humanistic principle. Antisemitism has gone rampant in the name of Palestine. How much more rhetoric do we endure before there is a modern day pogrom here in the US.

S
Shoshana Spiegel Verified

This is a brazen example of antisemitism

N
Nannette Shor Verified

Disrespectful to all those murdered on and after 10-7-23

M
M Isra-Ul Verified

It seems clear why this date was chosen. Being reminded of the actions of October 7th by a terrorist organization against non-combatants, a better day for this event should have been chosen. Those who desire real peace do not take actions that divide the community. It is important to always realize how our actions impact people on the ground where we are. Peace starts with us and works its way out into the world. May Palestine be truly free.

A
Amy Altman Verified

I think it is disrespectful to the victims, especially the women raped and burned by Palestinians/Hamas who send pictures home smiling and cheering their crimes of Humanity. By having a vigil on October 7th you are sending a clear message that you do not care about what happened to Israeli's especially the women. If anything, there should be a memorial for the victims on October 7th if you are willing to hold a vigil for the Palestinians.

J
Jessica Levy-Lavelle Verified

This is in poor taste. Grieve for all, but not by disrespecting such a somber and horrific time.

S
Sandra Mayer Verified

As a Jewish woman, I am appalled that First Union would choose October 7 for a vigil for Palestinians. Perhaps the organizers should view the documentary “October 8,” since they appear to be ignorant of what actually transpired that day. Or is it, perhaps, that they believe Jews and Israelis deserved to be mutilated, burned, raped and starved as hostages?

J
Judith Nelson Verified

There are many countries that warrent our attention. The Sudan warrants our attention, Ukraine, Yemen to start. So why is the focus always on Israel. I do not defend their actions. I'm ashamed of them. But the amount of world attention this gets compared to other countries is only about one thing. They're Jewish.

M
Martin Wegbreit Verified

Let me be very clear in my comment. The State of Israel has a right to exist, to have secure borders, to defend itself, and to respond in a proportionate manner to murderous attacks such as that launched by Hamas on 10/7/23. However, the response launched against Hamas has been vastly too extreme. Both things can be true at the same time and both need to be acknowledged whenever the issue is appropriately discussed -- which is NOT on October 7.

T
Tracy Herman Verified

This rally is a disgusting display of Jew-hatred and disrespect towards the victims of Oct. 7th and should be shut downdown.

C
Conor Shapiro Verified

This event is in poor taste to host on the anniversary of the massacre of our people.

M
Matthew Schor Verified

Is there no end to Jew hatred? This is horrendous.