Skip to main content

Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.

Test expectations and marking rubric on tests

Test expectations and marking rubric on tests

Closed — 31 supporters Verified

Final supporters

S
Someone
S
Someone
S
Someone
B
Brandie M.
S
Someone
S
Someone
S
Someone
F
Farzan D.
M
Mimi L.
S
Someone
+21 more
Started by Anonymous 13 years ago
Based on the mid-term review and the low average of the Rx2013 class, it appears that most students did not achieve a good grade because of the vague mark break down of questions. As an example, when a professor asks "What therapy would you change and why?" and the question is out of 2 marks, it is unclear how many marks are allocated to therapy selection and how many are allocated to the explanation. Another example is justifying a treatment based on available evidence. If the question is out of 4 marks it is unclear how many marks are allocated to describing 1) strengths 2) weaknesses and 3) providing a bottom line. It would be ideal to phrase questions the following way (given a hypothetical case question): Current way: What is the drug therapy problem and how would you treat it? [4 marks] Preferred way: What is the drug therapy problem [1 mark]? What therapy change would you make [1 mark]? Explain why you would exclude other treatments [1 mark]? Outline the monitoring parameters for your chosen treatment [1 mark]. A similar mark break down would greatly facilitate focused answers under a time pressure on tests/exams. We would greatly appreciate that consideration be given to writing test questions this way.

Updates

July 25, 2013

I am currently gathering feedback from students to present a consolidated report to the department head. Post this petition link on your class Facebook group to ensure our request reaches the faculty review committee before they finalize the next exam format.

July 25, 2013

The momentum behind this plea for clarity proves that we all share the same struggle with these vague exams. Post the link on your course Facebook page today to keep the pressure on the department. Email your section instructor and ask them to adopt these clear marking standards for the remaining tests.

3 Comments

J
Jessica Marshall
12 years ago Featured

About time someone said something. So tired of losing points just because the question was poorly written.

M
Mike Webb
13 years ago Featured

Exactly. The vague grading makes it way harder than it needs to be. Make the rubrics clear so we can actually show what we know.

S
Sarah McBride
13 years ago Featured

This is so true. Trying to guess what the prof wants for marks when you only have 30 seconds left is impossible. Please change this.

Share Petition

Don't stop at signing, share the petition link with friends to multiply our impact

Copy link or share directly

Instagram
QR Code