Recently, Twitter has been arbitrarily banning women for voicing concerns
about the impact of self-identification (i.e. the notion that self-identifying
as a woman is sufficient for *being* a woman) upon women, and in particular,
concerns about the impact upon women's spaces (e.g. refuges,
rape
crisis centres, lesbian
events), women's sports given the physical advantages a male physique
naturally confers, and the rights of women to speak freely in general
without professional
and personal
recriminations. We unapologetically believe that:
TRANS WOMEN ARE BIOLOGICAL MEN
We call upon Twitter to allow that women be able to state material reality
without being cut off from their social and professional networks.
Specifically, we call upon Twitter to review the bans of, and reinstate:
1. Alessandra
Asteriti (@AlessandraAster) who was banned for stating that in 2015,
300,000 women around the world died in childbirth, and that as such, it is
deeply unethical to consider womb transplantation for transwomen - NOW UNBANNED!
2. Jo
Bartosch (@CriticalSisters) who was banned for objecting to feminists being
compared to Nazi's.
3. Jane
Callahan (@cyberfrontier) who was banned for stating that lesbians are
"same sex attracted adult human females" (hence, a transwoman cannot
be a lesbian).
4. 'ClassyKassy'
(@Kassandra50) who was banned for stating that Morgane Oger was born a man and
objecting to their on-line behaviour.
5. Claire
Graham (@MRKHvoice) who was banned for objecting to transactivists
weaponizing intersex conditions for political purposes.
6. Dr
Alicia Hendley (@aliciaMHendley) who was banned for objecting to
Jessica Yaniv suing sixteen women for refusing to wax 'her' scrotum.
7. Sarah
McGurk (@SCMcG) who is presently banned for asking for a definition of
woman, pointing out that there are no significant differences between male and
female brains, and that women prisoners should not be made even more vulnerable
by being housed with biological men.
8. Dr
Louise Moody (@drlouiseJMoody) who was banned for joking to a friend that
she was going to "literally kill her" for making a joke about Dr
Moody's lack of culinary skills - NOW UNBANNED!
9. Meghan
Murphy (@MeghanEMurphy) who was banned for referring to Jessica Yaniv as
'he' - a pronoun used by Yaniv himself and a description that was not, at the
time of posting, considered to constitute 'misgendering' according to Twitter
rules.
10. Pilgrim
Tucker (@PilgrimTucker) who was banned for factually stating that, since
rape requires a penis, the only women rapists can be transwomen.
IT IS UNCLEAR HOW THE ABOVE WOMEN HAVE VIOLATED TWITTER RULES
In addition, we call upon Twitter to stop requesting that people delete
factual tweets, such as Bea
Jaspert who was banned for twelve hours for stating that most killers are
male and Dr
Lesley Semmens who was banned until she deleted a tweet asking how police
finding male DNA at a crime scene are supposed to know whether they "are
looking for a man or self-identified woman."
It is worth noting that, under the Equality Act 2010, sex is a protected characteristic and Twitter (UK) in incorrectly listing gender in their conduct policy, is in ignorance of U.K law. It is this false equivocation of sex with gender that is ostensibly allowing Twitter to ban women under 'gender identity' rules when they are the protected class.
To protect the interests and rights of women as a sex-class, we must be able
to talk freely about issues that affect us and not be compelled to revise
perfectly intelligible terms such as 'woman' or 'lesbian'. And Twitter being
the 'town square' of the internet should be one such place where we can do just
that.
It seems that rules designed to protect are being used as censorship of women who are raising safeguarding concerns. Men who say the same things are not suspended. In addition, dangerous individuals are left to wish violence on women without any repercussions.