Skip to main content

Protect the Paardeberg!

967 Comments

S
Suzy Digby-Smith

Please stop this desecration of these wine lands

V
Vanessa SKINNER

Themis is a Nono. We cannot allow this loss of our heritage.

C
Corlien Morris

STOP

S
Stephen Digby
Featured

Agricultural land for Agriculture please! Do NOT destroy what has recently become one of the world's best wine-growing areas, offering huge benefits to the SA economy, through the export of wine, the employment of thousands of workers, and in-bound tourism.

C
Craig Dennis

The Swartland region is possibly the most exciting wine growing region I. The world currently. It's potential has been developed over the last 20 years and at a point when it is about to really establish itself as a pre-eminent wine region, this mining approval would appear to be short sighted conservation vandalism of the most egregious nature. Chasing the fast buck whilst destroying something sustainable and growing seems preposterous.

M
Max Oldfield

A bloody disgrace

H
Heather Gould

No ways

E
Estelle Cooper

Nooooooooooooooo!

T
Timothy

We cannot afford to loose soil it is the foundation of all life

Z
Zaine Pritchard

Read and understand the facts please then make a fair assessment. It is about so much more and has dyer complications and a massive social impact for the exact reasons you mention.

M
Mpho Koning

Pristine by definition is natural unspoilt. Vineyards are not natural and the country side is definitely not unspoilt

C
Carol Buchan

What will be left when all the sand is gone? Short term gains. ..I wonder who is benefitting. This is a travesty and seems to be happening all over the country!

M
Mpho Koning

It is not just sand. Its building sand..... That's a big difference. Its like saying its only grapes. If farmers have already destroyed the fynbos and bio diversity ploughing up land etc. Surely the landscape is scared already. Its just a matter of opinion. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. For me seeing lovely natural habitats destroyed and line after line of vines planted is repulsive. One only has to see the huge dams being built to irrigate this alien plant. Run off water that could be feeding into rivers and dams. Maybe if there were less vineyards there would be water in our streams and dams. Have you considered the effect of run off water full of pesticides and chemicals. What effect does that have on the eco system. But the wine tastes GOOD LOL

T
TJ Botten

Do not destroy a pristine part of the country to line your own filthy pockets.

L
Lloyd Piater

the Paardeberg has more to offer The Swartland, Cape Town and South Africa by means of Tourism, farming, wine-making, geological studies. Sand mining will make a few rich immediately and ruin the area for the long term, putting many out of business and preventing others from benefitting year after year. It's a really bad idea.

M
Mpho Koning

maybe they should say where the mining will take place. Doubt its on the mountain. probably in the plains or valley

M
Mpho Koning

At least there is now discussion not emotional outrage. So lets me start off by assuming you are sitting at home in a brick built house, typing on your Eskom powered computer sipping on wine in JHB a city founded on gold mining. You drive a car that runs on petrol or diesel. All of which is possible because of mining and development. Now lets talk about your wonderful wine that was made from grapes grown on agricultural land. Pristine natural eco systems were destroyed to establish the vineyards. Wine is not food it does not feed the masses it is alcohol which these days even has a warning printed on the bottle about the dangers of the product. But vineyards are pretty so we forget the damage done to the environment. Farming for food security is important but wine is a luxury product with many many social problems from the abuse of alcohol. A sand mine might not be pretty but it does no more damage than agriculture. With a lot more social and economic benefits. From what I googled the top soil is removed and kept one side. Sand is mined and then the top soil is put back. If rehabilitation is done correctly then agriculture can continue. So maybe we should rather manage the mining process and benefit from it. Wine yards are pretty but not innocent. They destroy nature, use valuable water resources and are used to make alcohol not produce food. So maybe we should stop all activities in the Paardenberg that are detrimental to nature. No building no roads no farming. Totally unpractical but if food security was being threatened, by all means jump up and down.

K
Karl Nepgen

There is surely more than enough sand in the plains below Paardeberg.

L
Louise Linder

Please do not be sub moronic.

B
Barry Clinton

This should not be allowed to happen. Very short sighted by the authorities. Have they factored in how this will effect the areas tourism. I'm sure there are other more suitable areas to mine sand from.