Skip to main content
PUBLIC APOLOGY FOR MISS WORLD CANADA SEMI FINALIST ZIYAH KARMALI

PUBLIC APOLOGY FOR MISS WORLD CANADA SEMI FINALIST ZIYAH KARMALI

155 signatures 95 to reach 250
L
lily signed
M
Michelle G. signed
S
Someone signed
P
Parm S. signed
L
Laurie W. signed
B
Barb G. signed
F
Fey R. signed
M
Mathew D. signed
F
farah l. signed
F
Farah M. signed
Started by Anonymous 16 years, 2 months ago
The Miss World Canada 2010 contest held Friday March 7th 2010 by new Vancouver-based franchise-holders, Upstage This! Productions should be ashamed for some of it's disrespectful practices. Six (6) semifinalists spots were guaranteed to be reserved for the category award winners: Talent, Top Promotions, Top Fundraising, Best International Costume, Swimsuit and People's Choice. Ziyah Karmali won People's Choice, yet due to what organizers called an "oversight," Ziyah was denied to stand among her peers, and another girl was called up instead. Immediately after the pageant, President and CEO, Katherine Grefner, privately recognized the oversight to Ziyah and her family but no public announcement has been made. When questioned, the auditor (a woman identifying herself only as Christine) refused to comment. Ron Wear, Mr. World Canada 2010 and judge for the competition, said he was "shocked" and described Ziyah as a "top contender." To add insult to injury, the plaque awarded to Ziyah for being the 'People's Choice' was misspelled to read 'Peopls Choice' and at a small ceremony conclusion ceremony organized afterward by Upstage This! Productions (to give the awards to the winners) the oversight was not disclosed by pageant organizers to those in attendance. INSTEAD this disrespect was brought to the audiences attention by the pageant host, Tanya Memme (who felt that this was an "injustice"), and Ziyah's supporters. Katherine Grefner apologized again after the ceremony, in private, for not recognizing the matter. No resolution or public announcement to the matter has yet been made and the organization has since tried to distance itself from Ziyah. -------------------------- A pageant of this caliber and size should not be allowed to sweep their wrong-doings 'under the rug.' Pageants are notorious for claims of rigging and scamming - when they try to hide the truth and act unjustly they show just how seedy they REALLY are. SIGN THIS PETITION TO SUPPORT ZIYAH AND DEMAND THAT A PUBLIC APOLOGY AND ACKNOWLEDGMENT BE MADE BY PAGEANT ORGANIZERS. Katherine Grefner [email protected] Media Liason: Hayley Johnson [email protected] Program Coordinator: Karl McPherson [email protected]

Updates

May 13, 2010

The momentum behind this is proof that Upstage This! Productions cannot just hide their incompetence behind closed doors. Katherine Grefner and her team need to stop burying this injustice and finally face the consequences of their pathetic mismanagement.

Reached 100 supporters

May 13, 2010

6 Comments

D
David Rogers
16 years ago Featured

FIX THIS. She won the award fair and square. An oversight is not an excuse for ruining someones experience.

M
Mike Saunders
16 years ago Featured

Total incompetence. If you cant run a pageant right you shouldnt be doing it at all.

C
Chloe Farah
16 years ago Featured

Wow. Peopls Choice? Really?? Cant even get the plaque right. Ziyah deserved better than this amateur hour.

R
Robert Lane
16 years ago Featured

They need to do the right thing and own up to their mistake publicly. Leaving it in the dark makes them look worse.

J
Jessica May
16 years ago Featured

Poor girl worked so hard for that spot and they just pushed her aside like it was nothing. Disgusting behavior from the organizers.

S
Sarah Yamamoto
16 years ago Featured

How embarrassing for them. Spelling the award wrong is just sloppy on top of being completely unfair. Ziyah deserves a real apology.

Help this petition grow

Share it with friends to help reach 250 signatures.

Sign Petition

We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.

or sign with Email

Add a comment?

Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.

By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Share Petition

Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact

Copy link or share directly

Instagram
QR Code