Skip to main content

NO to Vigil for Palestine on October 7

48 Comments

J
Joel Blum Verified

I strongly support the need to recognize and actively address the enormous suffering of the Palestinian People. I totally agree, however, that choosing to do so on October 7th (which has been the chosen date for this vigil the past few years) and support this by having it take place at the 1st UU Church here in Richmond, where I am a member, is totally wrong and inconsistent with our Principals and Values. I hope the Church Board will decide to withdraw the authorization for this Oct. 7 vigil

H
Harlan Loebman Verified

I’m tired of anti semitism hiding under the cloak of righteous where there is none. We know the insidious and nefarious true goal. If the true goal came out very few if any one would say that holding this program on Oct 7 is anything but anti semitism. Stop saying it is anti Israeli policy when we know the true meaning is just anti Jew.

A
Aaron LeBauer Verified

It should be pretty obvious. But October 7 is the anniversary of the deadliest attack on Israel by Hamas and the Palestinian people care should be taken when choosing dates, especially this one.

J
Julie Marczak Verified

Because having this vigil on October 7 is a travesty!!!!

A
Adele Karp Verified

Choosing the date of the largest massacre of Jewish people since the Holocaust to hold this vigil is not only insensitive but a slap in the face to the Jewish people. This does not seem in keeping with the values the Unitarian Universalist Church supposedly supports.

S
Supporter Verified

I am dismayed that the UU church is holding a vigil for Palestinians on October 7. For Jews, October 7 is not simply another date on the calendar, it is the anniversary of the deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust, when more than 1,200 people were murdered and hundreds were taken hostage. Acknowledging Palestinian suffering is very important, but doing so on this date without also honoring the Jewish lives lost and the trauma inflicted on the Jewish community feels painful.

S
Supporter Verified

It’s time for reconciliation and not provocation. It’s time to stop the hatred and to hear and respect all voices. It’s time to make steps towards peace.

A
Ali Scales Verified

Isn’t anything sacred anymore?

M
Michael Jones Verified

Its immoral and cruel to hold this event on the anniversary of the attack on Israel by Hamas.

E
Elizabeth Brody Verified

Can you imagine this sort of insensitivity to any other minority?!

S
Supporter Verified

This is totally disrespectful and gross

D
Deb Wolff Verified

I have always valued and respected UU principles and actions. I value the equanimity the UU communities strive for. On Oct 7, people were massacred, raped, kidnapped, burned. Please choose a different date. If not, the message is that what happened in Oct 7 was acceptable. This does not negate what has happened to innocents who live in Gaza but instead demonstrates an understanding that Oct 7 was unacceptable.

S
Steven Saltzberg Verified

Unitarian Universalist put LOVE in the center of it work and meaning. The choice of October 7 is not about love!

G
Gregory Jorgenson Verified

This is not only insensitive. It’s sending a very inappropriate message.

P
Paul Ludwig Verified

There are 365 days in a year and this group chooses October 7 to recognize Palestinian suffering? The day the Palestinians slaughtered, took hostage, raped, beheaded, burned alive, and tortured Israelis and you don’t see this as evil?

E
Ellie Eve Verified

October 7 is the anniversary of one of the most horrific attacks on Jews in modern history—the massacre of 1,200+ people, the taking of hostages, and the brutal atrocities committed against innocent civilians. For Jewish people, this date carries enormous grief, trauma, and significance. There are 364 other days of the year on which a vigil for Palestinian lives could be held. Choosing October 7, of all dates, feels particularly painful and deliberately provocative.

F
Fran Gewirtz Verified

Very shocking for any type of religious entity to hold a vigil on October 7 when Hamas massacred innocent Jewish people and took mothers and babies hostage.

A
Anita Schneuder Verified

Scheduling this vigil for Palestine on October 7th, the date of the greatest mass murder of Jews since the Holocaust, shows a callous disregard for Jewish lives. The message it sends is that Israeli Jewish lives are of no concern to us.

S
Staci Assael Verified
Featured

It’SA day that was purposely chosen to be cruel. It is immoral, please allow some dignity in this country to not allow this!

R
Risa Levine Verified
Featured

Having this vigil on the anniversary of a tragic day for Jewish people in Israel is disrespectful. I am surprised that the Unitarian Universalist Church would plan such an event.