The signatories to this letter come from many different political orientations, but this is a shameful moment in the history of the Melbourne Jewish community that demands a united response.
Several hundred people attended a meeting organised by the so-called ‘Australian Jewish Association’ at South Caulfield Hebrew Congregation on Sunday night, 11 September 2017 turned up to hear Mark Durie. He is not a specialist in Islam or contemporary problems in the Muslim world, but an Anglican priest, linguist and autodidact. He argues for a literalist interpretation of Islam and Islamic culture and history to demonstrate the inherent violence and intolerance of Islam, and by implication, the treachery of all Muslims.This is Islamophobia.
Durie is also closely allied to the QSociety, a hate group, as well as Halal Choices, which believes that halal food labelling is also part of a conspiracy. The QSociety also tried to prevent a small group of Bangladeshi and Indian taxi drivers meeting for weekly prayer in a community house in St Kilda some years ago. This is OneNation stuff, and part of the agenda of other virulent, nationalist and even Antisemitic organisations in this country.
In Durie's eyes, Muslims are also engaged in deception and subterfuge whatever conciliatory words are said. Of course, the claim is made such words are not anti- Muslim, just anti-Islam. Does this sound familiar? It's exactly the same as the theological Antisemitism beloved of many Christian scholars in the past when both the Hebrew Bible and Talmud were poured over to prove how evil Jews were.
Regrettably, despite Beth Weizmann, the Zionist Federation and even Mizrachi synagogue came to their senses about hosting such a meeting, realizing that it sent all the wrong messages in a diverse community. However, the South Caulfield Synagogue leadership appears quite proud of its support for the Australian Jewish Association and Mark Durie.
This is not a free speech issue. Durie and the
Jewish right can say or publish what they want when they want. But feeding ill-informed garbage to people
who have deep anxieties, as we all do, about terrorism is another matter and
should not receive institutional support from a synagogue.
The organised and intolerant,
baiting Jewish right has found a spiritual home.
Updates
September 12, 2017
The response to this petition proves that our community rejects the hate spread by the Australian Jewish Association. Post this link on your Facebook feed and email your local representative to demand they denounce these views. We have the momentum now so we must keep the pressure on.
12 Comments
While the wording may not be accurate (bigotry might have been a better word), I absolutely support the intent of this petition.
Wonder if this talk has contravened Section 18C of the racial discrimination act
Jews should know better
Larry Stillman, I consider it an honour to be vilified and lied about for calling out antisemitism.
Please note that my suburb is Alphington not Toorak.
The repeated command is to escape our bubbles of like-thinkers and to love, not merely tolerate, those who appear at first as strangers. We have been strangers ourselves, many times.
No racism policy
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via . Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Copy link or share directly
The signatories to this letter come from many different political orientations, but this is a shameful moment in the history of the Melbourne Jewish community that demands a united response.
Several hundred people attended a meeting organised by the so-called ‘Australian Jewish Association’ at South Caulfield Hebrew Congregation on Sunday night, 11 September 2017 turned up to hear Mark Durie. He is not a specialist in Islam or contemporary problems in the Muslim world, but an Anglican priest, linguist and autodidact. He argues for a literalist interpretation of Islam and Islamic culture and history to demonstrate the inherent violence and intolerance of Islam, and by implication, the treachery of all Muslims.This is Islamophobia.
Durie is also closely allied to the QSociety, a hate group, as well as Halal Choices, which believes that halal food labelling is also part of a conspiracy. The QSociety also tried to prevent a small group of Bangladeshi and Indian taxi drivers meeting for weekly prayer in a community house in St Kilda some years ago. This is OneNation stuff, and part of the agenda of other virulent, nationalist and even Antisemitic organisations in this country.
In Durie's eyes, Muslims are also engaged in deception and subterfuge whatever conciliatory words are said. Of course, the claim is made such words are not anti- Muslim, just anti-Islam. Does this sound familiar? It's exactly the same as the theological Antisemitism beloved of many Christian scholars in the past when both the Hebrew Bible and Talmud were poured over to prove how evil Jews were.
Regrettably, despite Beth Weizmann, the Zionist Federation and even Mizrachi synagogue came to their senses about hosting such a meeting, realizing that it sent all the wrong messages in a diverse community. However, the South Caulfield Synagogue leadership appears quite proud of its support for the Australian Jewish Association and Mark Durie.
This is not a free speech issue. Durie and the
Jewish right can say or publish what they want when they want. But feeding ill-informed garbage to people
who have deep anxieties, as we all do, about terrorism is another matter and
should not receive institutional support from a synagogue.
The organised and intolerant,
baiting Jewish right has found a spiritual home.
Updates
September 12, 2017
The response to this petition proves that our community rejects the hate spread by the Australian Jewish Association. Post this link on your Facebook feed and email your local representative to demand they denounce these views. We have the momentum now so we must keep the pressure on.
12 Comments
It is appalling that this has any support in our community. Let's make it irrelevant by standing together against hatred.
While the wording may not be accurate (bigotry might have been a better word), I absolutely support the intent of this petition.
Wonder if this talk has contravened Section 18C of the racial discrimination act
Jews should know better
Larry Stillman, I consider it an honour to be vilified and lied about for calling out antisemitism.
Please note that my suburb is Alphington not Toorak.
The repeated command is to escape our bubbles of like-thinkers and to love, not merely tolerate, those who appear at first as strangers. We have been strangers ourselves, many times.
No racism policy
Help this petition grow
Share it with friends to help reach 50 signatures.
Sign Petition
We never post to your account. Social sign-in is used only to verify your signature.
Add a comment?
Your signature will be added via .
Tell others why you're signing — it's optional.
Signing with Google or Facebook verifies your signature instantly — no email needed.
By signing, you accept iPetitions Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Share Petition
Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact
Petitions like this
Other petitions you might want to support
Scan to share
Anyone who scans this can sign the petition.
It is appalling that this has any support in our community. Let's make it irrelevant by standing together against hatred.