ok so what area is ok in your books to be mined. ...... and what makes the one area more important than another. Surely to build you need building sand. So then one mines where there are deposits of building sand. Not all sand is equal. would you like to buy a house built with inferior quality sand. Or even better lets stop building infrastructure in South Africa completely
J
Jean-Pierre Vyncke
think again!
D
Derryn Holliday
Absolute madness in an ecologically sensitive and brilliant wine region!
R
Rui Branco
Fighting for a Fantastic Cause. #protectpaardeberg
K
Keith Grainger
Sandmining in this area will lead to economic decline and environmental destruction.
P
Pyves Metayer
Protect the Paardeberg against Sandpits
M
Mpho Koning
Lets consider the above statement. If we quantify the value of the mining industry and the building industry which relies on building sand etc, compared to the wine industry and its benefits and social harms. Drunken drivers, alcohol abuse etc. Maybe a few less drunken tourists on our roads would not be a bad thing.
The other 2 industries provide full time employment where as the wine industry is full of super rich landowners who make use of seasonal workers.
C
Chris Erasmus
I agree!!
M
MARK SAVAGE
The industrial vandalism of unique agricultrural resources must be resisted
vigourously. Short term financial benefits are less important than longterm sustainable projects and sites of a uniquely valuable heritage
J
Jonathan Beale
Please reconsider the decision and maintain Swartland as one of the worlds most exciting wine regions.
C
Carey Christie
#findsomeothersand
M
Mpho Koning
Dear Roy Richards, I am sure that Mr Sadie will still happily supply you with his wonderful wines even if mining takes place in the Paardenberg. If I am not mistaken he buys in grapes from various farms who have old vineyards and produces wines that sell for as much as R750 per bottle. Not something that the normal working class south African can even afford . If you consider that minimum wage in SA is about R2800 pm, he would pay a worker 3.7 bottles a month. Surely affordable building material, is of far more relevance to the average South African (living in shacks) than your elitist luxury products.
G
Geert Jan Cazemier
No sandmining plz
C
Christina Rasmussen
This should not be allowed to happen :(
N
Norman Collins
We need to protect some of the best wines in South Africa. What is the wind blowen sand going to do to these old vineyards producing great wine.
T
Tawanda Marume
Stop destroying agricultural land for small returns.
E
Ester Brand
The revival of the Swartland Wine Region has been nothing short of miraculous, with sustainable and honourable wine making methods, and to see it disappear this way would be a sad misjudgement.
J
Jaap-Henk Koelewijn
No to sandmining Save the vineyards!
S
Stefan Berg
Do not do this! Think about all the children who's heritage you destroy
S
Schalk Opperman
Absolutely non negotiable. No mining of any sort on this precious peace of earth. Agriculture creates jobs. Mining only destroys.
ok so what area is ok in your books to be mined. ...... and what makes the one area more important than another. Surely to build you need building sand. So then one mines where there are deposits of building sand. Not all sand is equal. would you like to buy a house built with inferior quality sand. Or even better lets stop building infrastructure in South Africa completely
think again!
Absolute madness in an ecologically sensitive and brilliant wine region!
Fighting for a Fantastic Cause. #protectpaardeberg
Sandmining in this area will lead to economic decline and environmental destruction.
Protect the Paardeberg against Sandpits
Lets consider the above statement. If we quantify the value of the mining industry and the building industry which relies on building sand etc, compared to the wine industry and its benefits and social harms. Drunken drivers, alcohol abuse etc. Maybe a few less drunken tourists on our roads would not be a bad thing. The other 2 industries provide full time employment where as the wine industry is full of super rich landowners who make use of seasonal workers.
I agree!!
The industrial vandalism of unique agricultrural resources must be resisted vigourously. Short term financial benefits are less important than longterm sustainable projects and sites of a uniquely valuable heritage
Please reconsider the decision and maintain Swartland as one of the worlds most exciting wine regions.
#findsomeothersand
Dear Roy Richards, I am sure that Mr Sadie will still happily supply you with his wonderful wines even if mining takes place in the Paardenberg. If I am not mistaken he buys in grapes from various farms who have old vineyards and produces wines that sell for as much as R750 per bottle. Not something that the normal working class south African can even afford . If you consider that minimum wage in SA is about R2800 pm, he would pay a worker 3.7 bottles a month. Surely affordable building material, is of far more relevance to the average South African (living in shacks) than your elitist luxury products.
No sandmining plz
This should not be allowed to happen :(
We need to protect some of the best wines in South Africa. What is the wind blowen sand going to do to these old vineyards producing great wine.
Stop destroying agricultural land for small returns.
The revival of the Swartland Wine Region has been nothing short of miraculous, with sustainable and honourable wine making methods, and to see it disappear this way would be a sad misjudgement.
No to sandmining Save the vineyards!
Do not do this! Think about all the children who's heritage you destroy
Absolutely non negotiable. No mining of any sort on this precious peace of earth. Agriculture creates jobs. Mining only destroys.