To: Jennifer Niles, Deputy Mayor of Education ([email protected])
Cc: Councilmember David Grosso ([email protected]), Councilmember Mary Cheh ([email protected])
We District of Columbia residents urge Deputy Mayor of Education Jennifer
Niles to protect children from burns and heatstroke by immediately
implementing a provisional surface temperature policy for playgrounds and
synthetic turf fields.
We recommend using Brigham Young University’s standard of 120 °F as the
maximum allowable surface temperature. Further research may indicate a
lower maximum is safer, but getting any measure in place now is an improvement from
having no policy at all.
A provisional policy will not hinder the process of establishing a permanent
policy. It will, however, protect children. Handheld laser
thermometers are inexpensive and easy to obtain. Principals should be
responsible for ensuring that fields or playgrounds that exceed 120 degrees are
not to be in use.
It is not sufficient to say that DGS will work out a policy later, as even on
9/26/17 and 9/27/17, the brand new synthetic turf fields at Eaton and Janney
Elementary School both reached 140.5 degrees at 3 PM.
According to NIST, at 111 °F, humans begin to feel a burning pain, with first-degree burns
developing at 118 °F. At 131°F exposed skin develops second-degree
burns. At 140 °F skin develops third-degree burns and pain receptors
overload and become numb. At 162°F human tissue is destroyed on contact,
and damage is so extensive that there may not be any pain because of nerve
damage.
From Penn State, a detail of materials and temperatures. They state “BYU guideline: no use above 120° F
(49° C).”
This policy statement from American Academy of Pediatrics, notes
that children have a harder time acclimating to environmental changes. Their
higher body-surface to mass ratio makes them absorb more heat.
There is a whole host of health, safety and environmental issues, not to mention long-term budgetary issues associated with synthetic turf playgrounds and fields. At a minimum, no more should be installed, clear plans put in place to keep children as safe as possible on those existing, and plans put in place for replacing these with properly installed and drained wood chip play areas and grass fields. This is all do-able.