Willie Collum should make decisions on what he see's, whilst he appears to make decision on what he thinks has happened. I cannot even consider him incompetent as that should balance fairly on both teams, but his one-sided view of games would infer that he is not incompetent but indeed biased which far worse than being incompetent. The sad fact that this is replicated at SPFL level with his continued appointments at "key" games. It's a sad state for Scottish football that it is governed and refereed in such a manor.
E
Emma Smith
10 years ago
Total disgrace of a clown!! SFA really need to do something but we know they wont because they all for celtic and they dont like the fact that there is still a challenge on in the premiership without rangers
N
neil macdonald
10 years ago
Cant believe he is a referee in the spl with all the mistakes he has and for him going to the euros is an embrassment
A
Alan Thomson
10 years ago
His decisions on key decisions are not up to the required standard
A
Adam Macdonald
10 years ago
An absolute joke of a ref.
L
Lee Greenhowe
10 years ago
The man is ruining good games of football
L
Lynn Ritchie
10 years ago
Decisions are baffling
J
John bruce
10 years ago
Hopeless ref.
J
Jim Sutherland
10 years ago
Terrible decision maker
K
Kieran innes
10 years ago
Should never be allowed to referee again
I
Ian Stephen
10 years ago
Worst ref ever
C
Chris Milne
10 years ago
Terrible referee
A
Anonymous
10 years ago
Time for him to hang up the cards like!
G
Graham Cox
10 years ago
Gets the big decisions wrong too many times
K
Kevin McLeod
10 years ago
Incompetent or biased. Either way, far too many questionable decisions to be ref'ing at Premiership level.
Not fit to referee at top level.
Willie Collum should make decisions on what he see's, whilst he appears to make decision on what he thinks has happened. I cannot even consider him incompetent as that should balance fairly on both teams, but his one-sided view of games would infer that he is not incompetent but indeed biased which far worse than being incompetent. The sad fact that this is replicated at SPFL level with his continued appointments at "key" games. It's a sad state for Scottish football that it is governed and refereed in such a manor.
Total disgrace of a clown!! SFA really need to do something but we know they wont because they all for celtic and they dont like the fact that there is still a challenge on in the premiership without rangers
Cant believe he is a referee in the spl with all the mistakes he has and for him going to the euros is an embrassment
His decisions on key decisions are not up to the required standard
An absolute joke of a ref.
The man is ruining good games of football
Decisions are baffling
Hopeless ref.
Terrible decision maker
Should never be allowed to referee again
Worst ref ever
Terrible referee
Time for him to hang up the cards like!
Gets the big decisions wrong too many times
Incompetent or biased. Either way, far too many questionable decisions to be ref'ing at Premiership level.
Completely incompetent
Below average ref. Must be removed.
Absolutely the worst referee by miles
boys a fudd.