Skip to main content

Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.

Get rid of Nicole as a judge on X-Factor

Get rid of Nicole as a judge on X-Factor

Closed — 61 supporters Verified

Final supporters

S
srwykb
T
terrie
J
Jakayla
C
Cayle
L
lisa w.
R
Rob
S
Someone
J
Julian B.
J
Jayan
A
Anisha
+51 more
Started by Anonymous 14 years, 9 months ago
After tonight it is clear there is absolutely no point in having Nicole as a judge on X-Factor since she doesn't judge. She's kept Marcus around for 3 weeks too long, and for what? For him just to get voted off next week, he clearly has no shot in winning. Instead of doing what she is paid to do (judge) she just whines and chickens out and sends Rachel home after she clearly out sung Marcus ( as she always has ). Nicole you sent home Drew because her save me song wasn't good but you couldn't send Marcus home?! Rachel's save me song was one of the best performances I've seen on the show! Nicolee is a waste of space on the show and she's really annoying. Always talking about herself , crying, talking too much, dancing stupidly, always trying to talk crap about Simon, just stop and go watch X- Factor at home where you should be watching it. She hates Simon and bases her comments and decisions on that which is wrong and ridiculous. She sent home drew in spite of Simon, so did Paula and LA. Simon get some judges who don't feel threatened by you and are able to judge well!  Simon, please get rid of her and you can get rid of LA Reid, Paula, & Steve the host while you're at it. The only one who should come back next season is you Simon, and maybe Paula. LA Reid is doing everything in spite of Simon and judges harshly on his contestants, when he knows everyone is better than his boys. He's so full of it and way too biased. Let's improve for next season Simon! Sincerely, the fans.

Updates

December 9, 2011

im still getting messages from people who watched the latest episode and honestly im just as frustrated as all of you. watching the show feels like a chore now because the judging is so biased it ruins the whole thing. thanks for sticking with me while we wait for this to finally change.

December 9, 2011

wow i cant believe how much this has taken off. its honestly wild to see so many people who agree that we need a serious shakeup on the judging panel.

6 Comments

D
Dave Bell
14 years ago Featured

NICOLE NEEDS TO GO!!!!

S
Sarah Doyle
14 years ago Featured

Nicole is the worst judge they have ever had. She is so biased and honestly just annoying to listen to. Bring back someone who actually knows how to judge talent.

K
Kevin Nash
14 years ago Featured

Can we just get a fresh start with the panel next year? Its getting unwatchable.

J
Jessica Garcia
14 years ago Featured

Totally agree. Rachel should still be there. Nicole is just playing favorites and it is super obvious to everyone watching.

B
Brenda Dixon
14 years ago Featured

I stopped watching because of her. She has no idea what shes doing and her personal vendetta against Simon is childish. Get new judges for next season.

M
Mike Hunt
14 years ago Featured

Get rid of her already. She just sits there crying and making it all about herself. Ruining the whole show.