I would like to do away with cycle classes keeping a student off of Honor Roll or Principal’s List, which they can in my school. Cycle classes consist of gym, health, woodshop, art, music, computers/keyboarding, Cooking, sewing, and Spanish. Right now, if a student gets all A’s but a C in one of said cycles, they are kept off of the Principal’s List and even Honor Roll. This is unfair to the students and needs to be resolved. The only exception that I would make is if a student doesn’t pass health, music, or Spanish, (academic classes), then they are still off of the Honor’s Lists. I know several very smart, all A’s students who are lousy sewers, woodworkers, and athletes. It is hard for them to achieve a passing grade, especially an A if they are going for Principal’s List. Some people just don't possess a skill necessary to pass the hands-on classes and we shouldn’t punish them for that. The reason I make an exception for health, music, and Spanish is because they are classes where if you study and do homework, you pass. They are on the same level as math, language arts, science, and social studies/civics. The other classes require skill and hand-eye coordination. In woodshop, if you drill a hole wrong, your project is messed up and a domino reaction occurs, causing you to lose points. In sewing, if you sew the hems incorrectly, you lose points. If you aren’t creative enough in art, you won’t do very well. And in any classes with large projects (woodshop and sewing), you have to be good with time management, which many students aren’t.
My point is that Principal’s List and Honor Roll should only be determined by academic grades, not hands-on ones. I am confident that you will agree based on the information stated above and will sign my petition. Thank you!
I have been reading your messages about how frustrating these grade policies are and it is clear that many students are feeling discouraged by the current system. Your experiences are the engine behind this movement because you are the ones pointing out how these standards fail to account for different talents. I truly never thought so many people would resonate with this perspective so quickly.
3 Comments
M
Michelle Richards
17 years ago
Featured
My son is a straight A student in every real subject but art is killing his gpa. It makes no sense to punish kids for not being born artists.
S
Sarah Hall
17 years ago
Featured
So unfair! I missed honor roll last year because of a grade in sewing. sewing has nothing to do with how well I do in math or english.
K
Kevin Knight
17 years ago
Featured
Totally agree. Gym and woodshop are electives for a reason. Keep it to academics!
Share this petition
Share this petition to help it reach more people.
Your share link
Couldn't copy automatically. Long-press to copy:
Share directly
Status: Closed — this petition is no longer accepting signatures.
I would like to do away with cycle classes keeping a student off of Honor Roll or Principal’s List, which they can in my school. Cycle classes consist of gym, health, woodshop, art, music, computers/keyboarding, Cooking, sewing, and Spanish. Right now, if a student gets all A’s but a C in one of said cycles, they are kept off of the Principal’s List and even Honor Roll. This is unfair to the students and needs to be resolved. The only exception that I would make is if a student doesn’t pass health, music, or Spanish, (academic classes), then they are still off of the Honor’s Lists. I know several very smart, all A’s students who are lousy sewers, woodworkers, and athletes. It is hard for them to achieve a passing grade, especially an A if they are going for Principal’s List. Some people just don't possess a skill necessary to pass the hands-on classes and we shouldn’t punish them for that. The reason I make an exception for health, music, and Spanish is because they are classes where if you study and do homework, you pass. They are on the same level as math, language arts, science, and social studies/civics. The other classes require skill and hand-eye coordination. In woodshop, if you drill a hole wrong, your project is messed up and a domino reaction occurs, causing you to lose points. In sewing, if you sew the hems incorrectly, you lose points. If you aren’t creative enough in art, you won’t do very well. And in any classes with large projects (woodshop and sewing), you have to be good with time management, which many students aren’t.
My point is that Principal’s List and Honor Roll should only be determined by academic grades, not hands-on ones. I am confident that you will agree based on the information stated above and will sign my petition. Thank you!
I have been reading your messages about how frustrating these grade policies are and it is clear that many students are feeling discouraged by the current system. Your experiences are the engine behind this movement because you are the ones pointing out how these standards fail to account for different talents. I truly never thought so many people would resonate with this perspective so quickly.
3 Comments
M
Michelle Richards
17 years ago
Featured
My son is a straight A student in every real subject but art is killing his gpa. It makes no sense to punish kids for not being born artists.
S
Sarah Hall
17 years ago
Featured
So unfair! I missed honor roll last year because of a grade in sewing. sewing has nothing to do with how well I do in math or english.
K
Kevin Knight
17 years ago
Featured
Totally agree. Gym and woodshop are electives for a reason. Keep it to academics!
My son is a straight A student in every real subject but art is killing his gpa. It makes no sense to punish kids for not being born artists.