Remove "Bicycles Prohibited" Signs from Hidden River Trail
193 Comments
J
Jim Verheul
I ride my bike down this road at 25mph, the speed limit for all vehicles, including mine. Why am I being prohibited? This is not legal. According to Common law and backed by Civil law (numerous federal court cases). Bicycles are a Right to Travel vehicle. That means that riders have a Right to Travel on public roadways and it is illegal to prevent them from doing so.
A Motor Vehicle is by legal definition a vehicle operated for hire and as such, has no such protection. Any lawyer purporting to defend cyclists should know this issue intimately. Defending cyclists' right to travel was the primary reason the (old) American Wheelmen was formed. Unfortunately rights are no longer taught or learned so almost no cyclist bothers to know this anymore. If the road is a private road (one of the local bridges purportedly is but receives public funds so really isn't anymore) then the rights do not apply. Interstates are military highways and are not public roads, for instance...
A
Anonymous
"Share the road" applies to all roads, hidden river is not exempt.
T
Tammie Gade
Please allow bicycles.
J
John Wade
There's no need for this restriction. Please allow bicycles.
J
Jerry Swink
Manatee County nor any other governmental entity does not get to pick and choose what applicable regulations it chooses to adhere to. The law is plain in that bicycles have a lawful right of usage.
G
George Campbell
Share The Road. We need more bike lanes to make the car drivers happy so start adding some dollars to the budget for upgrades in Bradenton.
P
Paul Diczok
Please consider this.
M
Mark Lewis
We should encourage those in Lakewood Ranch to exercise and use forms of transportation that are less polluting, not the other way around. I don't believe you can legally ban bicycles either, as they are classified as a vehicle.
M
Mike Krajewski
This sign needs to come down and no such sign should be allowed on public roads. Bicycles are not only for recreation but also a form of healthy and environmentally friendly transportation.
T
Tom Egan
This road is an important connector for cycling in Lakewood Ranch. Please consider allowing cyclists the use of this road. Thank you.
J
Jesse rutherford
According to the signage, school buses, trash trucks, and most landscape trucks can not use that road either!
K
karen Lucas
Please remove these signs.
M
Michelle belliveau
Please open the trail up
N
Nancy Groff
anything for my friends!
V
Village Idiots Cycling Club
· petition starter
Manatee County is placing themselves in a position of liability. By banning the use of this "safe" road in comparison to SR70 or University Parkway one could make a case that in the event of an accident on one of the other two roads, Manatee County could be held liable for restricting this roadway. Furthermore the sidewalk is in no condition to be ridden on. Further liability.
It's clear that the residents of Lakewood ranch are asking for a change. The county has yet to provide any reason for the ban other than "it was on the plans". Sounds a lot like "I was just following orders". And as we know, that's a poor excuse.
J
Jerry Johnson
As there are no neighborhoods along this road, I think the community would benefit more if this road were changed to a bicycles only road and closed to motor vehicles. Let's make this an area where people and bikes are welcomed!
R
Roy bentley
Ridiculous!
J
Jon Lang
This is highly traveled by bicycles, with nothing but advantages as a result. Please take down signs to ensure the trail is enjoyed by all human-powered travelers.
C
Court Nederveld
The cost of keeping this sign up in terms of constant police arrests of hundreds of cyclists, seem far higher than to stop treating cyclists as second class citizens.
I ride my bike down this road at 25mph, the speed limit for all vehicles, including mine. Why am I being prohibited? This is not legal. According to Common law and backed by Civil law (numerous federal court cases). Bicycles are a Right to Travel vehicle. That means that riders have a Right to Travel on public roadways and it is illegal to prevent them from doing so. A Motor Vehicle is by legal definition a vehicle operated for hire and as such, has no such protection. Any lawyer purporting to defend cyclists should know this issue intimately. Defending cyclists' right to travel was the primary reason the (old) American Wheelmen was formed. Unfortunately rights are no longer taught or learned so almost no cyclist bothers to know this anymore. If the road is a private road (one of the local bridges purportedly is but receives public funds so really isn't anymore) then the rights do not apply. Interstates are military highways and are not public roads, for instance...
"Share the road" applies to all roads, hidden river is not exempt.
Please allow bicycles.
There's no need for this restriction. Please allow bicycles.
Manatee County nor any other governmental entity does not get to pick and choose what applicable regulations it chooses to adhere to. The law is plain in that bicycles have a lawful right of usage.
Share The Road. We need more bike lanes to make the car drivers happy so start adding some dollars to the budget for upgrades in Bradenton.
Please consider this.
We should encourage those in Lakewood Ranch to exercise and use forms of transportation that are less polluting, not the other way around. I don't believe you can legally ban bicycles either, as they are classified as a vehicle.
This sign needs to come down and no such sign should be allowed on public roads. Bicycles are not only for recreation but also a form of healthy and environmentally friendly transportation.
This road is an important connector for cycling in Lakewood Ranch. Please consider allowing cyclists the use of this road. Thank you.
According to the signage, school buses, trash trucks, and most landscape trucks can not use that road either!
Please remove these signs.
Please open the trail up
anything for my friends!
Manatee County is placing themselves in a position of liability. By banning the use of this "safe" road in comparison to SR70 or University Parkway one could make a case that in the event of an accident on one of the other two roads, Manatee County could be held liable for restricting this roadway. Furthermore the sidewalk is in no condition to be ridden on. Further liability. It's clear that the residents of Lakewood ranch are asking for a change. The county has yet to provide any reason for the ban other than "it was on the plans". Sounds a lot like "I was just following orders". And as we know, that's a poor excuse.
As there are no neighborhoods along this road, I think the community would benefit more if this road were changed to a bicycles only road and closed to motor vehicles. Let's make this an area where people and bikes are welcomed!
Ridiculous!
This is highly traveled by bicycles, with nothing but advantages as a result. Please take down signs to ensure the trail is enjoyed by all human-powered travelers.
The cost of keeping this sign up in terms of constant police arrests of hundreds of cyclists, seem far higher than to stop treating cyclists as second class citizens.
bikes should be okay